See all
44 photos

Castleton Grill

(Now Closed)

American Restaurant$$$$

Castleton, Indianapolis

Save

Castleton Grill

56 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Wendy ReedNovember 7, 2012
Been here 10+ times
My favorite place when I want to relax and have great food and friendly service . They use hickory wood to smoke with here so don't miss entrees that are from the wood oven. Best Brussels sprouts ever
Lindsey BrinkAugust 9, 2011
Amazing experience.. One I haven't had in a long time!! We have black and blue prime rib and beef manhattan!!! The price is cheap and quality was amazing definitely will come back on a regular basis
Dana ParkerAugust 10, 2015
Very cool local food discovery. Looks deceptively chain on the outside, but has great surprises like the Andouille potato cake from Smoking Goose
James RossFebruary 17, 2013
It's my first time here. The service is fair and the food was pretty good. The Beef Manhattan is simple but good. They use Philly sandwich beef for the meat which was kind of a turn off for me though.
Jared CookSeptember 7, 2015
Carne Asada sliders, 3 bucks each, to die for! Pulled pork with all the fixings.. 10 bucks... Amazing
New RadarMarch 11, 2012
Great hidden gem restaurant on the northside. Highly reccomend the prime rib sliders and prime rib. Northside Nights $30 special #win
Sydney ClarkAugust 31, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Get the signature Bloody Mary!! It a meal in its-self!! Plus the food is great and a great price!!
MelissaJanuary 1, 2011
fish&chips were excellent. burger was made to order and really good too. great service! would come back. breakfast menu looked good too
Rachel HernandezJanuary 19, 2013
If you have kids, check out the shelf by the fireplace. They have some board games stashed to the right!
Laura BaileyDecember 18, 2011
Great place for drinks and a meal! Prime rib is amazing and filling for a great price!
Wendy ReedMarch 3, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Half price bottle night for your wine on Sundays. Great deal! Wide selection.
ryan brewerApril 7, 2014
Been here 5+ times
half-price bottles of wine and live music on Sunday evenings all year round!
Wendy ReedJuly 11, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Always a delicious meal. The Mallory Salad with Salmon today was especially super!
Chuck CharlesApril 10, 2016
The atmosphere is great and they're portions are quite generous.
Amanda MoloneyJuly 28, 2012
Food was great! But just for the record- the torte is not a torte. Still yummy though!
DaShay HallJuly 6, 2013
Blackened Cod fish sandwich was the best sandwich I have ever had!!!! #SupportYourLocals #Bop
Adam BoeglinFebruary 12, 2012
The chicken strips are huge and delicious. You have to try them!
Ken ChiggesAugust 29, 2015
Tasted like the kitchen needed to be cleaned and the oil needs to be changed. Too bad because the menu looks like they are making an effort to be fresh and local.
Mick WellingMarch 17, 2013
Prime Rib was tasty, juicy. Mashed potatoes were filling.
Kristen FickDecember 22, 2013
Been here 10+ times
You HAVE to get the andouille potato cake as your side!
James DiesFebruary 17, 2013
Been here 10+ times
The chicken wrap is out of this world!
Jonathan RodgersFebruary 12, 2010
Had the prime rib last night. It was delicious. The Castleton Grill is big supporter of #shop local. I like their style.
Theodore HuffFebruary 26, 2012
Had the Philly - freaking huge! And reasonably priced at $9!
Jeffrey HoffmanAugust 28, 2013
Awesome, good food,good drinks. Great service
David GioeApril 6, 2014
Get the Peppercorn steak ribeye awesome
Jim MApril 20, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Try the house L.I. ice tea or a bloody Mary.
Michael TrentNovember 8, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Portions are very large here. Plan your order accordingly.
Jeffrey HoffmanMarch 7, 2014
Great food and drink 5 star eatery
Jessica StangApril 18, 2012
The brisket is amazing and their kids ricekrispie treat they can paint is adorable and tasty!
Wendy ReedMay 1, 2014
Been here 10+ times
House infused pineapple martini...oh yeahhhhh!
Hazel WalkerJune 2, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Try the Mallory salad with the grilled salmon
Julie SawyerNovember 22, 2011
Eat local, support Indy! Castleton non-chain-- a rarity along the strip.
Hand IndyJuly 1, 2010
Food is amazing... Good prices, great portions... Service need A LOT of work.
Quinn SOctober 27, 2015
Have the prime rib 🍖
Charley csChasManDecember 17, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Try the Rib Eye steak.
Patrick HarveyMarch 1, 2013
Top 10 bathrooms in the Indy area.
Lynette V.December 4, 2012
Delicious salmon/asparagus salad!
Rich PhelanDecember 11, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Best Beef Manhattan in town.
Roger WilliamsJanuary 15, 2012
The BBQ burger was really good.
Alisha DunnMarch 21, 2012
Beef manhattan like no other!
Heather KlepserJune 11, 2010
Been here 5+ times
All of the food is good, especially the beef manhattan!!
Matt CorleyNovember 7, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Best food in Indy, Yo!!
Courtney Rae PuckettDecember 2, 2012
Tim was great!
Tracy DAugust 18, 2011
Been here 5+ times
The Cobb salad is awesome!
Charles McWilliamsJanuary 14, 2011
The black bean soup is great!
LeighMarch 14, 2010
RECEIVED NO SERVICE HERE. We were seated, waited 5 min, no one even looked at our table. A larger party seated after us recieved immediate service. Sad, because we support local biz. FAIL.
Brooks BowdenApril 2, 2011
Prime rib here is great!!!
Morgan BucciconeMarch 23, 2012
Eddie burger was great...onion ring sucked.
Matt CorleyJanuary 8, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Do the Eddie!!
Paul LucasOctober 15, 2011
Mouthwash dispensers in the bathroom!

1 2

44 Photos

Castleton Grill

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Castleton Grill

Appears on 14 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.