See all
121 photos

Mama Corolla's Old Italian Restaurant

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Meridian Kessler, Indianapolis

Save

9.2^/10

187

ratings

Ranked #1 for Italian restaurants in Indianapolis
"rosemary chicken lasagna and the chicken parm"(5 Tips)
"Veal medallions was delicious !"(2 Tips)
"You must try the Mediterranean Pasta!"(2 Tips)
"Artichoke fritters are AMAZING!"(2 Tips)

46 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
veal medallion
artichoke fritters
asparagus patties
restaurants
bruschetta
spicy food
outdoor seating
good for groups
dinner
crowded
good for special occasions
parking
garlic cheese bread
misto
stuffed mushrooms
dresses
city
road
(14 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Steven CrawleyJune 12, 2016
When you go here get the Rosemary Chicken Lasagna, the Manicotti, and then some Cannolis. No matter what you get itll be fantastic. If you like Italian Food then your next stop should be Mama Corollas
SarahJanuary 22, 2020
Devour Indy brought me in for my 1st visit to Mama Carolla's. It felt like a classy place for a ladies night with friends, food was delicious and not too heavy, and dessert was a must (cannoli!)
Wesley KalataJune 14, 2014
We had the garlic cheese bread and the fried ravioli as starters, then we had manicotti and beef lasagna for our entree, and for dessert we had tiramisu and cannot, it was great I'd recommend it all.
Catrina SmytheSeptember 21, 2017
Top notch bartender & atmosphere. Server lacked in professionalism: kept my change, no wine refill-despite sitting empty until after dessert, several other minor errors, as well.
Tarang AnthwalDecember 14, 2015
I had the bruschetta and stuffed shrimp with goat cheese for starters. And roasted rosemary chicken. Yum, yum, yum!
Liz FayeJune 28, 2017
Very romantic setting. Affordable for a place where you can dress up! Shrimp scampi is delicious.
SunainaMay 12, 2015
Excellent Italian food. The flavor are amazing and the ambience transports you to a tiny village in Italy. Great date spot.
Ashley MillsSeptember 19, 2013
Amazing cuisine at decent prices. Only open for dinner, but oh so worth the wait. Get the crab cakes!
Ned MulliganOctober 30, 2011
Been here 5+ times
This has to be the best Italian restaurant in Indianapolis. Just make sure you get there before 630 or after 830 or you'll be waiting for awhile
Chris HarveyMarch 4, 2012
The best Italian restaurant in this city by far. Start with the bruschetta and try the rosemary chicken lasagna.
Brooke GNovember 3, 2011
Cant go wrong with the garlic bread! Its to die for! Its always fun to bring a handsome man along for the ride as well!!
Malynnda JohnsonDecember 22, 2018
Ravioli was Devine! And be sure to save room for the Tiramisu.
Say it in ShirtsJune 18, 2011
You must try the Mediterranean Pasta! You will love it! Mama Carolla's is one of the best places in Indy for Date Nights.
Carmen CliftMay 26, 2015
You can't go wrong with anything here. I love the classics - spaghetti or lasagna
Terri BrowningJanuary 3, 2016
This is a great restaurant! Everything I have tried is awesome!
Scott ByerlyJanuary 26, 2013
Watch out and make sure your entire party is present when you arrive. No call ahead seating or reservations taken. Their house policy is not to seat you until your entire party had arrived.
Teri LockwoodJune 18, 2016
Veal medallions was delicious ! Great outdoor dining area.
Natasha ShallonMay 31, 2016
Artichoke fritters are divine, beautiful patio, yummy sangria, slow service.
Ian PettyMarch 2, 2014
Garlic cheese bread: yes. Rosemary chicken lasagna: yes. Tiramisu: yes. Mama Corolla's: yes. Every time.
Candace NicholsonMay 12, 2012
Beautiful atmosphere. Great for a first date. Not too intimate, but not too crowded.
Andrew Robinson IIIMay 26, 2013
Both the rosemary chicken lasagna and the chicken parm were excellent!
Kris KringleFebruary 14, 2016
Total disappointment! Arrived a little before 5 and was told 45 minute wait. 1 1/2 later we were seated! My steak was almost uneatable Mentioned to server, nothing done. Not even an apology.
Francene CostelloJune 24, 2016
Everything is delicious and old fashioned Italian!
JTDecember 22, 2017
Very homey American Italian with yummy fresh bread
Stuart PeckJanuary 26, 2016
Most authentic Italian food in the city!
Cathy DuclosFebruary 5, 2011
Been here 5+ times
The Chicken Rigatoni is my favorite here! A little spice and some pacetta - who could ask for more?
Tepic ParksApril 17, 2011
The asparagus patties were amazing and the shrimp scampi has my mouth watering a day later.
Tracy GardnerFebruary 16, 2019
Artichoke fritters are AMAZING!
Eric LaineMay 25, 2011
Get the mussels....I don't care if you're hungry or not...you must get them.
Dana ParkerNovember 29, 2014
The good and the ambiance is fantastic
Vanessa JennetteApril 19, 2013
Do yourself a favor and order the crab stuffed mushroom appetizer!
Alex SegrestMarch 9, 2012
Misto Mare is the BEST! Mama Corolla's is by far the best place in Indy!
Jeremiah CosnerOctober 7, 2017
Must try to the spicy meatballs!!!
Stephen POctober 16, 2011
Been here 5+ times
asparagus patties and artichoke friters are fantastic appetizers.
Carla BoveeJanuary 16, 2016
The Mediterranean pasta was way better than the rosemary chicken lasagna in my opinion. Lived in Italy 5 yrs. The Italian wedding soup, and the Mediterranean chicken pasta.The crab stuffed mushroom :)
Scott TerrellJanuary 23, 2017
love it mamas special is it
James GrahamOctober 6, 2017
Atmosphere food service
Theresa GrantMarch 14, 2010
This place is phenominal. We came here just for dessert but everything here is amazing!
Kyle HodgesDecember 11, 2010
Authentic Italian cuisine. A must stop on Indy's culinary road.
Joseph LoriaFebruary 22, 2015
Rigatoni, all pastas
New RadarApril 17, 2013
Chicken Lasagna is a win!
David MOctober 31, 2010
Veal Medallions or Mama's Chicken Lasagna .... especially if its ur first time baby!
Rachel NealisJuly 17, 2011
Try the calamari! The sauce is magical!!!
Melissa BJanuary 26, 2013
They will not seat you until a full party is there.
Jessica RFebruary 22, 2012
Chicken parm is good. Tiramasu is bangin
Justin EllingwoodMay 25, 2010
you have to get the steamed mussels...they are unreal.

121 Photos

Mama Corolla's Old Italian Restaurant

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Mama Corolla's Old Italian Restaurant

Appears on 103 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.