Make My Cake

Dessert Shop$$$$

Central Harlem, New York

Save

Make My Cake

7.5^/10

ratings

Ranked #6 for dessert shops in Central Harlem
"Try the red velvet it's amazing..a slice is $5"(7 Tips)
"This place is great for any occasion."(2 Tips)
"Delicious cakes, try the red velvet/buttercream slice."(10 Tips)
"The strawberry cupcakes are the perfect treat."(2 Tips)

20 Tips and reviews

Filter:

red velvet desserts
cake
cupcakes
peach cobbler
French toast
cheesecake
muffins
pumpkin
German chocolate
Weight Watchers
butter cream
banana nut
(7 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Cheryl YBRJuly 25, 2010
Another Location - same good stuff! They make the best Buttercream cake I have every had. Love it! And their Red Velvet is to die for! Save you Weight Watcher flex points for this - it's worth it!
Dei WestOctober 4, 2015
Been here 25+ times
Muffins are delicious! My favorites are: French Toast, Banana Nut and Pumpkin.
Tiffanni JMay 24, 2012
Best cakes ever. I get all my daughters cakes for her birthday here. Yummy but pricy. Worth the money!
Brendan RogersAugust 15, 2013
Delicious cakes, try the red velvet/buttercream slice. Pricy, but worth it!!
IvyApril 21, 2013
Bought the red velvet cheesecake and devoured it within in minutes. Delicious!
Zubetei ZxxOctober 23, 2011
There are a load of better places in Harlem for red velvet...don't forget to check them out as well.
Brittney OJune 20, 2013
The other location has better service, presentation add selection of treats.
Dei WestOctober 4, 2015
Been here 25+ times
Really good peach cobbler!
Kashem MiahMay 8, 2010
Been here 5+ times
This place is great for any occasion. You can smell it from across the street. Red velvet is great.
TV Food MapsAugust 26, 2014
Check out Make My Cake as seen on Throwdown with Bobby Flay Read more
Joi-MarieDecember 11, 2012
The strawberry cupcakes are the perfect treat.
Ny WhitakerFebruary 1, 2016
Sweet potato cheese cake
Emmanuel PerezSeptember 21, 2015
RED VELVET EVERYTHING!!!!
LeAnnJuly 17, 2010
Try the red velvet it's amazing..a slice is $5
Emma A.July 13, 2013
Long UNNECESSARY waits. Overall cake is delicious ...
Miss SiaApril 7, 2013
"Service" is hit or miss. As are the cakes.
Sophia Del CidAugust 28, 2016
Service and cakes are so so.
Lee MelendezDecember 12, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Red velvet is the best eva......
Derek PennApril 15, 2010
Delicios cakes for any occasion
JessicaFebruary 20, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Yummy German chocolate cupcakes. Read more

16 Photos

Make My Cake

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Make My Cake

Appears on 32 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.