City Island Lobster House
Seafood Restaurant$$$$
City Island, Bronx
"Lobster was fresh and delicious."(22 Tips)
"Dungeness crab legs"(5 Tips)
"Good service, and funny waiter !"(4 Tips)
"Fresh shrimp, lobster, clams, and oysters are on the menu when coming..."(3 Tips)
57 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- lobster
- good for groups
- scenic views
- good for dates
- casual
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Tony XerriMay 18, 2019For 65$ you get a lobster, 4 king crab legs, 6 baked clams, 4 shrimp, waffle fries, and a big bowl of better. Oh, and before that you get a 3 course meal on the house. Solid.
Cat DeLucaMarch 11, 2018The lobster and crab feast is OFF THE CHARTS!!!! You can share this humongous and delicious platter of 2 lobsters, snow crab and Dungeness crab legs, shrimp, corn and rice! AWESOME!!!- Erik CintronJuly 10, 2018Don’t go the normal route straight make a left and get some awesome views and good food. Giant lobsters! The drinks were strong! Prices are normal for the island. Good service, and funny waiter !
- Debbie ArnoldOctober 5, 2016The best seafood fresh,two lobsters, crab legs, shrimp and yellow rice, for two, service good, nice pace, salad, olives garlic bread.
Veronica ArguelloJuly 11, 2014Service was great! Every staff member was courteous and attentive! We went for a work lunch and were very happy with food and service! Location is perfect. Love the outside seating!
Tom Gerhard ElizondoJune 23, 2014Excellent sea food. The lobster it's delicious... And the tables by the weather it's an excellent choose... And the service was the best... Thank you guys... I'll be back soon 😊
Paige CJune 28, 2016Outstanding service! Food is delicious. Sit outside for beautiful views while you eat.
- Romel SantosNovember 1, 2011Fresh shrimp, lobster, clams, and oysters are on the menu when coming out here. Not only will you find delicious seafood, you'll also be able to find a bar or three serving up your faves.
ChristineJuly 4, 2012Tables by the water are the nicest. My experience overall was excellent. Complimentary appetizer was a delicious combination of seasoned olives, cheese, & fresh mushrooms.
EDoubleE 🎣🐟July 19, 2014I've been here several times. The food and service is excellent! !!! The drinks a great too. Try the City Island Mojito!!
Milagros Montes de OcaApril 23, 2017The food is delicious,the customer service is very good I will allways recommended as the best of city island..
Nika MoffattFebruary 17, 2014Bbq lobster feast was ammmmaaaazing, penne a la vodka, buffalo wings, calamari. Ask for Antonio. Gave us complimentary liquor.
Ruben RiveraJune 29, 2014I've been to the lobster house many times. The food is always excellent .i highly recommend ir for family gatherings.
Giomar TrigueroApril 28, 2014The food is spectacular and the attention is awesome. We love going to City Island Lobster House!!
Foster B. Kinkade IIIMarch 8, 2012I've heard a lot of great things about this place. I heard the Lobster is good but I would not try the Shrimp Alfredo. It takes like hot milk. Sorry to say but honest. Blueberry cornbread is banging!- Carla MoscosoMay 25, 2014Lobster was fresh and delicious. Our server Laundel was friendly and so accommodating with my elderly mom.
Khoa ChauNovember 2, 2015I think better than sammies, mussels in red sauce so you can dip the bread, avoid the garlic sauce
Morgan 🍷October 4, 2010Cortez must have had a bad experience - this place is AMAZING! Great food, fun atmosphere, perfect for celebrating that special day with family and friends!
AliciaMarch 31, 2019Kind of expensive. Some dishes are good, some aren't. If it's crowded, chances are your food'll be overcooked. But their prime rib is absolutely SUPERB.
eric bornemannAugust 16, 2020Not the quaint seafood restaurant you want. Food is not great for the price and service leaves a bit to be desired. Still one of the better options on City Island.
Evdokia Tsolomytis-KalousisMarch 29, 2013Had great food all the times I have dined there. Really enjoy sitting on the veranda by the bay.
Joyce LeeAugust 25, 2013Paella is definitely not for one. Loved the blueberry bread. Good service Good food Good prices.
Momo SharolApril 20, 2013Had a retirement party for my father and the food and service was excellent!!!
Prashant 🚀 AgarwalMarch 28, 2011They say the paella is for one, but it could easily feed a small family.
KaiJuly 16, 2010Long Islands are strong for us men, and for the women who can't decide get the Blue Ocean.
Lindsay KaplanAugust 5, 2011Food sucked, service sucked. My lobster was dry and rubbery. The soup was garbage. The lobster roll was all runny mayo. Save your money and keep walking down City Island to the Lobster Box.
Richard BlakeleyJune 18, 2011Not a great place if you're in any kind of hurry, food service can take over an hour. Avoid the Lobster Roll, it's like runny tuna salad.
185 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 11:30 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:30 AM–1:00 AM
(718) 885-1459
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Live Music
Parking
Private Lot
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after City Island Lobster House
- 7.7
"Can't go wrong with a classic chocolate milkshake. An excellent way to end your night."
Andy Quintanilla - 7.6
"This mile-long of Pelham Bay Park is the Bronx’s only public beach, and it’s a popular spot. It has snack bars & picnic areas, two playgrounds, and 26 courts for basketball, volleyball, and handball."
Condé Nast Traveler - 7.8
"The best quesadilla in the island"
Nastassja Porras
Appears on 58 lists
Created by Yvette P
84 items • 25 followers
Created by Kelsey✨
65 items • 4 followers
Created by David Rosenberg
13 items • 5 followers
