"Came to try their lobster roll."(5 Tips)
"highly recommend trying the skirt steak and shrimp combination"(2 Tips)
"A little pricey, but you get a lot of food!"(2 Tips)
"Try the fresh clams with linguini or the baked stuffed shrimp !"(2 Tips)
24 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- scenic views
- good for dates
- pretzel rolls
- island
- bar
- (10 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Harlem’s HungryAugust 18, 2015The food was delicious! You can also eat at the bar. I loved the service everyone greets when you enter. I recommend the surf and turf to accompany the bulldog. I will return#cityisland#happypatron
Diane CimineJuly 17, 2016What a gem! Food is delish & service is excellent. Our waiter brought frosty mugs to serve our beer in, bringing fresh ones for our second round. Beautiful views of water to boot 👌🍴
Julius GordilsOctober 3, 2015Omg!! The best dining experience I have ever had. Friendly, Personable servers, fresh, delicious food and unbelievably inviting ambience ! I can't imagine going anywhere else on city island.
- Rachel AdamsMay 1, 2017Came to try their lobster roll. So amazing. I love the bread they used almost like a buttered pretzel roll and fantastic lobster inside. They really had the perfect combination.
Ravey BabyJune 9, 2015Was here for a reception. Hated the order of how food was served but the salmon, skirt steak, shrimp & yellow rice and veggies were delicious. The cake was good too. Would def come back when I'm in NY- New York HabitatApril 16, 2014The lobsters here are delicious! Try the fresh clams with linguini or the baked stuffed shrimp ! Friendly atmosphere.
- Stephanie MacLeodAugust 31, 2012Excellent lobster bisque soup. Definitely try the lobster roll too. The fried shrimp is juicy and large. A little pricey, but you get a lot of food!
- Best seafood on city island. Clam chowder was out of this world and the crusted salmon was absolutely delicious. Must go!
This is the ONLY place in City Island where you can get a Lobster Roll. And it's served Lunch & Dinner.
Yanzy BearApril 27, 2017Just a tad bit pricy, my family prefers Johnny's.. can't wait for my piña colada- I would highly recommend trying the skirt steak and shrimp combination
Alaedeen K.May 27, 2012Make sure your waiter reads your order back to you because the guy waiting on us screwed up several of our orders!
Azra BeganovicApril 19, 2012Worst food on city island.clam bake platter was boiled together with corn so everything tasted like corn.paid $100 for plain boiled food.Go next door to Sammy's shrimp box instead
67 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until Midnight (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:30 AM–Midnight
- Fri–Sat
- 11:30 AM–1:00 AM
(718) 885-1952
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Lobster Box
- 7.7
"Can't go wrong with a classic chocolate milkshake. An excellent way to end your night."
Andy Quintanilla - 7.6
"This mile-long of Pelham Bay Park is the Bronx’s only public beach, and it’s a popular spot. It has snack bars & picnic areas, two playgrounds, and 26 courts for basketball, volleyball, and handball."
Condé Nast Traveler
Appears on 11 lists
Created by Judith O.
33 items • 1 follower
Created by Alexia, The Nail Concierge™
143 items • 10 followers
Created by New York Habitat
9 items • 45 followers
