See all
143 photos

Insomnia Cookies

Dessert Shop and Bakery$$$$

Upper West Side, New York

Save

Insomnia Cookies

7.8^/10

201

ratings

Ranked #6 for dessert shops in the Upper West Side
"Peanut Butter Cookies and the Double Chocolate are the best!"(6 Tips)
"Snickerdoodle cookies are delicious!"(2 Tips)
"Levain has better cookies but these aren't bad for the price."(2 Tips)
"They deliver hot, fresh baked cookies to your door."(2 Tips)

69 Tips and reviews

Filter:

cookies
good for a late night
casual
brownies
family-friendly
authentic
great value
ice cream
s'mores
chocolate
coconut
mint
milk
pecan
walnuts
snacks
(11 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

NicoleJuly 16, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Cookiewich or brownie a la mode all the way. My friend dropped her cookie on the floor before she even took a bite, and the staff was friendly enough to give her another. Warm, fresh cookies everytime
ᴡ ArcusFebruary 9, 2013
Been here 5+ times
And on the seventh day, as God rested after creating the earth, he made Insomnia Cookies' cookies. God looked at his creations - all the Earth, and Insomnia Cookies - and said "this is good."
Sameepa ShettySeptember 28, 2014
Levain has better cookies but these aren't bad for the price. Sweeten your palate after dinner in the locality. Great service. They even throw in a free cookie if you're super nice!
Christopher DovinoMay 6, 2016
Chocolate chunk cookies were to die for! So soft and warm. They just melt in your mouth!
Jessica de OliveiraDecember 8, 2015
These cookies are a drug and the later your order the more free cookies they fill your take-out orders with.
SwatiMay 30, 2016
Chocolate chunk. Warm from the oven, can't go wrong.
Paula RagucciNovember 1, 2012
amazing place! the stores smells delicious and the cookies are awesome. the dark chocolate is a must have!
Felicia MSeptember 3, 2013
Great spot for a late night cookie fix. My favorite branch of the insomnia cookies chain.
Michael Fox-RabinovitzNovember 22, 2014
Great cookies selection, tasty and milk in the freezer is a nice touch
AnthonyJanuary 11, 2017
Satisfy those late night munchies with milk and cookies. Pass on their ice cream options, however. They're not that exciting.
Dei WestDecember 1, 2015
Peanut Butter Cookies and the Double Chocolate are the best!
KarenJanuary 4, 2018
The cookies are really good, but way overpriced. The ice cream sandwiches are a little more worth it.
Evangelia GiakoumatosMay 29, 2018
everything is so good- you can't go wrong with these cookies!
S AApril 12, 2013
Yummy cookies! Just left this location. The guy lied to me and told me he put 2 oatmeal raisins in my container after I reminded him twice! There was only one. Lame! Count your cookies!
Hank NormanNovember 4, 2012
Are you serious? What is there to complain about. They deliver hot, fresh baked cookies to your door. Bam.
Sebastian BayterMay 7, 2017
Delicious!!! I loved the sugar and the peanut butter cookies.
Michael MosesApril 13, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Always get 3 cookies/person when you walk home drunk from the bars on Amsterdam. It is important you do this.
Pierre AdamczykJuly 19, 2011
Just amazing cookies. Be careful with the double chocolate one it is so warm that the chocolate is pouring!
Emily BooneMarch 25, 2013
Warm and gooey at all hours but Levain still reigns supreme in taste and quality (74th street).
Louise BradshawNovember 8, 2012
The double chocolate mint cookie is beyond delicious.
andrea zaretskyApril 20, 2014
Get the peanut butter cookie - gooey deliciousness
Alexandra TritzAugust 22, 2016
Warm cookies, best is chocolate chip, simple but tasty.
Matthew CaldecuttJanuary 9, 2016
The cookies are rather soft and it's like eating sugar with some dough.
Tariq AhmadDecember 20, 2011
Ridiculously good cookies for a ridiculously low price. SnickerDoodle cookies are awesome.
Erica FinleySeptember 3, 2013
Sometimes they give you a free jug of milk on your birthday.
LogoTVMarch 8, 2011
“The name explains itself. The cookies are always fresh, always addicting, and won't let your hips, ass, or stomach down!” – Meredith, Setup Squad
NabeelJuly 21, 2011
Seriously, you can't go wrong with a $1 warm cookie. Cheaper and often better alternative to other cookie joints in the area.
Jeff SolomonDecember 13, 2017
Get the warm peanut butter chocolate cookie
Dilani KahawalaSeptember 25, 2014
The sugar cookies are awesome!
Elizabeth PaulinoJune 10, 2013
Warm, soft, delicious tasting, incredible smell baked cookies!!!
Datrianna MeeksOctober 1, 2014
The M&M cookies are the best!
L BJanuary 22, 2015
Best cookies ever love the double mint
Tara ReedNovember 25, 2012
Good, not great. You can probably make these at home and save your $$
Mustafa Al NiamaApril 12, 2014
Try their cookies!
Alice NamAugust 8, 2014
Double/triple chocolate chip cookies with their milk👍
Scott LindrothSeptember 8, 2012
Been here 5+ times
The white chocolate macadamia is the best!
Maria Del RussoMay 10, 2011
Snicker doodle cookies are better than my grandmother's.. Don't tell her! And they're only a dollar!
Tracy RobertsSeptember 4, 2011
Snickerdoodle cookies are delicious! They're up to $1.25 though...
Raul ReyesNovember 11, 2016
Not much to say when cookies are simply great.
Seven12 MagazineSeptember 13, 2011
I love their cookies. No trip to NY is complete without at least 1
CandiceNovember 18, 2015
Everything
Danielle CassesseJune 22, 2013
Been here 100+ times
Best peanut butter cookies ever!
Tara WallaceJanuary 16, 2012
Coconut Pecan is off the charts awesome!
estherAugust 14, 2014
The mint chocalate chip!
Lea CeasrineFebruary 12, 2015
Double chocolate chip peanut butter DELUX.
josh gordonAugust 3, 2011
order the m&m extra mushy..greatest cookie in the world!!
Anita SillonsSeptember 6, 2012
Really fresh anytime u buy
Melissa MeadeMay 10, 2012
Open until 3am living up to the name!
Donnie FrancisMay 7, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Best peanut butter cookies in the history of the world.
Shil PaOctober 24, 2014
open late. can you ask for more?

1 2

143 Photos

Insomnia Cookies

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Insomnia Cookies

Appears on 164 lists

Top places in the area

Other Insomnia Cookies locations

Is this your business? Claim it now.