Amsterdam Tavern
(Now Closed)American Restaurant and Bar$$$$
Upper West Side, New York
48 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
The Wall Street JournalApril 4, 2012The tavern steak sandwich is reason to return, with sliced Black Angus strips and gruyere served on a garlic-buttered roll. The beer-battered fish and chips is another favorite. Read more
Harlem AmbassadorJanuary 13, 2013Chances are you won't make it home after the entertainment and debauchery at this uptown hangout. Karaoke is packing them in as well as the drink specials. If you do go home, it won't be alone.
This place was a nice surprise. Get their chili nachos- a huge plate that's plenty of food for 2 people. 🙌🏼
The food's great. The bartenders and servers are cool. Great people and lots of beer.
Haff The Homeless Guy isn't allowed in the bar, but is a great singer. Check him out Sunday nights for karaoke (outside the bar).
Brigette K.December 13, 2014Good beer selection. There was a person of questionable origin at the bar, alternating between sleeping and putting cream/lotion on their feet. Pretty disgusting. Probably won't go back bc of that.
HI - New YorkAugust 15, 2011Our Activities and Volunteer Coordinator Paul says go to Amsterdam Tavern for their draft selection and their beer and shot special! Great folks! We <3 you guys.- Toccarra CashOctober 12, 2013Their brunch is FANTASTIC! Try the French Toast B.L.T. It's like magic in your mouth. 😋
- Place CRUSHES it on Sundays for karaoke. Don't miss out.
If you like cider, order a Magners with an extra cup of ice. Not overly sweet and I can't get enough!
It's the first Football Sunday of 2013 and the bartender has no idea where to find Sunday Ticket or how to operate the TVs. HELP!!!
if you don't fill up growlers anymore don't print growler prices on yer menu, dummy.
great mac and cheese with lobster and amazing variety of beers!- HI - New YorkJanuary 13, 2012Ol' reliable for an early evening drink and great pub fare. We love these guys.
Brian CulliganJanuary 24, 2015"The burger" was way undercooked. They were out of every other thing we ordered...on a Friday night. Ordered a salad, they brought buffalo chicken nachos. Ordered another salad, got stir-fry. Wierd.
Outdoor seating and amazing mimosas, great way to spend a Sunday
- The Mac n cheese is to die for and the burgers are amazing
Karaoke after 10pm on Wednesdays. Drinks specials after 1am.
Rebecca SerlinMarch 24, 2011If you're getting the ceaser salad, be sure to ask for extra dressing. They barely give you any on the salad. And avoid getting chicken on it, unless you enjoy extremely dry and tasteless food.
- Stay away from that shady guy they call "Haff". He's a great karaoke singer, but he gets too ripped.
Juan Carlos MoralesNovember 11, 2015Karaoke para halloween...los tragos normales, la atención estuvo buena, el ambiente lo máximo!!
140 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Tue, Sun
- Noon–3:00 AM
- Wed–Sat
- Noon–4:00 AM
(212) 662-8881
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"The breakfast bowl is fabulous. The whole wheat pancakes are special. Avocado Toast also delicious"
Susan J Campbell - 8.9
"Short rib, period. Amazing wine list"
Valerie Brown - 8.8
"Had the quinoa, Brussel sprouts, cranberries and almonds bowl with chicken and it was DELICIOUS! Portions are great too"
Raquel GC
Places people like to go after Amsterdam Tavern
Appears on 106 lists
Created by Kino
153 items • 37 followers
Entertainment in Greater Harlem
Created by Harlem Ambassador
88 items • 30 followers
Created by Tristan
36 items • 43 followers
