See all
236 photos

Shorty's

(Now Closed)

Sandwich Spot and Sports Bar$$$$

NoMad, New York

Save

Shorty's

Has a stamp of approval from Serious Eats and Gothamist

109 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Ross SheingoldJanuary 13, 2013
GREAT cheesesteak! I got an original with cheez whiz, hot and sweet peppers and onions. The hot peppers are VERY hot. Loved it. Fries are also great. Highly recommended. Best cheesesteak in NYC?
Quyen SAugust 27, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Always get the Old Bay fries for a taste of home... And if you want something lighter than the (delicious) cheesesteaks, try the Turkey Hoagie Salad. Also, best onion rings I've had in NYC.
GothamistAugust 1, 2014
I've devoured one of their classic cheesesteaks with onions every week, and found myself happily sated while listening to my coworkers complain about their limp salads and disappointing sandwiches. Read more
Mike FriedlichMarch 13, 2017
Cheesesteak with Whiz is very good but the Italian fries are the best. Perfectly crispy, and is delicious with herbs and cheese on it.
Lenny GalloNovember 7, 2015
Philly cheesesteak was surprisingly amazing. Rivals anything you would find in Philly. Definitely a bar joint type place, but if you're here, the Phillys' are a must.
Anuj MathurJanuary 16, 2015
While the cheesesteaks take top billing, don't sleep on the yuengling rings (beer battered onion rings) -- they are excellent. Order 'em with a little ranch and hot sauce on the side.
Elizabeth BursteinJuly 28, 2019
Love their cheese triangles and salami ham sub w vinegar on such good bread. Brady ordered off ubereats
John WmsonMay 22, 2013
Their cheese steak is the best this side of Philly. Their Italian Fries are excellent, and they have Sierra Nevada Pale Ale in bottles... a personal favorite. Great ambiance, too.
Christopher TaiJuly 2, 2012
Been here 5+ times
If you crave Geno's, Patsy's, or Tony Luke's, this is the place for you. Philly sandwiches are the best, and the bread here is almost as good. Order a cheesesteak whiz wit, or a roast pork with rabe!
Care EMay 14, 2012
OMG! Heavenly food at reasonable prices! Cheesesteak with provolone and fried onion a must plus the mozz sticks and Italian fries...delivery is good but the location even better when sports is on. Mm!
Amanda AlbergoDecember 25, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Whiz wit. Philly born & raised, I can attest it's the closest you will get in NYC. Although rolls are shipped in daily from Philly, they are more doughy and heavy than the real deal-- my only issue.
Eric CNovember 1, 2015
Perfect spot to watch a game. Has nooks to sit with groups. Even if you don't like sports come for a beer with a group
GothamistAugust 1, 2014
I don't know what they do to these fries but they're the perfect combination of creamy interior with pleasingly crunchy exterior and I cannot get enough of them. Read more
Kim BurnellMay 10, 2012
Been here 10+ times
shorty's soul cavern every Wednesday night $5 Six Points - hours of greasy funk & slippery soul classics and rarities, featuring cuts from James Brown to Sharon Jones and everything in between.
Faisal FahadAugust 4, 2018
Loved the Cheesesteak with Whiz and sweet piper.. with a side of Italian fries was so great!!
Melissa KiwiAugust 25, 2012
Nom Nom Nom Nothing like a Philly cheesesteak in the heart of NYC. Very tasty, friendly service and cool music!
Joe SbordoneMay 29, 2013
They have free wifi and Val is excellent. The special with sharp prov and onions was really tasty. Sorry gotta go a beer is calling my name
Serious EatsApril 1, 2013
Solid Philly-style cheesesteaks and sandwiches; we're particularly fond of the roast pork and broccoli rabe.
Danny SullivanNovember 6, 2011
Been here 25+ times
Shortys special is awesome..12 bucks for an amazing steak sammie and a delicious beer. Great beer and bourbon selection. Italian fries are a must!
deestivSeptember 21, 2015
Long lines and a bit of a wait, but the cheesesteaks are definitely worth it. As are the bacon and cheese fries!
Caitlin ClementsMay 7, 2017
Happy hour is Monday through Friday from 4:00 p.m. until 7:00 p.m. Options include $5 beer and $6 well drinks.
JonMay 13, 2019
Been here 5+ times
Happy Hour beers for $5 and fries for $4. Also great cheeseteak and broccoli rabe sandwiches
Jason O'BrienMarch 19, 2013
I'll be honest, I was surprised how fun this place was... staff was accommodating and funny (on a St. Patrick's day) and prices were good.
Kinjil MathurJanuary 11, 2015
Go 30 mins before kick off for seats. Chilled out vibe compared to more football watching bars. Vegetarian options are good. Esp sliders.
drew tarvinMay 26, 2015
A solid option for a Philly Cheesesteak in NY, though nowhere near as good as what you can get in Philadelphia itself.
Gianna NebbiaSeptember 7, 2018
Kitchen was backed up so food took forever BUT excellent cheesesteak and chicken steak. And delicious Bloody Mary
Lou CarulliMay 14, 2014
Can't go wrong with a cheese steak, Italian fries and a beer here!
ZenFoodsterJune 10, 2013
Fries here are double-fried & have a bit of batter, which make it taste denser than they really are. So, they're not my fave.
Giovanni D'PalmaJune 15, 2015
Cheese steaks are a great choice but I really enjoyed their chicken Herod as well.
jena savioNovember 26, 2015
Cheesesteaks are pretty solid! Almost like home. Philly sports friendly too ❤👍
Daniel MitchellJuly 5, 2013
Been here 10+ times
The mayor says, "eat everything on the menu. It's all good. The Italian fries are delectable and I don't even like fries.
Kimmie OhhDecember 3, 2019
The roast pork special sandwich is my favorite here.
Noah XifrMarch 16, 2012
My Philly friends steared me 2 go Shorty's or go home. Cheesesteak done right! Ask 4 their specialty freakin PROVOLONE CHEEZ WIZ!
Tatiana FrancoApril 5, 2012
The sandwiches here are amazing!I'm in love! Lol.And tried the mocha beer! Yummy zzzz. Can't wait to come again.
SecondMarketJuly 24, 2012
Get the veggie supreme “cheesesteak” sandwich to-go and eat it in Madison Square Park, just around the corner.
heather heenanNovember 8, 2011
Been here 10+ times
best cheesesteaks in NYC are at Shorty's! this one is bigger than their original Hell's Kitchen location (9th & 42nd)
David DinkevichMay 27, 2014
Loved the chipotle beef sandwich! !!! Also try the Rye RD 95 Great beer!!!!
Cole KennedyJanuary 14, 2019
I can't appreciate things from Philadelphia since they beat the Patriots in the Super Bowl, but this place doesn't entirely suck.
KristiaMarie Pastor BalatbatJanuary 14, 2016
Their hot buffalo wings were hotter than we get at the UES location.
Demetri KaragasJanuary 14, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Awesome food. Great beer selection. Best cheese steak in the city
Tricia M.October 16, 2015
Food is good, service sucks! I noticed 15+ taps asked for a beer menu, she handed me the faded out/somewhat laminated paper from my own table (which I already perused and couldn't decipher half of)
David ZhangSeptember 21, 2014
The cheesesteak is fine, but those Italian fries are incredible!
Jason MillionMarch 19, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Fries are nice and crispy.
Paige KlingermanOctober 18, 2015
100% best cheesesteaks in Manhattan and I'm from PA
Ehrin FeeleyNovember 13, 2011
As a gal who grew up in the Philly area I have had my fair share of cheesesteaks. I have to say the ones here do not dissapoint!
Rudolph PachecoSeptember 28, 2015
Service is excellent
AlexDecember 5, 2011
Try d Philly cheese steak. It's there specialty. N it's good. I tried w d provolone n d onions.
Paul MiddlekauffJuly 26, 2013
Really good cheesesteak and Italian fries... $20 minimum for credit card
Tiffany ChunatJune 14, 2012
Who needs to drive to Philly??? Delicious! Try the italian fries too.
Marcus MaffucciAugust 16, 2013
Go classic cheese steak and Dogfish Head on draught. Weekday bliss.

1 2 3

236 Photos

Shorty's

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Shorty's

Appears on 238 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.