Gelateria
Ice Cream Parlor and Dessert Shop$$$$
NoMad, New York
"Best salted caramel and sweet milk gelato in NYC"(18 Tips)
"Have the nocciola and cioccolato it's an amazing combination."(2 Tips)
"Flavors: milk, tiramisu, and any of the fruit sorbets are wonderful"(4 Tips)
"DIY affogato."(2 Tips)
40 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- gelato
- nocciola
- lively
- ice cream
- casual
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Jean 💜September 15, 2012Pistachio was so good but when is it not. When in doubt, go for it. Or get the banana stracciatella and lemme know how it is ;)
ZherawatiMay 23, 2017Try the Calamari pasta which has Fresh scallops and shrimp ! Delicious!! I have to say the portion is a bit small !!
Kelsey LeeJune 14, 2014The tiramisu gelato includes chunks of sponge cake soaked in coffee, and combines the best of the coffee and fior di latte gelatos.
Iraihana LeonardiJune 22, 2015Delicious ice cream!! Tiramisù the best ice cream I've ever eaten! perfect combination with Belgian chocolate! Loved!
Scrumptious gelato made fresh daily. Make sure to sample the specials. Expect a 5-10 min line around lunchtime.
Daniel CapeMarch 2, 2012The Salted Caramel is INSANE! Pair it with something lighter, like the Pear & Vanilla, another powerhouse flavor. Power. House!
Gary HorMarch 16, 2013The Tiramisu gelato is a must try! Creamy, rich and delicious without being overtly sweet!
Rick NijhuisNovember 17, 2016Love their pistachio gelato. Its brownish color shows it's made with real nuts, not just flavored like its green-colored imitations.
Zayed KhanSeptember 3, 2013While the flavors are true and delicious, the crema options tend to be a bit more watery than they should be. Stick to the sorbets.
BrianFebruary 12, 2012Great gelato. The flavors are so fresh. Some of my favorites: coconut, banana, salted caramel.
Frank RimalovskiDecember 26, 2011Good gelato but nothing to write home about. if you are in the area and crave ice cream this will suffice, but don't go out of your way. (2 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
JennJune 10, 2011Iced Frangelico Cappuccino is lighter than air. It doesn't make you feel so bad for eating a scoop of gelato immediately afterwards.
Kate FurmanMay 27, 2015Cross contamination is going on here, so not a good place for people with nut allergies.
- Justine BloomeNovember 25, 2015Double Cup of Salted Caramel. Do not pass Go. Do not collect $200. Do. Not. Miss. Trying. This.
146 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(212) 229-2560
View menu on http://eataly.com/pasta-and-pantry
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More
Other places inside Eataly Flatiron
- 7.7
"great spot to grab dinner at the bar. Gnocchi is perfection!"
Margaret Ryan - 7.9
"delicious cappuccino. perfectly foamed milk!"
CM S - 7.8
"Chef Michael Toscano’s menu is perfect for a red meat meal. The veal chop was an absolute pleasure to eat with its smoky flavoring, and the mezzalune is one of the best we have ever tasted."
Halstead Property
You might also like
- 9.1
"Vegan ice cream. So good. Mint chip is solid."
Taylor - 8.1
"Such a good idea! Their creations are delicious and the people are so friendly. The milkshakes are the best! Ask them for their suggestion and you can be sure it'll be delicious."
Sasha Jones - 7.7
"Took a class here and loved it! Cinnamon toast crunch flavor was out of this world!"
Stephen Pugliese
