Brewstone Beer Company
(Now Closed)Gastropub$$$$
Castleton, Indianapolis
75 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Richard RaeJuly 13, 2013Beer list is huge, includes cider on tap and local brews. Food is really very good, high quality. Outside seating is great in ideal weather. Plenty of multiple screens in the main room for sports!
Sean MolinMarch 15, 2013A LOT of tips say the service is bad. It may very well be, generally, but La'quwan was fantastic. Also, the beer battered chicken is INCREDIBLE. The shrimp Alfredo was VERY good.
Lindsay SchimmollerDecember 9, 2012Sunday special $3.95 craft drafts? Yes, please! My bartender's experience and love for Brewstone shows in his attentive, down-to-earth demeanor (Fergie's the shiz). West Coast burger = delicious!
Tyler McCordSeptember 9, 2012Excellent environment, no issues with service, though it wasn't busy, I do agree that it is over priced ($4 for adding chicken on Nachos) but great drink specials. Give it a chance.
Great bar, but this place has 40 taps, not what they published is 120... You can't count the same beer 3 times. Especially when they can't serve quick enough. Good try though.
Christopher RogersJanuary 23, 2013so I know other people didn't like the service here but it was more than acceptable to me. The food was awesome. Maybe they should focus more on the food than the beer. Let the beer come naturally.
New RadarMay 15, 2012Tuesday is "Taco Tuesday". Try the baja fish tacos. Flatbreads are a great choice to share as meal or appetizer.
Chris SohalskiJune 21, 2013Food and service were excellent. The beer selection is decent, could use more micros from outside of IN.
John NewlinMarch 31, 2012Great pizza, beer, and environment. Service was slow, but they just opened 2 days ago, and the Final Four was in full swing.
Ricky PottsApril 1, 2012The beer list is impressive. They have a ton on tap and in bottle, including several local beers.
Matt KleinApril 22, 2012Beautiful place! Spinach Artichoke dip.. Bland bland! Good beer list! Awesome outside bar!!
Morgan McGinnissAugust 26, 2012Food was good (had herb grilled chicken). Had to flag down a waiter to recognize we were even sitting down and they weren't even busy. The servers were all standing around. Never got a drink refill.
Sarah K.September 9, 2012The black and bleu burger is great! And they have a great choice of local brews:)- Review: Chix Wraps - eh not bad, I've had much better, Chipotle Chic Sliders - eh, wish I ordered burgers, Chicken Madeira - wish I hadn't. For $16 the chicken should be seasoned.
JohnAugust 2, 2012Really cool place that I wanted to love. Unlike others on FS, I received excellent service, but food was average at best.
Eric HintonMarch 30, 2012Our server Krista was the Bomb... bartenders couldn't read tap handles... take 20+ mins to get a beer... Med. Rare stake came out well :(
Theodore HuffApril 26, 2012Had to get a manager to get me a table while attractive women walked in and were seated immediately.
Amber McDonoughMay 11, 2012Atmosphere good but how you gonna sit at the bar and have to flag down a bartender for another drink? Bartenders are clueless.
KellyFebruary 28, 2013You would have thought the waiter worked at Little Ceasars, they were missing 10 of the best beers on tap, terrible margs for dad and Case, and Case's food was awful. Never coming back.
Jennifer FoustApril 21, 2013Our "waiter" never asked if we needed anything or how the food was. We had to flag down other people for drink refills and condiments. I will never go back to this place ever!!!!
Brittanny GookinsMay 10, 2012Overpriced food, food took forever to come out, staff has no idea what's going on, spelling errors on menu. COULD be great but is going to fall flat without attention to detail- Jennifer FoustApril 21, 2013Powdered gravy frozen turkey burgers frozen pizza! Do not waste time or money at this place. The hostess didn't even acknowledge our existence. We had to introduce our selfs.
Kyle FoggMay 29, 2012Expensive for.a simple burger, fries, and drink. Burger tastes like the grill - not bad but nothing spectacular. Split a pizza and save the money.
Traveler Beer on draft! Look for the mustache tap handle.
Bret UpdegraffApril 4, 2012Slow service. Didn't look too busy. They ran out of beer glasses. An IPA in a pilsner glass? Spelling issues on menu. I will try the take out.
Nicole BlochApril 22, 2012Beware of rude bartenders. Burgers appear to be pre-made patties w toppings & tasted like a burger youd have at a picnic.Save your $ and go elsewhere. Culvers serves a better/fresher burger IMO.
Kevin TemplemanDecember 2, 2012The service here fucking blows. If you're the type to dine n dash, do it here!
Erin Barnett NicholsApril 7, 2013I wanted to like this place. I really did. But the "host" staff makes you fend for yourself to find a table, the service is incredibly slow, and the food is overpriced & mediocre. Go somewhere else.
Christian KidwellDecember 20, 2012Same flash different city. OK at best over priced crapy food. And Paul and Eric don't pay their venders.
Nicole SpaceyJuly 20, 2012The drinks are watered down! Don't let the crowd fool you, it's not worth the price!
Monte DMay 28, 2012Second and last attempt here. No hostess to seat us. And good luck eating gluten free. Scotty's is leaps and bounds better.
KalApril 4, 2012Nice atmosphere, but super slow service and overpriced mediocre food. You also can't get most beers on the patio when they get "too busy."- Management read comments. All similar & action needed. Slow service. tables not cleared quickly... just step 1 in running a restaurant. Nothing to do with 4sq.
128 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Brewstone Beer Company is a national restaurant brand specializing in good food, affordable prices, specialty beers and a unique and casual atmosphere.
(317) 577-7300
Features
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Drinks
Beer
See More
You might also like
- 7.2
"I love the pizza, so much so, I haven't tried the steaks yet and I've been here 4 times!"
Jim Lewis - 7.2
"Get the pork rinds and add hot sauce."
Cody Jackson - 8.7
"Outstanding drink selection and the band was amazing. The atmosphere topped of the evening. I will definitely be returning."
David Leszcynski
Places people like to go after Brewstone Beer Company
- 6.1
"Friday Saturday make sure you come early(7:30or8:00) or call and reserve a table! Thursdays and Sundays are cheap and fun if your lookin to save a little money!"
Mark Ringold - 7.6
"Their sushi is actually good! ! Spicy California roll..yum!"
Leah Pyle - 8.9
"World famous "Hermanki Wings".(A must try! Spicy Teriyaki sauce blend grilled on to the wings)"
Adam Zeigler
Appears on 10 lists
Created by Patrick Flanagan
28 items • 17 followers
Created by Kate @iKaterade
108 items • 40 followers
Created by Julie Newell ☕
11 items • 1 follower
