Sugar and Plumm
(Now Closed)Dessert Shop, American Restaurant, and Ice Cream Parlor$$$$
Upper West Side, New York
The folks at Serious Eats and Gothamist like this place. Would you agree?
96 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
A good place to pick up tasty, cutely packaged last-minute gifts. Also has good salads (spinach one or whole grains) and milkshakes/desserts. Kid-friendly, even when a kid I took made a huge mess.
JamesApril 17, 2014OK, they must smoke and bake their chicken wings because they're INSANE delicious. And by the time I got to the buttery, syrupy waffles I damn near cried. So so good.
Untapped CitiesNovember 17, 2014New to the Manhattan dessert community, this brightly colored boutique is a feast for the eyes with its vast array of chocolates, homemade candy and macarons on display right when you walk in. Read more
Jen DangJanuary 22, 2013Don't let the swarm of strollers fool you, the food is delicious and the service is spectacular. The pulled pork and waffles was hands down THE best food I've ever ate!
Brandon CliftonNovember 3, 2013This place is awesome! Cafe, candy land, and full restaurant. What more can u ask for? And the food is actually really good. The Plumm Burger OMGGGG. And the whole grain, Is just amazing.
refinery29August 3, 2014Insider tip: The wait for a table on weekends is out of control. If you’re with a squirmy child, order takeaway and enjoy it at the communal table in the front area of the café. Read more
Billy KimJanuary 5, 2013Realistic review- solid brunch. Nothing over the top amazing but very good. Pulled pork and waffles are good. Beet salad is great... Just replace with goat cheese for +2. Bit pricey but will return.
KarenJanuary 6, 2018Super adorable and sweet-looking brunch place. They serve amazing chicken and waffles. The place is super kid-friendly.
- KarenJanuary 6, 2018Super adorable and sweet-looking brunch place. They serve amazing chicken and waffles. The place is super kid-friendly.
Chelsea SoMarch 11, 2013Not feeling up for a big dish? Their pulled pork bun appetizer uses the same meat as the amazing pork and waffles entrée. And if you have a kid with you, try the chicken tenders rolled in cornflakes!
Aarthi D.August 10, 2014Excellent service, terrific staff, and the food (brunch) is consistently good. A touch expensive, but the caliber of care makes it worthwhile. I've never had a negative dining experience here.
BasApril 14, 2013Short rib hash is great, but get salt & pepper and some ketchup to set it off. The hangover helper is where you wanted to start your experience here
Shelly TimminsAugust 10, 2013The heaven and hell cake with dulce de leche is very good loved the peanut butter cream but the angel food doesn't really add much.. The chocolate chunk cookie is to die for though!
I love the macarons (apple pie, raspberry and blueberry) and ice cream here. Chocolate sorbet is a must have for chocolate lovers. The disco- dust sprinkled fruit tart is amazing as well!
Nancy KangMarch 22, 2014Try the multi grain salad w/ lemon vinaigrette, arugula, field greens, haricot vert, olives, onions. Believe it or not, they actually have healthy food here & it's good!
Lauren ColemanSeptember 2, 2013Cheesy decor but don't let it steer you away. Full bar and amazing dessert. I've had both the brownie sundae and Brooklyn blackout cake with ice cream. DELICIOUS!
chris OOctober 14, 2012The waffles w/pulled pork + heirloom egg is a great dish alone or shared w/a partner who gets the equally delish lemon ricotta pancakes. Noisy but worth the wait.
Emily ScheerDecember 19, 2016Cute brunch spot, went for a private party in the back. Waffles with bacon egg and cheese and vanilla ice cream were great.
Rob WilkJuly 23, 2014These guys cracked the code. It's a super kid friendly place that simply doesn't "feel" that way. Solid food and a great selection of desserts.
Upper West Side's version of Willy Wonka's chocolate factory. They have so much great goodies while also serving food. This is a great gem of the UWS.
Carl HubAugust 22, 2013Good food and dessert. Kid friendly. Nice cocktails. Few feet from Tecumseh public playground . Little expensive.
Ryan RossAugust 6, 2014Quite quirky combinations here. Pulled pork and maple syrup for example. Dailey good food but you risk over-indulging.
Minda AAugust 21, 2012The macaroons here are quality. Have yet to try other yummy desserts, but looks like this will be a real UWS stalwart. I always could use more sugar!
Josh BerkowitzAugust 14, 2014They have some fun cocktails. The Sugar Plumm and their upgraded Old Fashioned are my wife and my favorites, respectively.
Best chocolate shake on the UWS. Can't stop ordering the lemon waffle and heirloom eggs.. The coffee is first rate, too!
Gail AmuraoOctober 22, 2016The chicken & waffles is probably the best I've had in the city to date. And I take my waffles seriously.
Ambience is very cafeteria with lots of kids running around screaming. Great if that is what you want but if you don't I would skip. Food is worth the noise.
CRUZiiiEOctober 5, 2014It gets pricey for a latte and cookie, but the interior is so pretty that you kind of just ignore the cost. Ps: The communal table is the easiest for seating.
AdamFebruary 23, 2013This place kicked ass. Get the Short Rib Hash (I don't normally like short ribs) and the Hot Chocolate Milkshake. 5 stars!
Fernando MacielSeptember 29, 2013One of the best meals that I had in my life. Ask for the Pulled Pork Waffle. It is unbelievable!
Brooke BurdgeSeptember 21, 2012Great staff. Cute decor, but semi-overly commercial (could picture this place in a mall). Try the pommtini and bacon mac and cheese.
The chocolate chip cookies are delicious! Fantastic banana split & fishbowls if you have a crew:)
Guy BoazySeptember 6, 2016I felt my breakfast (heirloom eggs) were quite mediocre but my daughter felt her waffles were great !
Karen TaylorJuly 11, 2014If you want fantastic ice cream this is the place. It reminds me if Willy Wonka
Serious EatsMay 20, 2013Simple single-serving cakes to massive plated desserts from sweets mad scientist Pichet Ong.
Fun Foodie NYC ToursJune 21, 2013Tons of great chocolates and sweets, and a stop on the Spring Up to the West Side tour.
Meg CallenderJuly 28, 2013The macaroons aren't good. They should be light and flakey with a little bit of creme between the layers. These had so much creme that there were no flakey layers. Get them elsewhere.
SydneyApril 18, 2014Try to get reservations because you might be waiting a long time to get a table.
491 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Sugar and Plumm
377 Amsterdam Ave (btwn W 78th & W 79th St)
New York, NY 10024
United States
New York, NY 10024
United States
A boutique bistro. A whimsical bakery. An artisan chocolate maker.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 9:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri
- 9:00 AM–11:30 PM
- Sat
- 8:30 AM–11:30 PM
- Sun
- 8:30 AM–10:00 PM
(212) 787-8778
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Yes
Dining Options
Take-out, Delivery
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Cocktails, BYO
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Sugar and Plumm
Appears on 275 lists
Created by Kate K
201 items • 15 followers
Created by Allison D.
199 items • 88 followers
Created by D
91 items • 30 followers
