Carmine's Pizzeria
Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Williamsburg, Brooklyn
"The Philly cheesesteak slice is pretty awesome... when they have it."(3 Tips)
"Try the Artichoke & Olive Sicilian Slice - #pizza #vegetarian"(41 Tips)
"Eggplant slice with ricotta"(2 Tips)
"After you see all the special slices you are going to want to order two, which..."(2 Tips)
83 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- eggplant slice
- sports bars
- great value
- spacious
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Consistently good slices, and always fresh. Each pie has a sign showing when it was baked, so you'll never have an old slice here.
Great pizza pick up when coming home from the Subway! They also finally opened their sports bar which has been a total game changer in the neighborhood! Tons of TVs with great Italian food to order!Upvoted Feb 17
Jennifer JberryJune 9, 2014Bruschetta was delicious along with the mozzarella sticks, the Philly cheese steak pizza was out of this world 😍😍 the pepperoni and sausage was ok..
Bjorn L.August 31, 2015Very solid "local" pizza place. Nothing newfangled, just very good pizza, particularly IMO their white slice (try it with pepperoni) and their eggplant parm slice.
Vivian RamirezSeptember 26, 2016Absolutely amazing pizza that has been around forever. Feels like family. Dozens of visits sometimes more than once a day- never tire of their food.
High quality pizza slices all around. Philly cheese steak and cheese tortellini slices are two of the best.
Kimmie OhhDecember 30, 2019Each pizza has time cards that let you know when they were taken out so you know how fresh your pizza is. Get a cheesesteak slice !
Fantastic pizza, some of the best in the neighborhood. They also play every sports game you could want to watch.- Brian SNovember 3, 2012After you see all the special slices you are going to want to order two, which is a huge mistake I have made many times.
Can’t go wrong with the Tri-Color. Also the plain is solid. Best pizza in Williamsburg!
Michael TappJanuary 3, 2013I second Mike Caprio. Go for the Philly Cheese Steak slice if it's available. UNREAL! One of the best slices I have ever consumed.
HectorApril 1, 2015Full of Yankee theme stuff inside, this pizzeria is very well known for it's lasagna slice - highly recommend it.
Great solid neighborhood pizzeria with a connecting sports bar next door. What's not to love?
Sofia UzJanuary 8, 2015It may sound unbelievable, but this is one of the best pizza places i've been to in nyc....- Great solid neighborhood pizzeria with a connecting sports bar. What's not to love?
Chantele BondDecember 20, 2017They seem to have an issue with people of color. On more then one occasion they have made many people I know feel like their business wasn’t welcome. My daughter and her friends were ignored! Beware!
Louis MattaNovember 10, 2015Very new/very nice sports bar connected to its pizzeria. Makes for a genius idea I'm shocked not many other people have thought of.
Awesome specialty slices, kind of heavy on the stomach, but sometimes that's what you want. I like Tony's for deep dish and Carmine's for the rest.
Great pizza place - try the plain slice or the deep dish or one of their specials! Everything is awesome here! =)
Best pizza in the Williamsburg/Greenpoint area. The Penne ala Vodka slice is LEGEN...wait for it...DARY
Get yourself a personal pizza packed w/ toppings. It will last you for dinner and lunch the following day
yesenia linaresAugust 11, 2010this is one of the best places to get a slice of pizza, the buffalo chicken with jalapenos is my fave!
They label each pie with the time it was made and when it'll be discarded.
The chicken with roasted peppers sandwich is really good.
Plain slice and a fountain soda. You can't go wrong!
Arugula / grape tomato slice is out of control, but you gotta be there during lunch rush if you wanna catch one before they disappear.
this place has better food and service than Tony's next door. my favorite pizza in the World.- Eggplant slice with ricotta, mozzarella and tomato sauce - one of my favorite foods in the world.
- John StrikaAugust 7, 2014Tony's Pizza across the street is FAR better and they don't bend over to cater to the hipsters as much as Carmine's does.
Ryan DanielsSeptember 11, 2012Pizza was late, sloppy and had metal in it. Talked to Carmine; he was rude and condescending. Been a customer 2 years. Brought my mom and baby there. Never felt so unvalued. Will never order again.
Ana MangeonFebruary 16, 2010Get off the couch and go there to grab a slice. The delivery pizzas don't taste as good as the ones you eat in loco.
145 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Carmine's Pizzeria
358 Graham Ave (btwn Conselyea St & Metropolitan Ave)
Brooklyn, NY 11211
United States
Brooklyn, NY 11211
United States
Open until Midnight (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–Midnight
(718) 782-9659
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
No
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Yes
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Carmine's Pizzeria
Appears on 127 lists
Created by Chris Gampat
200 items • 50 followers
Created by t m
30 items • 32 followers
Created by Dan Kim
137 items • 43 followers
