El Atoradero Brooklyn
(Now Closed)Taco Restaurant and Tex-Mex Restaurant$$$$
Prospect Heights, Brooklyn
40 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Emily WilsonJanuary 2, 2017The best Mexican brunch you'll find in all of NYC. Go with a friend, split the chilaquiles (with tinga) and the eggs divorciados. Wash it all down with a glass of jamaica (hibiscus).
Adrian PhillipsAugust 29, 2017Great spot to pop into on a Saturday afternoon for a margarita and guacamole. A pitcher is $42, one taco per serving. Preferred the shrimp over the pork. Cute back patio with a very friendly staff.
Noah NormanAugust 24, 2016A new import to Crown Heights delivers real-ass Mexican in your face with albondigas, poblanos, and probably something you've never heard of, all excellent.
Aja BrandmanMay 4, 2018Can’t beat the fresh blue corn tortillas here! The chilaquiles are 👌🏼One of the best Mexican restaurants in this neighborhood. See if you can get the Madre drink, a tequila mezcal margarita!
Melanie TravisJanuary 26, 2016Authentic Mexican. The menu is in Spanish and the waitress didn't know what all the items were. "Lamb of goat" turned out to be deliciously barbecued goat. Mole enchiladas were great too
Nick AndlingerJanuary 21, 2016Outstanding tacos and plates. Mole was super flavorful. Al pastor tacos were 🔥
LukeFebruary 10, 2018The torta ahogado is low key one of the best guilty pleasures around and eating one is the only time it’s acceptable to eat a sandwich with a fork
Marie RicherJune 20, 2017Mole and tacos were delicious. Tasty aqua fresca. The back patio looked cute and decor inside as well. Friendly casual service.
Brian PenningtonDecember 19, 2015The steak torta was especially delicious, and the guacamole was perfectly balanced with some interesting flavors
AmateurConciergeFebruary 18, 2017Some of NYC's best Mexican (the mixote sous vide chicken was awesome) but the kitchen is slow and the service is lacking. Good cheap food tho
Definitely a hidden gem for brunch. The chilaquiles with tinga pollo is especially killer.
Joanna FlammNovember 16, 2016Cozy ambiance and delicious Mexican food. Enchiladas Rojas are just the right amount of spicy.
Andre RibeiroSeptember 25, 2016Sour Orange Chilli Mescal Frozen Margarita and the Chicken Tinga tacos were the bomb. 💣
Barbacoa tacos, pork riblets, salsas, were all excellent. Not your average Mexican restaurant.
Jeremy FisherJanuary 13, 2016Outstanding Mexican offered at this Bronx transplant. Get the carnitas picaditas
Tacos were not that great. However everything else was exceptional! Go with the bigger "entree" plates especially the mole
- Don't miss the steak nachos, the serving size is also generous
37 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
El Atoradero Brooklyn
708 Washington Ave (btw St Marks & Prospect Ave)
Brooklyn, NY 11238
United States
Brooklyn, NY 11238
United States
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 5:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 11:00 AM–4:00 PM
- 5:00 PM–Midnight
(718) 399-8226
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Music
No
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dessert
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after El Atoradero Brooklyn
- 9.3
"Really can't go wrong with anything, but the marshmallow/rice crispy ice cream is out of this world."
Meg Farmer - 8.9
"Get the grilled cheese sandwich with their house made beer cheese and delicious pickles. Or get the cheese and pickles on their own."
Barry Hott - 9.3
"The Counter Cafe is excellent! Try the Croque Monsieur--outstanding! The lentil soup was great!"
Charles Petkanas
Appears on 260 lists
Created by PureWow
18 items • 25 followers
Created by Howard
350 items • 8 followers
MICHELIN BIB GOURMAND 2016-2017 NYC
Created by Jessica A
156 items • 10 followers
