Martha's Country Bakery
Bakery$$$$
Williamsburg, Brooklyn
"I had the best banana pudding I've ever tried!"(3 Tips)
"Amazing selection of desserts, cheesecakes are amazing."(15 Tips)
"Try the banana cream pie with vanilla ice cream!"(2 Tips)
"Try their peanut butter hot chocolate and add the whipped cream 👍🏻"(2 Tips)
66 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- desserts
- cheesecake
- spacious
- pie with vanilla ice
- coffee
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
TaniaNovember 24, 2017I just wanted hot tea but when I got into, I decided to stay. Very nice place and the personnel, toms of desserts and hot drinks! Recommend if you need to warm up and eat smth good))
Christina ChinJune 5, 2018Delish desserts, hard to go wrong, just may take time to decide what to get, so many choices!
- Sara JordanAugust 4, 2018Their cheesecake is so thick and scrumptious! Sometimes they have sales on pudding cups and smaller options. Try the banana cream pie with vanilla ice cream! Not for the faint of heart.
Jeff PetrielloApril 29, 2019A Paradise of deserts. I'm partial to the mixed fruit tart, but honestly you can't go wrong. If you're getting gelato, do yourself a favor and take the two block walk down to Gelateria Gentile instead
Austribeth MoranMay 25, 2022The costumer service was excellent, the girl who served me prepared the best white chocolate, even though it was not on the menu, she made it with the best attitude and it was exquisite.Thank you❤️
KEMarch 31, 2019Order to stay or go, vibe is pretty corporate. The chocolate chip cookies leave something to be desired, black & white cookie icing peeled off with the plastic wrap. Gelato flavors looked good!
Ashley ChanApril 22, 2017Typical New York pastries such as cheesecake, banana bread pudding and black and white cookies. Nothing standout about the desserts, but I love that the place has an in-house DJ. Lots of space to sit.- TaniaSeptember 22, 2018Napoleon cake with custard cream or with berries and butter cream are very rich, big and delicious👌🏻
Marina MalakAugust 15, 2019I’ve tried black forest, 7 layers, and banana cream pie. All were incredibly delicious! Great service and staff
RickyJuly 27, 2019This place is amazing! My wife and I got the Tiramisu Mousse Cheesecake,Red Velvet cake and banana chocolate chip bread pudding!
Tatiana RodriguezApril 15, 2018The vegan carrot cake, strawberry and fudge cheesecake are highly recommended!
Joana Cavalheiro GomesJune 26, 2017Best place ever for cheesecake, we were 4 and tasted 4 different slices and all of them were just... amazing!!!
Jackie ToddJuly 22, 2017Really nice, spacious bakery. Everything looks quality-made. I tried the red velvet cupcakes. Delicious.
Natalie SchaafJuly 28, 2017Martha's Country Bakery is such a great place! The service is incredible, I felt very welcome!
- Andy JiangApril 9, 2019Open late with a bunch of dessert options and wifi. Great hot chocolate selection.
Afro lynneAugust 21, 2017had a DJ on a Sunday night, choice of music is very strange, feels like a family banquet instead of a mellow dessert place ... 😰
Natalie FreilichOctober 8, 2016Holy crap, if you want to be overwhelmed by dessert choices - this is the place to go. Almost every type of cake, cookie, and pastry imaginable.
Fabienne HBDecember 28, 2016Just stopped here to grab a quick coffee. I had a latte. Well if they want to call it that way it is up to them. This was more like warm milk mixed with water.
Bianca VasconcellosApril 7, 2019anytime it’s a good place to have a cup of tea and a generous slice of cake.
Alexandra BurdDecember 28, 2016Cozy space for coffee stop: great choice of pastries for reasonable price.
Alexandra FanningAugust 20, 2017It's like being in Eastern Europe. A bit of techno with your coffee and cake 🎉
- Amazing and more importantly delicious! I had the best banana pudding I've ever tried! So many choices and they have a spacious cafe! Must try in Williamsburg!
313 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Martha's Bakery was founded with the goal of providing our customers with classic American baked goods in a warm, friendly atmosphere. Each day, we bake everything from scratch using the finest ingredients.
Closed until 6:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 6:00 AM–Midnight
- Fri–Sat
- 6:00 AM–1:00 AM
(718) 599-0900
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Martha's Country Bakery
- 7.9
"Big, modern movie theater with nice seating and a good selection of new mainstream Hollywood releases, and a few indie films too. The popcorn is pretty good too. Good place to go for movie night."
Brian Grogan Jr. - 8.7
"Love this branch of whole foods, has a good selection on the hot & cold food counters. Location is close to the East river so I usually make up a food box and take a short walk to eat by the river."
Aimée Jane Parr - 9.6
"My favorite in Brooklyn. Domino's Park goes along the water under the Williamsburg Bridge. Great skyline views perfectly picturesque during sunset and it's conveniently right by the many shops nearby"
ℳ𝒶𝓎♍
Appears on 211 lists
Created by Caitlin Clements
284 items • 4 followers
Created by Mon
111 items • 2 followers
Stevenson's Favorite NYC Speciality Groceries
Created by Robert Stevenson
118 items • 3 followers
