Maison Pickle is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

1. Maison Pickle

9.1
2315 Broadway (W 84th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Upper West Side · 89 tips and reviews

Annie H.Annie Hung: A delightful mismatch of things -- Biggie Smalls blaring in a sleek, loungey space with delicious schmancy French dip sandwiches, mac n cheese...and top notch cocktails. Hey, why not?! It works!

Tim R.Tim Rossi: The Mac & Cheese is amazing and French Dips are great. Will be back but with a bigger group to share!

Christine C.Christine Casano: The deluxe French dip is bomb!!

Loring Place is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

2. Loring Place

9.0
21 W 8th St, New York, NY
American Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 93 tips and reviews

AmateurConciergeAmateurConcierge: Buzzy spot on a quiet street with very good New American cuisine. Loved the ricotta/squash, the short rib and the spaghetti. Pizzas too. Felt the grain salad and pear & leeks dishes were overdressed

Elyse E.Elyse Estrada: Everything is fantastic! Exactly what you'd expect from ABC Kitchen alums. Short rib is to die for! Agnolotti pasta is amazing. Crispy chicken app is super tasty. Very inventive cocktail list. ❤️❤️❤️

Bridget H.Bridget Holmes: Brunch with Fran and Jess

Westville is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

3. Westville

9.0
333 Hudson St (at Charlton St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Hudson Square · 205 tips and reviews

Rachel P.Rachel Port: Always share a plate of market veggies, they're all so delicious!

Jen B.Jen Berg: Biggest and brightest Westville location, same great menu. The Cobb is my go-to. Lemon dill dressing is out of this world. Side of fries to boot!

Alberto M.Alberto Mann: Oh and bring your Bose noise canceling headphones. Babies everywhere. Sounds like a bunch of dying pterodactyls in here.

The Polo Bar is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

4. The Polo Bar

8.9
1 E 55th St (5th Avenue), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Midtown East · 65 tips and reviews

Julie S.Julie Soscia: Reservations will definitely need to be made in advance, but you can enjoy a meal or cocktails at the bar. All the food is delightful, but the steak is a must!

Jason R.Jason Rodriguez: Everything about this place is perfect. Polo Burger and an old fashioned are a must.

Heather R.Heather Rodriguez: Over-priced, trendy douchebaggery.

Craft is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

5. Craft

9.0
43 E 19th St (btwn Park Ave S & Broadway), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Flatiron District · 126 tips and reviews

Joao V.Joao Veloso Jr: Book in advance . One of the best restaurants in the planet. The potatoes aligot is heaven. Staff is well prepared and will make the experience even better.

Jessica W.Jessica Worthington: beef short ribs, side of baby carrots, sugar & spice donuts for desert = heaven. amazing service... they give you fresh muffins from the pastry chef when you leave!

The New York TimesThe New York Times: Recommended: Marinated big-eye tuna, crispy bacon, pork ravioli; roasted sturgeon, scallops; roasted and braised suckling pig, roasted vegetables; gnocchi, risotto; ice cream, sorbets, pain perdu. Read more.

Blue Ribbon Brasserie is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

6. Blue Ribbon Brasserie

9.0
97 Sullivan St (btwn Prince & Spring St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · SoHo · 153 tips and reviews

MarthaMartha: oysters, beef marrow, steak tartar, french onion soup, foie gras...

Seth G.Seth G: Got to try the marrow it's like heaven in your mouth.

Marianna V.Marianna Vitoroulis: On both my visits to Blue Ribbon Brasserie i left quite spoiled by the delightful food and the topnotch service! Bone marrow with oxtail marmelade and the raw seafood bar are winners all around!

Family Meal At Blue Hill is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

7. Family Meal At Blue Hill

9.0
75 Washington Pl (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 151 tips and reviews

Robert L.Robert Laurente: Great food and even better service. Get the Farm Egg appetizer.

How To Make It In AmericaHow To Make It In America: Dan Barber's fresh, eco-friendly food is driven by the harvest at his farm upstate. The room located just below street-level on quaint Village block has the same casual grace as the eats.

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Very kind to the stomach, but not to the wallet! Do splurge on This Morning’s Farm Egg and the Blue Hill Farm Pig.

Gramercy Tavern is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

8. Gramercy Tavern

9.3
42 E 20th St (btwn Broadway & Park Ave), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Flatiron District · 447 tips and reviews

Rachel R.Rachel R: The beef tartare first course is superb. Beautiful restaurant, and they brought out two complimentary desserts at our meal's end.

CNNCNN: CNN Eatocracy: It's one of the New York's most beloved restaurants -- and for good reason with its luxurious yet homey atmosphere. Everything's seasonal and you really can't go wrong.

EaterEater: The unofficial official First Restaurant of New York. Though its formal dining room is a bit too too for Eater 38 contention, the front room and its seasonal American menu wins. [Eater 38 Member] Read more.

Cookshop is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

9. Cookshop

8.9
156 10th Ave (btwn W 19th St & W 20th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Chelsea · 520 tips and reviews

Jessica M.Jessica M.: Incredible brunch - fried egg sandwich, egg scramble, and spicy fries were all perfection. Make a res and bypass the crowds.

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Leave your name for a table and take a stroll on the Highline as you wait to be called. Great ambiance, good service and fresh ingredients combine for an excellent brunch or lunch spot.

Kayvon M.Kayvon Mesbah: Honestly, I have to steal the words of Immaculate Infatuation, "[it's] so good that you'll want to take your leftovers home and bury them in a time capsule." Best brunch in a long time!

Westville East is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

10. Westville East

8.8
173 Avenue A (at E 11th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · East Village · 299 tips and reviews

Katie R.Katie Rose: Go for a market plate. It's vegetarian, delicious and a ton of food. And if you still have room for dessert, order a homemade Oreo. They're a little dry, but they're delicious.

Anne H.Anne Hubert: I still maintain this place should be called Eastville

Susan L.Susan Loh: if you're here for dinner, always order off the specials menu. always. then get a slice of apple pie.

Clay is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

11. Clay

8.8
553 Manhattan Ave (W 123rd Street), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Central Harlem · 14 tips and reviews

Matthew C.Matthew Caldecutt: The wine list is superb. The cocktails are masterfully crafted. The food is great. My family loves the duck and pastas. Be sure to save room for dessert.

Arthur E.Arthur Esque: Duck confit, sea bass, chicken liver and WINE! Service is great too. A gem.

Brendan N.Brendan Naylor: Pasta and pork belly!

The Smith is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

12. The Smith

8.8
956 2nd Ave (at E 51st St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Turtle Bay · 362 tips and reviews

Amy M.Amy Mixa: Spicy blood orange margarita and the jalapeño cheese grits are my favs!!!

Jasmine B.Jasmine Benun: Unisex bathroom, enter at your own risk.

AskMenAskMen: Aside from seafood towers & ceviche, the menu also includes smart comfort food like fried chicken & potato waffles, and St. Louis-style sticky ribs. Read more.

Au Cheval is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

13. Au Cheval

8.8
33 Cortlandt Alley (btwn White & Walker St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Downtown Manhattan · 68 tips and reviews

Courtney D.Courtney Desh: Great burgers with egg and thick bacon on it! Decent prices, cute ambiance. Fried chicken is also really good.

Damian B.Damian Bayona: Tip: single cheeseburger (no egg), fries split with you & your honey & a glass of cab to wash it down. More food & you will be down for the count - trust me 🤤

Alex P.Alex Pyatetsky: Instant favorite. Single burger has 2 patties. Bacon on side is amazing meat candy. Green salad is the platonic ideal of acidic and herbaceous. Looking forward to returning.

The Commerce Inn is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

14. The Commerce Inn

8.8
50 Commerce St (at Barrow St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · West Village · 4 tips and reviews

Caroline M.Caroline McGurk: The pork belly and beans, bone marrow, country ham, and oxtail anything is to die for. Milk punch w walnut rum is my favorite cocktail!

Mackenzie M.Mackenzie Moore: Fried okra with hot honey sauce and potted shrimp appetizers were delicious. Shared T-bone steak special with four people - excellent meat.

Ran Y.Ran Yan: Simple but balanced! Like the drink too.

Cafe Cluny is one of The 15 Best American Restaurants in New York City.

15. Cafe Cluny

8.7
284 W 12th St (at W 4th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · West Village · 271 tips and reviews

CharlottesCharlottes: Super cute and cozy, perfect for date night. My tagliatelle was very rich and a bit too buttery but my partner really enjoyed his burger. The roasted baby lettuce was delicious. Enjoy!

The Wall Street JournalThe Wall Street Journal: Among the most popular items is the breakfast club sandwich with a fried egg, bacon, tomato, avocado and mayonnaise served with a side of fries. Read more.

Kenny K.Kenny Kim: Don't wear stripes, you'll match the waiters.