Jimmy's Diner is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Shakes in Brooklyn.

1. Jimmy's Diner

577 Union Ave (btwn N 10th & N 11th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Diner · Williamsburg · 206 tips and reviews

Debbie P.Debbie Pressman: The BEST chocolate peanut butter banana shake you ever tasted. Wonderful staff, too!

Kelly K.Kelly Kai: Great chocolate banana shake! I have never had a FLT (facon lettuce and tomatoe) before... And it was great! A great alternative to the regular veggie burger.

Gaëlle M.Gaëlle Ma Tata: Very tasty American dinner, with art on the wall and great staff

Häagen-Dazs is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Shakes in Brooklyn.

2. Häagen-Dazs

7.4
109 7th Ave (President St & Carroll St), Brooklyn, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · North Slope · 10 tips and reviews

Rima L.Rima Lukin: Best banana milkshake ever. Seriously mmm

Nate F.Nate Folkert: stracciatella gelato brownie a la mode sundae

LindaLinda: Nice staff, great staff

Stur-Dee Health Foods is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Shakes in Brooklyn.

3. Stur-Dee Health Foods

222 Livingston St (Elm & Hoyt St.), Brooklyn, NY
Gourmet Store · Downtown Brooklyn · 14 tips and reviews

Kevin P.Kevin Postler: #4 banana shake large $5.25 plus peanut butter $.50

ValVal: Their dairy free ice cream shakes are amazing. Try the mango. You won't be disappointed.

Ayana L.Ayana Lawall: Try their sot chicken patty! It is remarkable!! :-)

International Restaurant is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Shakes in Brooklyn.

4. International Restaurant

4408 5th Ave (btwn 44th St & 45th St), Brooklyn, NY
Latin American Restaurant · Sunset Park · 12 tips and reviews

LadyMissDiLadyMissDi: The pernil was incredibly tasty & tender. The rice with gandules was also very good. The prices are very affordable. Perfect neighborhood gem!

Sonia G.Sonia Gonzalez: Good Foods

AdrianAdrian: cubano... that is all.

Cafe Hadar is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Shakes in Brooklyn.

5. Cafe Hadar

7.8
2923 Avenue N (29th St), Brooklyn, NY
Restaurant · Midwood · 9 tips and reviews

Deb W.Deb Wunder: The roasted beet salad with added salmon is yummy, as are the stuffed mushroom caps. The peanut butter mousse was the lightest mousse I have ever had.

Gregory B.Gregory Bluvshteyn: French soup is dimly awesome!!!! As well as other soups!!!

Steven W.Steven Weinstock: Gorgeous looking menus courtesy of my company

Caracas Arepa Bar is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Shakes in Brooklyn.

6. Caracas Arepa Bar

291 Grand St (btwn Roebling & Havemeyer St), Brooklyn, NY
Arepa Restaurant · Williamsburg · 218 tips and reviews

Eric H.Eric Holland: Absolutly delicious arepa, get the de pollo!

Real Cheap EatsReal Cheap Eats: The yo-yo gets a sugary makeover at Caracas. Sweet plantains are fried in a cinnamon-spiked plantain batter, then they’re stuffed slightly chewy, fresh cheese and served with honey dipping sauce. Read more.

Cara C.Cara Capello: Is there anything not to like?

Dutch Boy Burger is one of The 7 Best Places for Banana Shakes in Brooklyn.

7. Dutch Boy Burger

6.9
766 Franklin Ave (btwn Lincoln Pl & St. Johns Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Burger Joint · Crown Heights · 120 tips and reviews

Gabriel H.Gabriel Hayes: Delicious milkshakes. Enjoyed the Nutella banana milkshake a lot. Try one of the spiked milkshakes too

Candice R.Candice Rivera: The Dutch boy burger was great, as were the sweet potato fries! Everything was very flavorful and hit the spot, plus a chocolate milkshake, it was a perfect summer night meal!

Chase T.Chase Turner: Blue Cheese and Bacon burger is great. Not sure why people bitch about the price, $8 for a burger with cheese and bacon isn't too bad if you ask me.