Gamla / Old Iceland is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

1. Gamla / Old Iceland

9.1
Laugavegur 72, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Restaurant · Miðborg · 100 tips and reviews

Darshy N.Darshy N: Cozy vibes, authentic eats, they don't lie when they say the lamb in Iceland is the best you'll ever have! Get a taste of both seafood and meat soup by opting for appetizer portions.

Alexis S.Alexis Scherl: The lamb was perhaps the best I've ever eaten. Generous portions, beautifully composed plates with balanced flavor profiles. The restaurant owner's mom bakes the rhubarb cake and the brownies!

Nate M.Nate Meyer: Everything was incredible. Best lamb I've ever had, the cod was excellent and the fish soup was a must.

Icelandic Street Food is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

2. Icelandic Street Food

9.2
Lækjargata 8, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Scandinavian Restaurant · Miðbær · 57 tips and reviews

David v.David van Sunder: The lamb soup was excellent! The proprietor and woman at the front were both extremely nice and generous. A great value & must visit!

Sebastian D.Sebastian Dieguez: Lamb soup in bread bowl !! And they give you free chocolate sweets!

Mlle B.Mlle Bijou: The Shellfish and lamb soups are delicious! There are complimentary desserts and waffles. The staff is wonderfully friendly and welcoming ! Check it out.

Grillmarkaðurinn is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

3. Grillmarkaðurinn

8.8
Lækjargata 2a, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Steakhouse · Miðbær · 172 tips and reviews

Gunnar H.Gunnar Holmsteinn: Locally grown meat, straight from our farmers. The Icelandic Lamb is out of this world, you can taste the blueberries and arctic thyme that they eat during their outdoor life in the wilderness.

Jeff J.Jeff Jenkins: The lamb skewers make a great and succulent appetizer

Faris A.Faris Altorki: The whale steak not to be missed. Also the lamp chops is very delicious 😋

KOL restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

4. KOL restaurant

8.5
Skólavörðustígur 40, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Modern European Restaurant · Miðborg · 49 tips and reviews

David Z.David Z.: Incredible Lamb Salmon & Risotto !!! And don't forget the cheesecake !

Jo R.Jo Rasheed: Great food! Try the duck salad and the Lamb

Urður Á.Urður Árnadóttir: Lamb was great and the scallops as well! Great service and delicious assorted desserts!

SNAPS is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

5. SNAPS

8.7
Þórsgata 1 (Týsgata), Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Bistro · Miðborg · 145 tips and reviews

Pirkka M.Pirkka Maksimainen: Bearnaise lamb, the best lamb I have ever had.

Eric G.Eric G: The lamb was fantastic!

RosalineRosaline: Servers will tell u that the local specialities are a must: lamb & salt cod. Lamb was melt in ur mouth delicious & cooked perfectly. Beef bourguignon was also solid on flavor tho meat was tougher.

Sjávargrillið is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

6. Sjávargrillið

8.9
Skólavörðustíg 14, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Seafood Restaurant · Miðborg · 161 tips and reviews

Victoria W.Victoria Wong: favorite restaurant in Reykjavik. Taste, ambience, service is top notch. I had the lamb and pork belly and it blew me away, and I have had many lamb and pork bellies in my life

Jonathan C.Jonathan Carr-Harris: Incredible food. Be sure to try the tasting menu. The lamb is awesome

Sarah C.Sarah Clifford: Seafood and lamb were amazing!

Austur India Fjelagid is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

7. Austur India Fjelagid

8.7
Hverfisgötu 56, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Indian Restaurant · Miðborg · 27 tips and reviews

Stephen N.Stephen Northcott: Really enjoyed the lamb shank. Amazing. :)

Max M.Max Malm: Amazing lamb shank, best lamb I've ever eaten, maybe the best Indian food as well

JenMJenM: Delicious. Lamb shanks are fantastic. Garlic naan is perfect (not too much garlic). Pricey, but excellent service

Café Loki is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

8. Café Loki

8.2
Lokastígur 28, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Café · Miðborg · 94 tips and reviews

Sad MatzohSad Matzoh: Had a delicious Icelandic sampler platter of mashed fish, smoked trout, smoked lamb, fermented shark, & dried fish. Definitely recommend it, & had a nice schnapps of birsk to complement it afterwards

Tilman B.Tilman Benecke: original islandic kitchen - lamb was delicious - nice friendly staff and a somehow mesmerizing wallpainting

Maikas K.Maikas Katastrofa: Lamb soup is wonderfully spicy and warming. A great addition to that is the lamb pattè on a homemade rye bread. Staff is extremely nice + Free wifi:)

Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

9. Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur

8.5
Tryggvagata 1 (Pósthússtræti), Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Hot Dog Joint · Miðbær · 215 tips and reviews

LaraLara: Awesome lamb hotdogs!

MatthiasMatthias: Iceland’s oldest fast food stand. The hot dogs are made of lamb meat with pork casing, topped with a combination of raw & fried onion, ketchup, mustard & mayo-relish rémoulade on a homemade bun.

MarieMarie: This modest hot dog stand is famous for a reason. Delicious & unique (the dog is mostly lamb). Order up, take a seat at the picnic table, and rest your dog in the whimsical attached holder. So fun!

Sæta Svínið is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

10. Sæta Svínið

8.3
Hafnarstræti 1-3, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Gastropub · Miðbær · 31 tips and reviews

Fulya M.Fulya M: The food was amazing! The service was great! Their lamb is yummmm!

Attila S.Attila Santa: Rack of lamb is perfekt as well as the rib eye steak. Good beers, very kind waiters, highly recommended!

Lina B.Lina Bodestad: Excellent food that won't leave you hungry - the slow-cooked lamb shank and the duck salad were both great.

Forréttabarinn is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

11. Forréttabarinn

9.0
Nýlendugötu 14 (Mýrargata), Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Restaurant · Vesturbær · 52 tips and reviews

Rachel P.Rachel Port: We got the smoked duck, pulled pork bbq quesadilla, lamb skewer, and salmon skewer, which was by far the best salmon dish I've ever had!

Jonas V.Jonas Voss: Cosy place near the harbour with tasty dishes. Their lamb dish is very tasty, and they have a very tasty Icelandic lager from Akureyri.

Brendan H.Brendan Hickey: The set menus were excellent, each offering a mixture of seafood and other dishes (lamb and horse were both delicious).

ROK is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

12. ROK

8.9
Frakkastígur 26a, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Scandinavian Restaurant · Miðborg · 28 tips and reviews

Thomas D.Thomas Dori: Order the lamb and thank me later - it's extraordinarily good👌

Ryan H.Ryan Hartley: Mussels, lamb and the Cod were amazing! Great staff that helped us out with what to buy.

Tina G.Tina Gheorghiu: Must eat the lamb! Amazing!

Íslenski barinn is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

13. Íslenski barinn

8.6
Ingólfsstræti 1a, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Scandinavian Restaurant · Miðborg · 50 tips and reviews

MatthiasMatthias: Traditional Icelandic food in a friendly, cosy bar also popular among the locals. The pick of this place would be the Kjötsúpa - Icelandic meat soup - a hearty bowl of lamb soup with rye bread.

D F.D F: This place is in the league of it's own. The appetizer platter is filling for 2 people. House beer is magnificent. Lamb shank is melting in your mouth and if you still have space for dessert...

D F.D F: This place is in the league of it's own. The appetizer platter is filling for 2 people. House beer is magnificent. Lamb shank is melting in your mouth.

Apótek Bar Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

14. Apótek Bar Grill

8.5
Austurstræti 16, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Bar · Miðbær · 54 tips and reviews

Javi L.Javi Lorbada: Lax Salmon is definitely a dish worth to try, out of the chart. The Lamb is also a fantastic choice, it comes accompanied with a great sauces combination. The service made it an incredible dinner.

Nicholas M.Nicholas M.: Lamb leg and salmon v good. Desserts interesting. One of the better fine dining establishments in Reykjavik.

David B.David Blurton: Just consistently great. Cocktails are fantastic - happy hour 4pm-6pm. Recommendations: Lamb steak, fish of the day, Sunday roast.

Matur og Drykkur is one of The 15 Best Places for Lamb in Reykjavik.

15. Matur og Drykkur

8.5
Grandagarður 2, Reykjavík, Höfuðborgarsvæði
Modern European Restaurant · Vesturbær · 27 tips and reviews

Lainie G.Lainie Green: You have to try the lamb entrée it might've been the most tender and succulent piece of meat.

Nicholas M.Nicholas M.: Arctic char preparation v good. Smoked trout excellent. Bread great. Halibut soup good in concept but broth was flavorless milk; Lamb leg +heart uninspired; white chocolate skyr dessert saccharine.

Daniel M.Daniel Mejia: The lamb dish and the catch of the day (salmon) were both incredible!!!