Bajco T. • November 1, 2014Classic homey and romantic place. Used to love the onions topping but recently it seems different onions are used. But pizza still great! Love going in the wintertime to sit in front of the fireplace.
Stephanie W. • January 9, 2012My absolute favorite pizza place in Califon. Great service, friendly atmosphere, amazing food. A must eat place.
Amber V. • December 28, 2014Amazing fettucini Alfredo. Great for both small family dinners and large gatherings!
Corinne P. • January 10, 2012Traditional Italian fare, Nicola's has been a neighborhood favorite for years. The place is a little tired, but the food, especially the fish, is excellent.
Caroline S. • February 12, 2011Try the Chilean Sea Bass Nicola. It's a large portion, perfectly cooked, and amazing with spinach.
Nick O. • June 12, 2014One of the benefits of working from home today: fantastic prosciutto sandwich for lunch.
amoolia • March 25, 2011I don't even live in midtown anymore but we still come here for prosciutto. And you can't beat the service.
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.