Arman R. • June 12, 2011A great pizza joint, but not by the slice. where nicola's excels is in their cheesesteak and hoagie department. get an Italian hoagie grinder
Stephanie W. • January 9, 2012My absolute favorite pizza place in Califon. Great service, friendly atmosphere, amazing food. A must eat place.
Amber V. • December 28, 2014Amazing fettucini Alfredo. Great for both small family dinners and large gatherings!
Corinne P. • January 10, 2012Traditional Italian fare, Nicola's has been a neighborhood favorite for years. The place is a little tired, but the food, especially the fish, is excellent.
Caroline S. • February 12, 2011Try the Chilean Sea Bass Nicola. It's a large portion, perfectly cooked, and amazing with spinach.
Nick O. • June 12, 2014One of the benefits of working from home today: fantastic prosciutto sandwich for lunch.
amoolia • March 25, 2011I don't even live in midtown anymore but we still come here for prosciutto. And you can't beat the service.
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.