Suggestions for Pizzeria near Sarasota

Carol D. • June 22, 2012Jimmy Is a wonderful owner/manager. The baked shells with cheese and tomato sauce, Greek salad and garlic bread are delicious!

Jamie O. • July 11, 2013By far the best pizza I've had in Sarasota. Reminded me of my summers at the Jersey shore. Can't wait to go back!

Rory P. • February 5, 2022Start with the Origin salad then some mango habanero wings and then the barbershop pizza

Gregorio B. • July 21, 2020The calzones are excellent. Recommend the Chicago deep dish as well.

B T. • July 23, 2017Vegetariano, Wedding Soup, Mussels! Service was outstanding. Kevin was the best server and Gulie, the manager was so attentive!

Tommi O. • December 14, 2016Do yourself a favor try the soup. Authentic. Now get the parm, lasagna or ziti- the best Pizza. Quick service lots of table space and good prices.

Christian Z. • October 28, 2012Bacon Turkey Wrap is my go to. Live music on Sunday AM is fun.

Ariane H. • February 8, 2014Nice decor now. It was formerly the Blue Owl & Box Social. Though I miss those 2 "dive-y" bars, I'm glad for the renovation. They now have a new and improved beer list!

Mrugesh P. • March 2, 2013Best and most respected pizzeria on Main Street. Regular for their lunch special as it's a close walk from the Selby Library, my current study residence.

Ankush K. • February 9, 2019Great pizzas!

Sue R. • February 21, 2013Great place to eat and it's an easy walk from the Hyatt Regency. This is our second time here and we knew we would have dinner here tonight while we were flying in from Ohio. Great pizza & service!

Sarah C. • May 15, 2010The eggplant, ricotta and basil pizza is the best!

Count Cory B. • March 5, 2014Pizza is incredible. Go for the Grandmas Sicilian or try Tortellini di Nonna. Very casual place. Great quality.

Melissa C. • December 19, 2015Pizza so yummy and great $ Greek salad is huge with great dressing

Darcie L. • September 5, 2013Great pizza and service! Favorite by far!

Leslie R. • April 28, 2014Best pizza I've ever had at Papas and the manager Vinny is the bomb

Anne S. • June 3, 2018Pizza is delicious. I prefer plain cheese well done or eggplant pizza well done. Yum!

Tom S. • July 17, 2018Pizza and beer

Tom G. • July 12, 2014This is my new "go to" place for pizza. It's awesome and you simply have to try it.

Debbie S. • December 27, 2016The Pizza is to die for! So fresh, so hot and tons of toppings!

Emilio C. • November 6, 2014It's like the chipotle of pizza. Go for unlimited toppings and add multiple cheeses. Some of the toppings are super premium! Oh, and get the fra-diavolo pizza sauce!

Lori M. • March 1, 2015A fabulous bake case full of rich desserts.

Holly L. • October 31, 2017Loved the crispy, grilled wings~ !!

Debbie M. • October 14, 2013Good food.

Eric C. • April 16, 2015Best thin crust pizza in town !

A M. • May 12, 2014I got carry out and the pizza was awesome. Try the white pizza with jalapeño. My new pizza place for siesta!