PureWow • December 18, 2015This is the joint created by Patsy Lancieri, Grimaldi’s uncle. Patsy’s changed owners in 1991, but the thin-crust, coal oven pie at its original East Harlem location is one of the best in the city.
Russell B. • September 3, 2013Great pizza and great chicken parm. Skip the eggplant parm. Also no veal parm on menu.
Josh W. • November 20, 2009OK, battlestations: Time to throw down for the best pizza. Lombardi's, Patsy's, Grimaldi's -- whatever. This is the stuff. Tell your friends. (Bleecker St. only, please.)
Danielle T. • May 1, 2013The Pappardelle alla Toscana is one of the best things I have ever eaten. The fried zucchini & eggplant w/ garlic yogurt sauce is great too!
Emily I. • March 20, 2010Calzones are great (my favorite.) Cesar salad could use a bit more dressing but the calzone makes up for it!
Gordon L. • July 5, 2013Best pizza in Manhattan. Yes, I know, that's a big claim. But check it out. Right under the David Letterman sign. Similar to Patsy's on W. 74th and Grimaldi's in Brooklyn, but this Angelo's is #1.
Jeff Y. • December 12, 2009Seems like Patsy's? It used to be, before a franchising dispute. Same menu, actually better!
Naomi • October 8, 2015Great, simple slices. Way better than Freddie & Peppers or Patsy's, so I'm dubbing La Traviata my fave UWS slice.
Ann D. • July 17, 2017More than just pizza - we also had salads, pasta and meat dishes - all very good.
Leah T. • March 24, 2013Why isn't this place at the top of every "best pizza place" list? Honestly, I've been to Patsy's, Lombardi's, etc. this pizza is superior.
Genie A. • September 7, 2014If you want good pizza, DO NOT go to this place. Check out Joe's pizza in in Union Square or Patsy's all around town. Bleecker Street Pizza is NOT worth it. Actually gross and a disappointment.
Marilyn S. • July 9, 2013Yuck! I had the signature artichoke slice. Very thick and very big. Much too greasy and heavy for my stomach! The grease dripped all over my pants. For classic NY pizza, try Grimaldi's or Patsy's.
Nelson D. • July 5, 2013Put your name on the waiting list (1 hr wait) and then go eat elsewhere. Try Patsy's Brick Oven Pizza across the street, then go back to S3 just in time for dessert.
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.