Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Update:The City Guide web experience will be sunsetting on April 28, 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more.
Read more
Madfish Grill

Madfish Grill

American Restaurant and Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Sarasota
Save
Share
Madfish Grill
8.0/10
56
ratings
Photos27 Photos
MenuMenu
Wine & Beer 17Spirits & Cocktails 3Dinner Menu 8Gluten Free 4Brunch 10Lunch Menu 9Lunch Fish 3Early Bird 1Desserts & Coffee 3Kids Menu 5Sunset Happy Hour 4
Wine List
Whites and Pinks
Sparkling
Coastal Vines, Brut Cuvee, California
9.00
Mumm 'Cuvee M', Napa
74.00
Perrier Jouet, Grand Brut, France
97.00
Ruffino, Prosecco, Italy
7.30
Iron Horse, Green Valley of Russian River, Sonoma
96.00
Intriguing Wines
Cupcake, Riesling, Mosel Valley, Germany
7.90
Sonoma Cutrer, Rose of Pinot Noir, Winemaker's Release
54.00
Louis Jadot, Rose, Burgundy, France
36.00
Jaffurs, Viognier, Bien Nacido Vineyard, Santa Barbara
63.00
Pinot Grigio / Gris
Caposaldo, Pinot Grigio, Italy
7.30
Lange, Pinot Gris, Willamette Valley, Oregon
12.30
Banfi, "Le Rime" Pinot Grigio, Toscano, Italy
8.30
King Estate, Pinot Gris, Oregon
51.00
Sauvignon Blanc
Brancott, New Zealand
8.50
Kim Crawford, Marlborough, New Zealand
39.00
Murphy Goode, "the Fume", North Coast California
34.00
Sterling, Napa Valley
9.50
Chardonnay
Chloe, Sonoma County
7.50
Murphy Goode, Sonoma
9.50
Jadot, Pouilly-Fuisse, France
70.00
Kendall Jackson, California
9.90
Sonoma Cutrer, Russian River
13.90
Reds
Intriguing Reds
Alta Vista, Malbec, Argentina
7.90
Kendall Jackson, Summation, California
40.00
Ernesto Catena, "Siesta", Malbec, Mendoza
55.00
Terrazas, Malbec Reserva 2014, Mendoza
10.30
Conundrum, Red Blend, California
66.00
Jaffurs, Syrah, Santa Barbara
63.00
Zinfandel
Joel Gott, California
11.50
Seghesio, Sonoma
56.00
Murphy Goode, "Liar's Dice", California
54.00
Pinot Noir
Mark West, Central Coast California
8.90
Willamette Valley Vineyards, Oregon
53.00
Ron Rubin, Russian River Valley
53.00
David Bruce, Russian River
83.00
La Crema, Sonoma
13.90
Meiomi, California
11.90
Penner-Ash, Willamette Valley
75.00
Cabernet Sauvignon
Hahn, California
9.70
Beringer, Knights Valley
53.00
Hall, Napa Valley
102.00
Tom Gore, California
10.50
Jackson Estate, Alexander Valley
60.00
Silver Oak, Alexander Valley
137.00
Merlot
Blackstone, California
7.90
Alexander Valley Vineyards, "Estate"
56.00
Beer
On Tap
Brooklyn Brown Ale
Harpoon Ipa
Miller Lite
Michelob Ultra
Circus City Ipa
Stella Artois
Yuengling
Islamorada Ale
By the Bottle
Amstel Light
Bud
Coors Light
Corona Light
Miller Lite
Red Stripe
Sierra Nevada
New Belgium Glutiny
Beck's Non Alcoholic
O'douls Non Alcoholic
Blue Moon Belgian Wheat
Bud Light
Corona
Guinness
Newcastle
Sam Adams
Stella Artois
Angry Orchard
Kaliber Non Alcoholic
Classic Cocktails
$10.90 each, $8.90 during happiest hours 4-6pm
007 Martini
Svedka vodka chilled up + olives
The French 75
Named after the 75-millimeter MI897 artillery piece from WWI. The lightweight gun was powerful with quick results, just like this cocktail! champagne + damrak gin + lemon
Negroni
Damrak gin + campari + sweet vermouth + orange twist
Michter's Manhattan
Michter's rye + sweet vermouth + bitters + filthy cherry
Hand Crafted Whiskey Sour
Michter's american whiskey + fresh citrus juice + sugar + frothy egg whites
One Bourbon, One Scotch, One Whiskey
Basil Hayden
12.50
Buffalo Trace
8.90
Larceny
9.50
Knob Creek
12.90
1792 Ridgemont Reserve
8.50
Balvenie 17 Year "Madeira Cask"
25.90
Glenlivet 12 Year
12.50
Maccallan 12 Year
13.90
Scapa 11 Year
14.10
Michter's Rye Whiskey
9.70
Jack Daniel's Single Barrel
11.90
High West Small Batch American Whiskeys
Tasting Flights Available $14
Rendezvous Rye
14.90
Straight Rye Blend * Batch #15H21
Campfire
15.90
Bourbon, Rye, Scotch Blend. Batch # 16B25
Blanton's Single Barrel
13.10
Bulleit
9.70
Maker's Mark
11.20
Woodford Reserve
11.50
Balvenie 12 Year "Doublewood"
14.90
Glenfiddich 12 Year
10.90
Glenmorangie 10 Year
12.50
Maccallan 15 Year "Fine Oak"
17.90
Michter's American Whiskey
9.70
Sam Houston American Whiskey
9.50
Gentleman Jack
11.20
American Prairie
10.90
Straight Bourbon Blend. Batch #1546
Double Rye
11.90
Straight Rye Blend. Batch #15R23
Classic Cocktails
Negroni
9.90
The origins of this drink trace back to 1919 in Florence, Italy. Count Camillo Negroni, an Italian nobleman, took his favorite cocktail, the Americano, and gave it a bit more "kick" by adding gin Ungava Gin + Campari + Sweet Vermouth + Orange Twist
The French 75
9.90
Named after the 75-millimeter MI897 artillery piece from WWI. The lightweight gun was powerful with quick results, just like this cocktail! Champagne + Ungava Gin + Lemon
House Sangria
6.90
Red wine, blackberry brandy + fresh squeezed juices
Michter's Manhattan
9.90
Folklore suggests that this cocktail originated at the Manhattan Club in New York City, in the 1870's. It was created for Lady Randolph Churchill (Winston's mum) Michter's Rye + Sweet Vermouth + Bitters + Filthy Cherry
Classic Whiskey Sour
9.90
Did you know that Admiral Edward Vernon created this iconic drink to save his sailors? Utilizing rations like lemons, to prevent scurvy, and liquor he created something safe for them to drink. Michter's American Whiskey + fresh citrus juice + sugar + frothy egg whites
Madfish Cocktails
$9.90
Dog Bite
Svedka grapefruit-jalapeno vodka, grapefruit juice, grenadine + ice
Joe's Mojito (the Joejito!)
Muddled mint, lime, simple syrup, white rum, soda water + ice
Eric's Watermelon Martini
Vodka, watermelon, gran gala + cranberry juice
White Chocolate Martini
Godiva White Chocolate, vanilla vodka + chocolate laced glass
Snickertini
Caramel vodka, Godiva chocolate, Frangelico + a splash of cream
Superfruit Margarita
Tequila, triple sec, lime juice, acai berry + ice
Jon's Mad Mai Tai
Light rum, dark rum, orgeat syrup, triple sec, pineapple, oj + ice
Brendan's Espresso Martini
Vanilla Vodka, dark cocao + espresso
Blue Pomegranate Martini
Blueberry vodka, sour mix + pomegranate
Hawaiian Martini
Vodka, Malibu rum + pineapple splash
Appetizers
Escargot*
10.90
Garlic, herbs, butter, mushrooms + swiss cheese (Gluten Free when ordered with no bread)
Crispy Thai Calamari
11.90
Rhode island harvested + sweet chili sauce
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
16.90
Our decadent, jumbo lump crab cake + remoulade
Benny Jamaica's Jerk Wings
11.90
Jerk glazed wings, creamy herb sauce
Caprese Board*
9.90
Heirloom tomatoes, basil, fresh mozzarella, mixed greens, xvoo, sea salt, reduced balsamic + crostinis (Gluten Free when ordered with no crostinis)
Bang Shrimp
10.90
Crispy wild caught shrimp, sriracha bang sauce + greens
Caribbean Egg Rolls
8.90
Jerked chicken, rice, black beans, cilantro, cheese + guava jelly, avocado ranch
Pan Seared Tuna Tataki*
10.90
Sliced spicy RARE tuna, wasabi peas, pickled ginger, blackening spice, ponzu + cusabi drizzle (Gluten Free with no ponzu or wasabi peas)
Coco Mac Shrimp
14.90
Coconut-macadamia crust + orange ginger marmalade
Hand Helds
Blackened Gulf Grouper Sandwich
Lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar, kaiser roll + fries (seasonally available)
The Key West Fish Sandwich
14.90
Crunchy tempura battered whitefish, cuban roll, lettuce, tomato, onion + fries
The Brendan Burger
13.90
Fresh chuck blackened, smothered with blue cheese, applewood smoked bacon, frizzled onions + fries
Blackened Mahi Tacos*
14.90
Spicy blackened mahi, lettuce, pico de gallo, cilantro slaw, chipotle aioli, cheddar-jack + rice & beans (Gluten Free when ordered with corn tortillas)
Soup Or Salad
Small Salads
Blt Wedge
6.90
Caesar
4.90
Kale Beet & Goat Cheese Salad
9.90
Madhouse Salad
4.90
4059 Cuban Salad
5.90
Scratch Soups
Mangospacho
4.90
Drunken Lobster Bisque
5.90
Vegetarian Black Bean & Rice
4.90
Crab & Corn Chowder
5.90
Bowls
Salmon & Kale Salad*
20.90
Grilled salmon, baby kale, roasted beets, chevre, candied sunflower seeds + citrus vinaigrette
St. Croix Shrimp Salad
19.90
Coco mac shrimp, greens, mango, pineapple, yuca, blue cheese crumbles + mandarin dressing (a cult favorite)
Spicy Soba-Salmon Bowl
15.90
Pan seared salmon, panang peanut curry, chilled soba noodles, cilantro + papaya slaw
Grouper Carciofi*
21.90
Sautéed grouper medallions, artichoke hearts, tomato, white wine, lemon over jasmine rice + basil (seasonally available)
Pasta Martinique*
26.90
Scallops, wild gulf shrimp, lump crab, creamy tomato-basil sauce, penne + parmesan (Gluten Free when ordered over jasmine rice)
Quesadilla Chopped Salad
15.90
Chargrilled chicken, corn, tortilla strips, black beans, cheddar-jack cheese, pico de gallo, avocado ranch, honey-balsamic vinaigrette, chopped romaine + cheese quesadilla wedges
Bang Shrimp Bowl
14.90
Crispy wild gulf shrimp, bang sauce, fried rice, asian vegetables + cilantro
Poke Tuna Bowl
16.90
Diced sushi grade tuna, spicy Hawaiian poke sauce, jasmine rice + avocado
Gulf Shrimp Scampi*
22.90
Usa harvested wild gulf of mexico shrimp, garlic, butter, wine, lemon, blistered tomatoes, fresh herbs, linguini + garlic crostini (Gluten Free over jasmine rice with no crostini)
Chicken Mad Thai
17.90
Pad thai rice noodles, chicken, edamame, onions, peppers, carrots, fried egg, cilantro, toasted cashews + spicy panang peanut sauce
The Chalkboard
The Chalkboard
Check out the chalkboards for our available fresh catch! Served with Jasmine rice and steamed broccoli and a choice of accompanying sauces
Large Plates
Coco Mac Chicken
18.90
Pan fried coconut-macadamia crusted chicken breast, mango-chili sauce, jasmine rice + broccoli
Filet Mignon*
26.90
Chargrilled, mashed potatoes + asparagus
Hand Battered Fish & Chips
16.90
Grouper (seasonally available - mkt)
Cedar Planked Salmon*
24.90
Maine salmon roasted on cedar, barbeque glaze, asparagus + mashed potatoes
Coco Mac Shrimp
24.90
Our famous coconut-macadamia shrimp, orange ginger marmalade, jasmine rice + broccoli
Flat Iron Steak*
19.90
Chargrilled, mashed potatoes + chef's vegetables
Lump Crab Cake
27.90
(original all jumbo lump recipe) jumbo lump blue crab, remoulade sauce, steamed broccoli + jasmine rice
Pan Seared New England Cod*
19.90
Fresh lemon, olive oil & butter, sautéed spinach + mashed potatoes
Fried Whole Belly Clams
Fresh Ipswich clams! ½ pound flash fried, fries, tartar + cole slaw
Seafood Pie
29.90
(our house favorite for over 17 years) maine lobster, shrimp, scallops, sherry cream, scallions, mushrooms, fresh baked puff pastry + mashed potatoes, vegetables
Gluten Free
some items available with lunch / early bird portions and pricing
"Bacon & Eggs" Deviled Eggs
5.90
Made w/ love + spicy sriracha drizzle
Cheese Board
11.90
Ask for today's selection served with fresh fruit + crackers (Gluten free when ordered with rice crackers)
Escargot
10.90
Garlic, herbs, butter, mushrooms + swiss cheese (Gluten free when ordered with no bread)
Chicken & Mushroom Pâté
8.90
Chicken liver, crimini mushrooms, cognac, shallot, dressed greens, pickled onion + crostinis (Gluten free when ordered with rice crackers)
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
2.90
Chilled Gulf of Mexico whites, lemon + house made cocktail sauce
Pan Seared Tuna Tataki
10.90
Sliced spicy RARE tuna, wasabi peas, pickled ginger, blackening spice, ponzu + cusabi drizzle (Gluten free with no ponzu or wasabi peas)
Bowls
Salmon & Kale Salad
19.90
Grilled salmon, baby kale, roasted beets, chevre, candied sunflower seeds + citrus vinaigrette
Pasta Martinique
23.90
Scallops, wild Gulf shrimp, crab, creamy tomato-basil sauce, penne + Parmesan (Gluten free when ordered over jasmine rice)
Gulf Shrimp Scampi
21.90
Usa harvested wild gulf of mexico shrimp, garlic, butter, wine, lemon, blistered tomatoes, fresh herbs, linguini + garlic crostini (Gluten free over jasmine rice with no crostini
Large Plates
Flat Iron Steak
18.90
Chargrilled, mashed potatoes + chef's vegetables
Cedar Planked Salmon
22.90
Atlantic salmon roasted on cedar, barbeque glaze, asparagus + mashed potatoes
Blackened Mahi Tacos
14.90
Spicy blackened mahi, lettuce, pico de gallo, cilantro slaw, chipotle aioli, cheddar-jack + rice & beans (Gluten free when ordered with corn tortillas)
Hand Cut Filet Mignon
24.90
Chargrilled, mashed potatoes + asparagus
Grouper Carciofi
21.90
Sautéed grouper medallions, artichoke hearts, tomato, white wine, lemon over jasmine rice + basil (seasonally available)
Fresh Catch
Fish availability varies, please call for today's catch! All of our fresh fish may be prepared grilled, Jamaican jerk spiced or blackened and are served with Jasmine rice and steamed broccoli and your choice of sauces: creamy lemon-butter, thai chili sauce, mango chili sauce or infused herb oil
Gulf Red Grouper
American Red Snapper
Atlantic Salmon
Tilapia
Maine Lobster Tails
Mahi Mahi
Cobia
Alaskan Coho Salmon
Rainbow Trout
Ahi Tuna
Eggs
The Traditional Breakfast
8.90
Two eggs, bacon or sausage, wheat toast + home fries, fruit or cheddar-jack grits
Scramble Bowl
8.90
Scrambled eggs, bacon, cheddar cheese over home fries + scallion
Southern Comfort Breakfast
10.90
A hearty platter of two eggs your style, scratch biscuit, sausage gravy, grilled ham steak + cheddar-jack grits
Huevos Rancheros
10.90
Two fried eggs, crispy corn tortillas, shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, black beans, cheese + home fries, fruit or cheddar-jack grits
Breakfast Burrito
10.90
Scrambled eggs, sausage, peppers, onions, tomato, flour tortilla, smothered with ranchero sauce & cheese + home fries, fruit or cheddar-jack grits
Our Famous Quiche
Decadent Homemade Three Cheese + Fresh Fruit
9.90
Quiche of the Day + Fresh Fruit
Omelettes
The Frenchman's Omelette
10.90
Country ham, brie, wheat toast + home fries, fruit or cheddar-jack grits
Mediterranean Omelette
10.90
Spinach, blistered tomatoes, goat cheese, wheat toast + home fries, fruit or cheddar-jack grits
"the Hippy" Omelette
10.90
Egg white omelette, spinach, portobello mushroom, blistered tomatoes, smoked gouda, basil, wheat toast + home fries, fruit or cheddar-jack grits
"Three Little Piggies" Omelette
11.90
Sausage, country ham, bacon, smoked gouda, green onions, toast + home fries, fruit or cheddar-jack grits
Benedicts
All Eggs Benedict are served on an English muffin with poached eggs, hollandaise + home fries
"Traditional", Canadian Bacon
9.90
"the American", Tomato & Bacon
10.90
"Tenderloin", Sliced Filet Mignon
16.90
"the Myakka" Benedict
10.90
Scratch biscuits topped with sausage gravy, poached eggs, tomato & smoked bacon
"Veggie", Portobello, Spinach & Tomato
11.90
"the Jumbo Lump", Crab Cake
17.90
"Pastrami Salmon", Onion & Tomato
14.90
Sweets
Make your Waffle or French Toast even more delicious with one of these scrumptious toppings: Fresh Strawberry Compote +$1, Vermont Maple Syrup +$1 or Bourbon Barrel Maple Syrup +$2
Warm Housemade Belgian Waffle
8.90
Whipped cream topped + sausage or bacon & home fries, fruit or grits
Almond Crusted French Toast
9.90
Crunchy almond crust, cinnamon + sausage or bacon & home fries, fruit or grits
Brioche French Toast
8.90
Egg dipped, cinnamon + sausage or bacon & home fries, fruit or grits
Odds & Ends
One Egg Your Way
1.90
Fresh Baked Croissant
2.90
With fig preserves
New York Everything Bagel + Cream Cheese
3.50
The Trifecta
8.90
Country ham, breakfast sausage + bacon plate
Scratch Biscuit & Sausage Gravy
3.90
Side of Fruit, Home Fries Or Grits
1.90
Gluten Free Toast
1.90
Yogurt Parfait
5.90
Greek yogurt, granola + fresh berry compote
Pastrami Salmon Platter
12.90
Pastrami style smoked salmon, tomato, caper, red onion, cream cheese + fresh baked everything bagel
Avocado Toast
6.90
Wheat toast, mashed avocado, sea salt, xvoo
Sharables
"Bacon & Eggs" Deviled Eggs
5.90
Made w/ love + spicy sriracha drizzle
Bang Shrimp
10.90
Crispy wild caught shrimp, sriracha bang sauce + greens
House Smoked Fish Dip
8.90
Pico de gallo, greens + crostinis
Caribbean Egg Rolls
8.90
Jerked chicken, rice, black beans, cilantro, cheese + guava jelly, avocado ranch
Benny Jamaica's Jerk Wings
11.90
Jerk glazed wings, creamy herb sauce
Chicken & Mushroom Pâté
9.90
Chicken liver, crimini mushrooms, cognac, shallot, dressed greens, pickled onion + crostinis (Gluten Free when ordered with rice crackers)
Sandwiches
All sandwiches are served with fries, fresh fruit or cole slaw. Avocado may be added to any sandwich for $1.90
Fried Green Brie.L.T.
11.90
Fried green tomato, applewood smoked bacon, brie, baby lettuce, chipotle aioli + Brioche roll
Roasted Vegetable Sandwich
10.90
Portobello, roasted pepper, blistered tomato, wilted spinach, brie, pesto aioli + baguette
Blackened Mahi Tacos
12.90
Spicy blackened mahi, shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, cilantro slaw, chipotle aioli, cheddar-jack + black beans & rice
The Key West Fish Sandwich
13.90
Crunchy tempura battered whitefish, lettuce, tomato, onion + fresh Cuban roll
The Brendan Burger
12.90
Blackened ground chuck, blue cheese, bacon, frizzled onions + kaiser roll
The Cermak's Chicken Sandwich
10.90
Grilled chicken, bacon, smoked gouda, lettuce, tomato, onion, chipotle mayo + kaiser roll
Turkey Rachael
10.90
Turkey breast, Swiss cheese, cole slaw, Russian dressing + grilled rye bread
The Ultimate Cuban
10.90
Pressed ham, pork, Swiss cheese, mustard, pickles + fresh baked Cuban bread
Blackened Grouper Sandwich
Spicy Gulf grouper, lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar + kaiser roll (seasonally available)
Authentic New England Clam Roll
Totally authentic Ipswich clams! griddled New England roll + cole slaw
Mombo Jumbo Burger
9.90
Fresh ground chuck, chargrilled or blackened, lettuce, tomato, onion + kaiser roll
Greens
St. Croix Shrimp Salad
17.90
Our cult favorite! coco mac shrimp, greens, mango, pineapple, yuca, blue cheese crumbles + mandarin dressing
Grilled Salmon Spinach Salad
16.90
Baby spinach, warm Vidalia onion dressing, apples, cucumbers, tomatoes, blue cheese + bacon
Southern Chicken Cobb Salad
12.90
Fried chicken, bacon, pico de gallo, boiled egg, cheddar-jack, lettuce + honey mustard vinaigrette (Gluten free when ordered with grilled chicken)
Beverages & Desserts
Natalie's Fresh Squeezed
3.90
Fresh squeezed local orange or grapefruit juice
Assorted Hot Teas
3.00
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie
6.90
Rick's "to die for" secret recipe + whipped cream
Ball Jar Cheesecake
4.90
+ seasonal berries
Chocolate Lava Cake
6.90
Warm molten chocolate cake, vanilla ice cream + whipped cream
Bete Noir
5.90
A classic flourless dark chocolate cake, white chocolate drizzle + raspberry sauce
Key Lime Pie
5.90
A "quintessential" Florida favorite Graham cracker crust + whipped cream
Endless Cup of Coffee
3.00
Cold Brew Coffee
3.90
Whole milk, cream or almond milk available
Crispy Bread Pudding Bites
5.90
Vanilla ice cream, whipped cream + caramel
Créme Brulee
5.90
Classic Vanilla Bean
Mounds Bar Sundae
6.90
Coconut ice cream, bete noir, whipped cream + chocolate sauce
Mezzo Forte
5.90
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, caramel sauce, cashews, coconut + whipped cream
Fresh Soup & Inspired Pairings
Pick Any 2 for $9.90 (No Sides Included)
½ Hand Held
Toasted Blt Or Ham & Swiss Or Turkey On Wheat Bread Cuban
+$1
Blackened Mahi Taco
+$3
Grilled Chicken Taco
+$1
Cup of Soup
Black Bean
Soup of the Day
Lobster Bisque
+$1
Mangospacho
Crab & Corn Chowder
+$1
Small Salads
Madhouse
4059 Salad
+$1
Caesar
Kale, Beet & Goat Cheese Salad
+$2
House Made Soups
Vegetarian Black Bean Soup
4.90
Cuban style + rice, sour cream, onion
Chef's Inspiration
Made with love daily
Drunken Lobster Bisque
5.90
Sherry wine infused + basil oil
Chilled Mangospacho
4.90
Sweet and spicy + sour cream
Crab & Corn Chowder
5.90
Blue crab, sweet corn, cream + secret seasonings
Bowls & Greens
Southern Chicken Cobb Salad
12.90
Fried chicken, bacon, pico de gallo, boiled egg, cheddar-jack, lettuce + honey mustard vinaigrette (Gluten free when ordered with grilled chicken)
St. Croix Shrimp Salad
17.90
Our cult favorite! coco mac shrimp, greens, mango, pineapple, yuca, blue cheese crumbles + mandarin dressing
Kale, Beet & Goat Cheese Salad
10.90
Baby kale, roasted beets, chevre, candied sunflower seeds + citrus vinaigrette
Grilled Salmon Spinach Salad
16.90
Baby spinach, warm Vidalia onion dressing, apples, cucumbers, tomatoes, blue cheese + bacon
Chicken Mad Thai Bowl
12.90
Pad Thai rice noodles, chicken, edamame, onions, peppers, carrots, fried egg, cilantro, toasted cashews + spicy panang peanut sauce
Spicy Soba-Salmon Bowl
14.90
Pan seared salmon, panang peanut curry, chilled soba noodles, cilantro + papaya slaw
Asian Chicken Salad
12.90
Lettuce, Napa cabbage, carrots, bell pepper, cilantro, edamame, wontons, sesame seeds, crispy noodles, chopped chicken + spicy Thai peanut dressing
Caprese Board
9.90
Heirloom tomatoes, basil, fresh mozzarella, mixed greens, xvoo, sea salt, reduced balsamic + crostinis (Gluten Free when ordered with no crostinis)
4059 Salad
10.90
Iceberg, ham, Swiss cheese, Parmesan, tomato, green olives, Cuban vinaigrette (Gluten Free when ordered with balsamic vinaigrette)
Quesadilla Chopped Salad
13.90
Chargrilled chicken breast, corn, tortilla strips, black beans, cheddar-jack cheese, pico de gallo, romaine garnished with a cheese quesadilla + avocado ranch & honey-balsamic vinaigrette
Bang Shrimp Bowl
13.90
Crispy shrimp, bang sauce, fried rice, Asian vegetables + cilantro
Poke Tuna Bowl
15.90
Diced sushi grade tuna, spicy Hawaiian poke sauce, warm jasmine rice + avocado
Hand Helds
Hand Helds come with a choice of homemade potato chips, cole slaw, fresh fruit or fries (Mahi Tacos come with rice & beans unless ordered differently). Avocado may be added to any sandwich for $1.90
Turkey Rachael
10.90
Turkey breast, Swiss cheese, cole slaw, Russian dressing + grilled rye bread
Turkey Pesto Panini
11.90
Turkey breast, gouda, roasted red peppers, pesto mayo + pressed baguette
The Ultimate Cuban
10.90
Pressed ham, pork, Swiss cheese, mustard, pickles + fresh baked Cuban bread
Mombo Jumbo Burger
9.90
Fresh ground chuck, chargrilled or blackened, lettuce, tomato, onion + kaiser roll
Blackened Mahi Tacos
12.90
Spicy blackened mahi, lettuce, pico de gallo, cilantro slaw, chipotle aioli, cheddar-jack + rice & beans (Gluten Free with corn tortillas)
The Key West Fish Sandwich
13.90
Crunchy tempura battered whitefish, lettuce, tomato, onion + fresh Cuban roll
Roasted Vegetable Sandwich
10.90
Portobello, roasted pepper, blistered tomato, wilted spinach, brie, pesto aioli + baguette
Fried Green Brie.L.T.
11.90
Fried green tomato, applewood smoked bacon, brie, baby lettuce, chipotle aioli + Brioche roll
The Cermak's Chicken Sandwich
10.90
Grilled chicken, bacon, smoked gouda, lettuce, tomato, onion, chipotle mayo + kaiser roll
The Brendan Burger
12.90
Fresh ground chuck blackened, blue cheese, bacon, frizzled onions
Blackened Grouper Sandwich
Spicy Gulf grouper, lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar + kaiser roll (seasonally available)
Authentic New England Clam Roll
Totally authentic Ipswich clams! griddled New England roll + cole slaw
Other Lunch Notions
Build Your Own Omelette
9.90
Two eggs + choose 3: cheddar-jack, Swiss, Gouda, tomato, mushroom, spinach, bacon, ham or turkey + wheat toast & fruit
Fish N Chips
11.99
Hand battered & fried, fries, slaw + tartar. Gulf Grouper - Mkt Price
Pan Seared Tuna Tataki
10.90
Blackened, ginger, ponzu + cusabi drizzle (Gluten free with no ponzu or wasabi peas)
Crispy Thai Calamari
11.90
Rhode island harvested + sweet chili sauce
"Coco-Loco" Shrimp Appetizer
14.90
Coconut-macadamia crusted shrimp served with an orange marmalade dipping sauce
"Bacon & Eggs" Deviled Eggs
5.90
Made w/ love + spicy sriracha drizzle
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
16.90
Our decadent, jumbo lump crab cake + remoulade
Benny Jamaica's Jerk Wings
11.90
Jerk glazed wings, creamy herb sauce
Bang Shrimp
10.90
Crispy wild caught shrimp, sriracha bang sauce + greens
Caribbean Egg Rolls
8.90
Jerked chicken, rice, black beans, cilantro, cheese + guava jelly, avocado ranch
Our Famous Quiche & Fruit
Three Cheese Quiche
9.90
Quice Du Jour
Starters
Crispy Thai Calamari
10.90
Rhode island harvested + sweet chili sauce
"Coco-Loco" Shrimp Appetizer
12.90
Coconut-macadamia crusted shrimp served with an orange marmalade dipping sauce
Fresh Catch
served blackened, grilled or jamaican jerk spiced with jasmine rice and steamed broccoli
Atlantic Salmon
14.90
Whitefish
11.90
Tilapia
12.90
Shrimp (5)
14.90
Mahi-Mahi
14.90
Coho Salmon
18.90
Gulf Grouper
17.90
Catch of the Day
More Preparations
New England Cod Fish & Chips
11.90
Tempura Shrimp
14.90
Pasta Martinique
16.90
Scallops, wild gulf shrimp, crab, creamy tomato-basil sauce + penne (Gluten free when ordered over jasmine rice)
Grouper Fish and Chips
16.90
Gulf Shrimp Scampi
14.90
USA harvested wild Gulf of Mexico shrimp, garlic, butter, white wine, lemon, blistered tomatoes, fresh herbs, linguini + garlic crostini (Gluten free over jasmine rice with no crostini)
Sunset Dining
4-6 PM. Sunset entrées include a small Madhouse or Caesar salad or cup of black bean, mangospacho or soup of the day
Chicken Mad Thai
12.90
Rice noodles, chicken, edamame, onions, peppers, carrots, fried egg, cilantro, toasted cashews + spicy panang peanut sauce
Spicy Soba-Salmon Bowl
14.90
Pan seared salmon, panang peanut curry, chilled soba noodles, cilantro + papaya slaw
Crispy Chicken with Bacon Jam
12.90
Amazingly juicy, charbroiled chicken leg and thigh, balsamic bacon jam + sriracha roasted new potatoes & broccoli
Grouper Carciofi
15.90
Sautéed grouper medallions, artichoke hearts, tomato, white wine, lemon over jasmine rice + basil (seasonally available)
Flat Iron Steak
15.90
Chargrilled 5oz steak + mashed potatoes & chef's vegetables
Bang Shrimp Bowl
13.90
Crispy shrimp, bang sauce, fried rice, Asian vegetables + cilantro
Poke Tuna Bowl
15.90
Diced sushi grade tuna, spicy Hawaiian poke sauce, warm jasmine rice + avocado
Pan Seared New England Cod
13.90
Fresh lemon, olive oil & butter + sautéed spinach & mashed potatoes
Coco Mac Chicken
14.90
Pan fried coconut-macadamia crusted chicken breast, mango-chili sauce, jasmine rice + broccoli
Sweets
Bete Noir
5.90
A classic flourless dark chocolate cake, white chocolate drizzle + raspberry sauce
Créme Brulee
5.90
Classic Vanilla Bean
Crispy Bread Pudding Bites
5.90
Vanilla ice cream, whipped cream + caramel
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie
6.90
Rick's "to die for" secret recipe + whipped cream
Mounds Bar Sundae
6.90
Coconut ice cream, bete noir, whipped cream + chocolate sauce
Ball Jar Cheesecake
4.90
+ seasonal berries
Key Lime Pie
5.90
A "quintessential" Florida favorite Graham cracker crust + whipped cream
Chocolate Lava Cake
6.90
Warm molten chocolate cake, vanilla ice cream + whipped cream
Mezzo Forte
5.90
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, caramel sauce, cashews, coconut + whipped cream
Coffee Drinks
Keoke Coffee
7.90
Dark Cacao, Brandy and Coffee liqueur
Spanish Coffee
7.90
Tia Maria, Grand Marnier and Brandy
Espresso
2.70
Caramel Delight
7.90
Caramel Vodka and baileys
Nutty Irishman
7.90
Frangelico Hazelnut Liqueur and Irish Cream
Cappuccino
3.90
Port
Graham's, Ruby Port
9.90
Warre's, Otima 10 Yr Tawny Port
11.90
Fonseca, Bin No 27 Ruby Reserve
10.90
Sandeman's 20 Yr Tawny Port
13.90
Entrées
Chicken and Waffles
9.90
Tempura fried boneless chicken, Belgian waffle + syrup & one side
Fish Tacos
8.90
Two fried fish tacos with shredded lettuce cheese & sour cream + one side
Grilled Chicken
7.90
Boneless chicken, chargrilled or spicy Jamaican jerk
Chicken Fingers
6.90
Deep fried tempura chicken + ranch or honey mustard & one side
Grilled Cheese
3.90
American cheese on toasted wheat bread + one side
Mac and Cheese
3.90
The classic - Kraft mac and cheese
Mac and Chicken
6.90
Classic Kraft mac and cheese topped with a diced chicken breast
Flat Iron Steak
10.90
Char-grilled 5oz steak + one side
Kid Shrimp
8.90
Four shrimp grilled or tempura fried + one side
Coco Mac Shrimp
10.90
Three coconut-macadamia shrimp with Mandarin dipping sauce + one side
Hamburger
4.90
Fresh ground chuck, cooked well done + one side
Hot Dog
3.90
Char-grilled, New England roll + one side
Fish and Chips
8.90
Battered and fried whitefish with fries and tartar sauce
Mac and Dog
5.90
Kraft mac and cheese topped with a diced hot dog!
Penne Pasta
4.90
With Marinara or butter
Fresh Catch
Served grilled or tempura fried + one side
Tilapia
9.90
Maine Salmon
10.90
Whitefish
7.90
Sides
Broccoli
Fresh Fruit
Seasoned French Fries
Sweet Plantains
Mashed Potatoes
After 4PM
Cole Slaw
Jasmine Rice
Mixed Veggies
Black Beans and Rice
Drinks
Coca Cola
Free Refills
Mr. Pibb
Free Refills
Sprite
Free Refills
Milk
Refills Not Included
Apple Juice
Refills Not Included
Orange Juice
Refills Not Included
Cranberry Juice
Refills Not Included
Bottled Water
Refills Not Included
Iced Tea
Free Refills
Light Lemonade
Free Refills
Shirley Temple
Free Refills
Chocolate Milk
Refills Not Included
Grapefruit Juice
Refills Not Included
Ibc Root Beer
Refills Not Included
Pineapple Juice
Refills Not Included
Sunday Brunch
Served with a choice of one: sausage or bacon or fresh fruit
Kid's Traditional Breakfast
4.90
One egg you way, wheat toast + side choice
Kid's Cheese Omelette
5.90
Two egg omelette with cheddar-jack cheese, wheat toast + side choice
Belgian Waffle
6.90
Adult sized fresh baked Belgian waffle just for kids + one side
Kid's French Toast
5.90
On slice of egg battered brioche + side choice
Kid's Biscuits and Gravy
4.90
Two just baked buttermilk biscuits with homemade sausage gravy
Madfish Summer Specials
Summer Tasting Menu
Blue Chips
8.90
House made potato chips, warm blue cheese fondue, balsamic drizzle + scallions
Cheese Board
11.90
Ask for today's selection served with fresh fruit + crackers (Gluten free when ordered with rice crackers)
Pub Burger
9.90
⅓ lb chuck burger, Amish cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion, craft beer bun + housemade chips
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
2.90
Chilled gulf of mexico whites, lemon + house made cocktail sauce
Tenderloin Bruschetta
11.90
Tenderloin tips, roasted peppers, frizzled onions, rosemary crostini + gorgonzola sauce
Voodoo Chicken
9.90
Blackened chicken, blue cheese, blistered tomatoes + wilted spinach
Lobster Salad Mini Rolls
10.90
Lobster sensations, celery, mayonnaise, buttered soft roll + tobiko
Chicken-Lemongrass Potstickers
9.90
Sweet chili & soy drizzle + szechuan green beans
Bavarian Pretzel
8.90
Enormous 10 oz hand twisted soft pretzel + pub cheese
Smoked Fish Board
14.90
Maple-honey hot smoked salmon, smoked trout, smoked wahoo, pastrami salmon, smoked fish dip + accoutrements
Charred Brussel Sprouts
8.90
Shaved parmesan, xvoo, sea salt
"Bacon & Eggs" Deviled Eggs
5.90
Made w/ love + spicy sriracha drizzle
Chicken & Mushroom Pâté
8.90
Chicken liver, crimini mushrooms, cognac, shallot, dressed greens, pickled onion + crostinis (Gluten free when ordered with rice crackers)
Lobster Chimichanga
11.90
Lobster sensations, corn, pico & cheddar jack rolled in a flour tortilla, deep fried & served with ancho cream
Tonight's Dinner Specials
Turkey Pot Roast
17.90
Braised turkey, rich demi glace, au gratin potato + charred broccolini
Coconut Crusted Whitefish
21.90
Pan fried with a panko-toasted coconut crust, mango-pineapple salsa + jasmine rice & steamed broccoli
Siesta Key Rum Cake
7.90
Warm individual rum cake + Siesta Key Rum sauce (made locally & to die for!)
Fried Chicken Mac & Cheese
18.90
Cavatappi pasta, white cheddar cheese sauce, fried chicken + buttered bread crumbs
Tomahawk Chop
41.90
20oz bone in ribeye, pepper crusted, cognac cream + crispy brussel sprouts & garlic mashed potatoes
Sunset Happy Hour
Available Daily from 4-6pm
Well Drinks
5.00
Select Draft Beer
3.00
$2 Off All Summer Specials
4-6PM (excludes Shrimp Cocktail)
House Wine
4.50
$3 Off Select Premium Wines By the Glass
Eric's Pineapple Express Cocktail
7.00
The logo for our menu provider

Disclaimer: Always check with the business for pricing and availability of menu items. SinglePlatform is not responsible for menu or pricing changes, but the information is believed to be accurate when posted. Listing of a menu does not mean that there is any affiliation, endorsement or sponsorship between SinglePlatform and the listed business.

Problem with this menu?
Compass icon
Madfish Grill
4059 Cattlemen Rd (Bee Ridge & Cattlemen)
Sarasota, FL 34233
United States
Get directions
Information icon
The owners of Madfish Grill are Miles & Mindy Millwee, who have been in the restaurant industry for over 3 decades. They had the vision to turn an old bank i...
Clock icon
Closed until 11:30 AM (Show more)
  • Mon–Sat
    • 11:30 AM–9:00 PM
  • Sun
    • 11:00 AM–8:00 PM
Phone icon
(941) 377-3474
World Wide Web icon
Facebook icon
madfishgrill
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
See More

You might also like

Places people like to go after Madfish Grill

Appears on 7 lists

United States » Florida » Sarasota County » Sarasota »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.