Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Update:The City Guide web experience will be sunsetting on April 28, 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more.
Read more
Sheridan's Lodge

Sheridan's Lodge

Bar and American Restaurant$$$$
Newton
Save
Share
Sheridan's Lodge
8.1/10
71
ratings
Photos75 Photos
MenuMenu
Menu 11Daily Specials 4Menu 11Daily Specials 4Happy Hour 6
Appetizers‎
Chicken Quesadilla
9.00
Pierogies
5.00
Chicken Fingers
7.50
Mozzarella Sticks
6.00
Chili
5.00
Skewered Coconut Chicken
8.50
With orange glaze
California Skins
8.00
With avocado, red onion, red pepper, tomato, cilantro & lime juice
Boneless Chicken Bites
8.75
Choice of sauces: Hot, BBQ, Sweet & Sour
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
9.00
Topped w/ a burgundy reduction
Nachos
10.00
House Fries
4.50
Potato Skins
7.00
With bacon & cheese
BBQ Baby Back Ribs
8.50
Sweet Potato Fries
4.00
Crab Cake Sliders
9.00
With lettuce, tomato & honey mustard mayo
Mac & Cheese Bites
7.00
Hot Wings
8.75
Choice of sauces: Hot, BBQ, Sweet & Sour
Soups‎
Soup of the Day
3.00 - 4.00
French Onion
4.00 - 4.50
Seafood Chowder
4.00 - 5.00
Basket‎
Chicken in the Basket
9.50
Chicken Fingers in the Basket
8.50
Shrimp in the Basket
8.50
Mexican‎
Burritos
9.50
Enchiladas
10.00
Chicken Fajitas
14.00
Chipotle Marinated Hanger Steak
13.00
With pineapple salsa
Tacos
7.50
Taco Salad
10.00
Chicken Chimichangas
12.00
With guacamole
Chicken Monterey
13.00
Sautée With tomato, onion, black olives, cheddar & Monterey Jack
Salads‎
Caesar Salad
7.00
Clearwater Salad
10.50
Baby greens, fresh mozzarella, carrots, red onions & strawberries
Cajun Chicken Salad
12.50
Cajun chicken, tri-color pasta, onions, tomatoes, cheddar, olives & Cajun ranch dressing
Iliff Salad
10.50
Spinach, shaved fennel, pear, candied walnuts, raisins & crumbled bleu cheese
Mexican Chicken Salad
12.50
Marinated chicken over greens, w/ red peppers, seasoned potatoes, guacamole, cheddar & Monterey Jack w/ tri-colored tortilla chips
Baby Iceberg Salad
10.50
With feta cheese, grape tomato, mandarin oranges, cucumber & carrots
Burgers & Dogs‎
Hamburger
6.50
Belly Buster
8.75
With‎ peppers, onions, bacon, mushrooms, Swiss & American
California Cheeseburger
8.50
With lettuce, tomato, onion & a side of mayo
Turkey Burger
8.50
Hot Dog
6.50
Cheeseburger
7.50
Texas Burger
8.50
Our own Texas BBQ sauce
Pizza Burger
8.00
Bacon Cheeseburger
8.50
Chili Dog
8.50
Main Course‎
Fish & Chips
13.50
Broiled Sole
15.50
With lemon caper sauce
Alpine Dog
8.50
With Swiss, sauerkraut, spicy mustard all on a hoagie roll
Cottage Pie
12.50
Just like shepherd’s pie but only beef
Bacon Wrapped Chicken Breast
15.00
With sage & onions on a fondant potato
Braised Beef & Vegetables
15.00
Just like mom’s pot roast & gravy
BBQ Baby Back Ribs
19.00
New York Strip Steak
21.50
12 oz. New York strip steak, Choice center cut
Smoked Bacon, Pea & Parmesan Sauce Over Fettuccini
13.00
Sheridan’s Penne
12.00
With fresh spinach, grape tomato, garlic & a white wine sauce
Baked Salmon
16.50
With mozzarella, tomato & fresh basil
Fresh Crab Cakes
16.00
Chicken Pot Pie
13.00
Chicken Parmesan
13.50
Mom’s Meatloaf
11.50
Calves’ Liver With bacon & onions
14.00
Char Grilled Pork Chop
15.50
10 oz. Pork chop w/ sweet potato fries & homemade applesauce
Sheridan’s Classic Ribeye
17.00
Pasta w/ Marinara Sauce
9.00
Pasta Primavera
13.00
With zucchini, yellow squash, eggplant, pepper & red onion w/ your choice of garlic & oil or pink cream sauce
Sandwiches‎
Cheesesteak
8.50
Crab Cake Sandwich
9.50
BLT
7.50
Prime Rib Sandwich
9.50
With sautéed onions, mozzarella & roasted garlic mayonnaise on a Kaiser roll
Grilled Vegetables & Cheddar
9.50
On a panini w/ eggplant, yellow squash, zucchini, peppers & red onion
BBQ Pulled Pork
9.00
With‎ cheddar & fried onions on a Kaiser roll
Meatloaf Sandwich
8.50
With gravy
Cajun Chicken Wrap
8.50
California Chicken Sandwich
8.50
With lettuce, tomato, onion & mayo
Grilled Pesto Chicken
9.50
With roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella & fresh spinach on a ciabatta roll
Cape Codder
8.50
Turkey w/ stuffing, cranberry sauce & mayonnaise on a Kaiser roll
Fish Sandwich
9.50
8 oz. Of our own beer battered cod w/ lettuce, tomato & tartar sauce
Kids‎
All kids’ meals include ice cream or sherbet
Hamburger
7.00
With fries
Mac & Cheese Bites
7.00
With fries
Pizza
7.00
Grilled Cheese
7.00
With fries
Pasta
7.00
Hot Dog
7.00
With‎ fries
Chicken Fingers
7.00
With fries
Sides‎
French Fries
2.75
Sweet Potato Fries
4.00
Beer Battered Onion Rings
4.75
Baked Potato
2.50
Rice
2.50
Guacamole
2.00
Mashed Potatoes
2.50
Specials‎
Soup
Apps
Beer Battered Catfish Bites
7.99
W/ an old bay aioli
Vegetable Beef
9.99
“2” Dozen Steamers
9.99
Entrees‎
14oz Rib Eye Steak
21.99
W/ Chipotle Butter, Sliced Avocados & Red Onions
Baked Stuffed Chicken
14.99
W/ spinach, smoked gouda, roasted red peppers, proscuitto & a side of yellow rice
Triple “ot” Chicago Black Hawk Burger
9.00
Blackened burger topped w/ canadian bacon & melted smoked gouda
Seafood Trilogy
19.99
W/ tuna, scallops, shrimp, brie cheese a plum tomato basil sauce & served over penne
Balsamic Grilled Chicken Over A Greek Salad
12.99
W/ black olives, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, hard boiled egg & artichokes
Dessert‎
Banana Caramel Cheesecake Xango
5.00
Appetizers‎
Chicken Quesadilla
8.99
Pierogies
4.99
Chicken Fingers
7.79
Mozzarella Sticks
6.79
Chili
4.99
Irish Potato Skins
8.59
With corned beef, swiss cheese, & a side of Russian dressing
California Skins
8.99
With avocado, red onion, red pepper, tomato, cilantro & lime juice
Boneless Chicken Bites
8.99
Choice of sauces: hot, BBQ, teriyaki
Cheeseburger Sliders
7.99
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
9.99
Topped w/ a burgundy reduction
Nachos
9.99
House Fries
4.79
Potato Skins
7.99
With bacon & cheese
BBQ Baby Back Ribs
8.99
Sweet Potato Fries
4.29
Crab Cake Sliders
8.99
With lettuce, tomato & honey mustard mayo
Mac & Cheese Bites
7.59
Beef Tapas Teriyaki marinated beef skewers w/ a side of Asian coleslaw
8.99
Hot Wings
8.99
Choice of sauces: hot, BBQ, teriyaki
Soups‎
Soup of the Day
3.49 - 4.49
French Onion
4.29 - 4.79
Seafood Chowder
4.49 - 5.49
Salads‎
Caesar Salad
6.99
Tavern Salad
10.99
Spring mix salad w/ fresh beets, fresh mozzarella, red onion, tomatoes, cucumber & roasted red peppers
Cajun Chicken Salad
12.99
Cajun chicken, tri-color pasta, onions, tomatoes, cheddar, olives & Cajun ranch dressing
Iliff Salad
10.99
Spinach, shaved fennel, pear, candied walnuts, raisins & crumbled bleu cheese
Mexican Chicken Salad
12.99
Marinated chicken over greens, w/ red peppers, seasoned potatoes, guacamole, cheddar & monterey jack w/ tri-colored tortilla chips
Andover Salad
10.99
Chicken salad w/ apples, craisins, red onions, & celery served over baby iceberg w/ grape tomatoes & cucumber
Baskets‎
Chicken in the Basket
9.99
Chicken Fingers in the Basket
8.99
Shrimp in the Basket
8.99
Mexican‎
Burritos
9.99
Enchiladas
10.99
Chicken Fajitas
14.99
Chipotle Marinated Hanger Steak
14.99
With pineapple salsa
Tacos
8.49
Taco Salad
9.99
Chicken Chimichangas
13.99
With guacamole
Chicken Monterey Sauteed
13.99
With tomato, onion, black olives, cheddar & monterey jack
Burgers & Dogs‎
Hamburger
6.99
Belly Buster
8.99
With‎ peppers, onions, bacon, mushrooms, swiss & American
California Cheeseburger
8.99
With lettuce, tomato, onion & a side of mayo
Turkey Burger
8.99
Hot Dog
6.99
Alpine Dog
8.99
With swiss, sauerkraut, spicy mustard all on a hoagie roll
Cheeseburger
7.99
Texas Burger
8.99
Our own Texas BBQ sauce
Blue Onion Burger
8.99
Hamburger topped w/ an onion ring & bleu cheese dressing
Bacon Cheeseburger
8.99
Chili & Cheese Dog
8.99
Main Course‎
Fish & Chips
13.99
Seafood Medley
19.59
Broiled cod, shrimp, & scallops in a lemon caper sauce
Chicken Pot Pie
12.99
Chicken Parmesan
13.99
Mom’s Meatloaf
11.99
Calves’ Liver
14.59
With bacon & onions
Char Grilled Pork Chop
15.99
10 oz. Pork chop w/ sweet potato fries & homemade applesauce
Sheridan’s Classic Ribeye
17.59
Pasta w/ Marinara Sauce
9.99
Pasta Primavera 13.59
With zucchini, yellow squash, eggplant, pepper & red onion w/ your choice of garlic & oil or pink cream sauce
Baked Salmon
16.99
With mozzarella, tomato & fresh basil
Fresh Crab Cakes
16.59
Cottage Pie
12.99
Just like shepherd’s pie but only beef
Roast Stuffed Chicken
15.59
A chicken breast stuffed w/ fresh mozzarella, spinach, roasted red peppers, & wrapped in proscuitto
Garlic Herb Crusted Basa
15.59
A mild tasting white fish broiled w/ a white buerre blanc sauce
BBQ Baby Back Ribs
19.59
New York Strip Steak
21.99
12 oz. New York strip steak, Choice center cut
Smoked Bacon, Pea & Parmesan Sauce Over Fettuccini
13.59
Sheridan’s Penne
12.59
With fresh spinach, grape tomato, garlic & a white wine sauce
Teriyaki Sesame Beef Skewers
14.99
Marinated beef skewers w/ peppers, onions, mushrooms, & an Asian coleslaw, all served w/ white rice
Sandwiches‎
We offer white, 7 grain whole wheat, rye bread, brioche & ciabatte rolls
Meatloaf Sandwich
8.99
Served on a brioche roll w/ gravy
Cajun Chicken Wrap
8.99
California Chicken Sandwich
8.99
With lettuce, tomato, onion & mayo on a brioche roll
Grilled Pesto Chicken
9.99
With‎ roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella & fresh spinach on a ciabatta roll
Open Face Corned Beef Reuben
8.99
Cape Codder
8.99
Turkey w/ stuffing, cranberry sauce & mayonnaise on a brioche roll
Fish Sandwich
9.79
8‎ oz. Of our own beer battered cod w/ lettuce, tomato & tartar sauce
Cheesesteak
8.99
Crab Cake Sandwich
9.99
BLT
7.99
Prime Rib Sandwich
9.99
With sautéed onions, mozzarella & roasted garlic mayonnaise on a brioche roll
Santa Fe Marinated Chicken Sandwich
8.99
With Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, & served on grilled 7 grain whole wheat bread
Portobello Sandwich
9.79
Marinated portobello cap grilled & served on a brioche roll w/ lettuce & tomato
BBQ Pulled Pork
9.99
With cheddar & fried onions on a brioche roll
Kid's‎
All kids’ meals include ice cream or sherbet
Hamburger
7.59
With smiley fries
Mac & Cheese Bites
6.99
With‎ smiley fries
Pizza
7.59
Grilled Cheese
6.99
With smiley fries
Pasta
6.99
Hot Dog
6.99
With smiley fries
Chicken Fingers
6.99
With smiley fries
Sides‎
French Fries
2.79
Sweet Potato Fries
4.29
Beer Battered Onion Rings
4.99
Baked Potato
2.59
Vegetables
2.59
Rice
2.59
Guacamole
2.59
Mashed Potatoes
2.59
Mexican Rice & Beans
2.59
Specials‎
Soup
9.50
Split pea w/ ham apps. steamers
Pastrami Reuben Sliders
7.99
Entrees‎
Beef Teriyaki
14.99
With carrots, green beans, broccoli rabe, onions & served over rice
Fresh Spring Mix Salad
10.00
With cucumbers, almonds, craisins, apples, red onions, blue cheese crumbles & tossed in a orange-cranberry vinaigrette
Thin Crust Pizza
6.00
Chicken Mediterranean
15.99
Served in a bread bowl w/ artichokes, onions, black olives, tomatoes, peppers & a plum tomato basil sauce
Battered & Fried Salmon On 7 Grain Whole Wheat
9.50
With lettuce, tomato & old bay seasoned mayonaise
Desserts‎
Cocktail Parties
Dinner Buffets
Luncheon Buffets
Platters & Trays To Go
Monday‎
$1.50 off all drinks
Tuesday‎
$1.50 off bottled beer
Wednesday‎
$1.50 off wine
Thursday‎
$1.50 off mixed drinks
Friday‎
$1.50 off draught beer

Problem with this menu?
Compass icon
Sheridan's Lodge
631 Limecrest Rd (Lake Iliff Rd.)
Newton, NJ 07860
United States
Get directions
Information icon
Since 1978, Sheridan’s Restaurant and Tavern has been a favorite to the local community. Family owned and operated from the beginning, We offer warm and friendly service, good food and drink, in a unique setting overlooking beautiful Lake Iliff. And we have live music most weekend nights.
Clock icon
Open until 2:00 AM (Show more)
  • Mon–Sun
    • 11:00 AM–2:00 AM
Phone icon
(973) 383-7577
World Wide Web icon
Facebook icon
SheridansRestaurantandTavern
Twitter icon
@sheridans_nj
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
TouchTunes Jukebox
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More

You might also like

Places people like to go after Sheridan's Lodge

Appears on 14 lists

United States » New Jersey » Sussex County » Newton »