| # | Last week | Neighborhood | |
| 1. | 1 | Cha Cha Matcha Coffee Shop · NoLita | NoLita |
| 2. | 1 | Chikarashi Asian Restaurant · Little Italy | Little Italy |
| 3. | 4 | Union Fare Café · Union Square | Union Square |
| 4. | 1 | Magnum New York Ice Cream Shop · SoHo | SoHo |
| 5. | 12 | Tapestry Restaurant · West Village | West Village |
| 6. | 1 | Shake Shack Burger Joint · Garment District | Garment District |
| 7. | New | by CHLOE Vegetarian / Vegan Restaurant · Flatiron District | Flatiron District |
| 8. | 2 | Carla Hall's Southern Chicken Comfort Food Restaurant · Cobble Hill | Cobble Hill |
| 9. | 1 | Dizengoff Israeli Restaurant · Chelsea | Chelsea |
| 10. | 4 | Hao Noodle & Tea Noodle House · West Village | West Village |
| 11. | 7 | Sauvage French Restaurant · Greenpoint | Greenpoint |
| 12. | New | Screamer's Pizzeria Pizza Place · Williamsburg | Williamsburg |
| 13. | New | Hey Hey Canteen Asian Restaurant · Gowanus | Gowanus |
| 14. | 5 | Tacuba Mexican Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen | Hell's Kitchen |
| 15. | New | Coco & Cru Australian Restaurant · Greenwich Village | Greenwich Village |
| 16. | 4 | Indian Accent North Indian Restaurant · Theater District | Theater District |
| 17. | 9 | Olmsted New American Restaurant · Prospect Heights | Prospect Heights |
| 18. | New | Hail Mary Diner · Greenpoint | Greenpoint |
| 19. | New | Le Coucou French Restaurant · SoHo | SoHo |
| 20. | New | Gebhard’s Beer Culture Bar · Lincoln Square | Lincoln Square |