Reloading results...

Suggestions for pot pie near New York

Filters:
    • 8.2

      1. Penelope

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      159 Lexington Ave (at E 30th St), New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches pot pies
    • 8.7

      2. The Waverly Inn

      American • $$$$ •
      16 Bank St (at Waverly Pl), New York
      Save
      • Cihan E.

        Cihan E. • October 12, 2014Biscuits, I could eat tens of them.. Chicken pot pie & fries is a must! Ask for a table near fire place and oh they're not allow you to instagram your meal, YES..!! 😝

    • 8.4

      3. The Smith

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      55 3rd Ave (btwn E 10th & E 11th St), New York
      Save
      • Star 2 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 8.8

      4. The Smith

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      956 2nd Ave (at E 51st St), New York
      Save
      • Star 3 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 8.1

      5. Friend of a Farmer

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      77 Irving Pl (btwn E 18th & E 19th St), New York
      Save
      • Star 2 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 8.6

      6. Fraunces Tavern

      Whisky Bar • $$$$ • View Menu •
      54 Pearl St (at Broad St), New York
      Save
      • Star 14 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 9.3

      7. The Dead Rabbit

      Cocktail • $$$$ •
      30 Water St (btwn Broad St & Coenties Slip), New York
      Save
      • Paul M.

        Paul M. • December 15, 2015Tough place to get in. But worth the hassle. The stirred cocktails are based on old fashions and are delicious. I had the chicken pot pie, wonderful and my guest had the shepherds pie also super.

    • 8.5

      8. The Smith

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1900 Broadway (at W 63rd St), New York
      Save
      • Star 3 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 7.1

      9. St. Dymphna's

      Pub • $$$$ • View Menu •
      118 Saint Marks Pl (btwn First Ave. & Ave. A), New York
      Save
      • Megan H.

        Megan H. • December 14, 2010Try the fries with curry sauce! Excellent! I love the chicken pot pie, but FYI it has bacon in it.

    • 8.9

      10. Gottino Enoteca Salumeria

      Wine Bar • $$$$ • View Menu •
      52 Greenwich Ave (at Perry St), New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches pot pies
    • 8.4

      11. Café Gitane

      French • $$$$ • View Menu •
      242 Mott St (at Prince St), New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches pot pies
    • 9.0

      12. Earl's Beer & Cheese

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      1259 Park Ave (btwn E 97th & E 98th St), New York
      Save
      • Greg L.

        Greg L. • April 23, 2017All three dishes we ordered were great: chicken pot pie, huevos rancheros, and earl salad (with pork belly!)

    • 8.5

      13. The Dutch

      New American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      131 Sullivan St (at Prince St), New York
      Save
      • Jade C.

        Jade C. • May 23, 2011Oysters amazing, rabbit pot pie delicious and comforting, excellent wine list, great service. A fantastic surprise!

    • 8.8

      14. Little Pie Company

      Pie Shop • $$$$ • View Menu •
      424 W 43rd St (btwn 9th & 10th Ave), New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches pot pies
    • 8.5

      15. Ear Inn

      Pub • $$$$ • View Menu •
      326 Spring St (btwn Greenwich & West), New York
      Save
      • Simon M.

        Simon M. • September 19, 2012Best try the chicken pot pie

    • 8.0

      16. The Porterhouse at Fraunces Tavern

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      54 Pearl St (at Broad St), New York
      Save
      • Star 3 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 6.7

      17. Brooklyn Diner

      Diner • $$$$ • View Menu •
      212 W 57th St (Broadway), New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches pot pies
    • 8.0

      18. White Oak Tavern

      Restaurant • View Menu •
      21 Waverly Place (Greene St.) (Greene St), New York
      Save
      • Waley C.

        Waley C. • June 30, 2017Chicken pot pie was awesome!

    • 7.1

      19. Pershing Square Café

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      90 E 42nd St (at Park Ave), New York
      Save
      • Star 2 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 9.0

      20. Bar Belly

      Cocktail • $$$$ • View Menu •
      14 Orchard St (at Canal St), New York
      Save
      • Vishal S.

        Vishal S. • November 17, 2012The food was good but not as good as Fat Radish cross the street. mussel pot pie was pretty amazing (and I don't love mussels). Spicy Pineapple cocktail was awesome! Great scene & music.

    • 7.0

      21. Brooklyn Diner

      Diner • $$$$ • View Menu •
      155 W 43rd St (at Broadway), New York
      Save
      • Star 3 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 8.6

      22. Rainbow Room

      American • $$$$ • View Menu •
      30 Rockefeller Plz (49th Street), New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches pot pies
    • 8.4

      23. Jones Wood Foundry

      English • $$$$ • View Menu •
      401 E 76th St (btwn York & 1st Ave.), New York
      Save
      • sue q.

        sue q. • December 4, 2014Cozy neighborhood British gastropub. Recommend: scotch egg, fish and chips with mushy peas, pot pies and sticky toffee pudding. Great beer selection.

    • 7.9

      24. Molly's Shebeen

      Irish • $$$$ • View Menu •
      287 3rd Ave (btwn E 22nd & 23rd St.), New York
      Save
      • Star 2 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 7.1

      25. Connolly's Pub & Restaurant

      Irish • $$$$ • View Menu •
      121 W 45th St (at 6th Ave), New York
      Save
      • Star 2 items on the menu match pot pies
    • 8.1

      26. Row House

      Restaurant • $$$$ •
      2128 Frederick Douglass Blvd (W 115th St), New York
      Save
      • Msfroggyjay

        Msfroggyjay • December 12, 2015The chicken pot pies are amazing! The funky strong cocktail is my favorite drink ! Amazing ! Brussels are fantastic !

    • 7.9

      27. Boulton & Watt

      Gastropub • $$$$ • View Menu •
      5 Avenue A (at W Houston St), New York
      Save
      • Elizabeth B.

        Elizabeth B. • January 6, 2017Good comfort food, yummy chicken pot pie and butternut squash ravioli. Also good IPA

    • 7.7

      28. Tea & Sympathy

      Tea Room • $$$$ • View Menu •
      108 Greenwich Ave (btwn 12th & 13th St), New York
      Save
      • Holly W.

        Holly W. • November 23, 2010Things to try: chicken pot pie, treacle pudding, sparkling Ribena, strawberry cupcake, and afternoon tea for two!

    • 8.5

      29. The Smith

      New American • $$$$ •
      1150 Broadway (at W 27th St), New York
      Save
      • MARQ L.

        MARQ L. • November 25, 2018Everything but the maple bacon is unbelievable. French toast was ridiculous and the breakfast pot pie was delish. I will return to the West Coast 20 lbs heavier.

    • 7.8

      30. Sidecar at P.J. Clarke's

      Speakeasy • $$$$ • View Menu •
      205 E 55th St (3rd Ave.), New York
      Save
      • Star 1 item on the menu matches pot pies

    • Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.