Grace K. • July 31, 2016The first place I ever had rolled ice cream. It's super fun to watch them make the ice cream, and the results are delicious.
Sonia K. • November 7, 2017Peanut butter shake, java shake, all the fries and burgers look amazing and sinful too.
BuzzFeed • April 23, 2014The methods are old-fashioned at this retro soda fountain and ice cream parlor, but the menu isn’t; try the Pink Poodle float, made with hibiscus soda.
Alice Q. • November 20, 2019Don’t sleep on the berry flavors. I’m usually a chocolate fan but the berry flavors are exceptionally good.
eric b. • December 28, 2023A staple of Brooklyn now no matter the price. Good interesting flavors keep you coming back.
Barry H. • April 5, 2016Their gluten free vegan chocolate fudge coconut sorbet is worth a try
Nilay G. • July 5, 2019Italian ices are really good - they come in every flavor that they have for ice cream
Max B. • April 25, 2019This location has the new summer flavors! Vegan Oat Milk is Columbian coffee ice cream with chocolate fudge swirls, simply the best!
Jeremy F. • May 26, 2021Haven’t had Oddfellows in years, and was shocked at how good it is these days
Robin D. • August 20, 2022I only get Butter Pecan on a cake cone. Not because the other flavors aren’t good. Butter Pecan is all I ever get anywhere. Their Butter Pecan is fabulous. I highly recommend it.
Sue E. • November 5, 2017Great coffee shop close to the waters to stop by. Liked their coffee and lots of space to study
MidgeMadge D. • August 2, 2021Chocolate mallow crunch, banana were stand outs
Christina C. • May 2, 2023Just opened, took over the Brooklyn ice cream old place. Some indoor seating and mwrch for sale in there too. Can sample the flavors!
Julyane L. • November 10, 2017Ameii o sorvete daqui! ❤️
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.