Elyse E. • June 18, 2010The Mata Hari is my fave! Cognac, chai infused vermouth and pomegrante juice. Divine.
Polina W. • October 10, 2017This was such a nice surprise! The place is located on the 2nd floor of five guys burger joint, and had a cozy vibe. The friendly bartender made a great cocktail, based on my favorite flavor profile.
jeffrey a. • July 15, 2016Any place that advertises themselves as a 'Speakeasy' should be shut down automatically, but the service is good and the dry-aged steaks are tasty so I keep coming back.
Ira B. • February 16, 2023There’s a fireplace here. Comfortable and surprisingly not overly crowded.
Ben K. • May 28, 2015Great new bar from the Acme team that harks back to 50's LA. Must try the In-N-Out inspired burger and cocktails. Don't miss Slowly Shirleys, the swankier (and pricier) speakeasy downstairs.
emily c. • October 19, 2014great little speakeasy restaurant. feels like a bit of brooklyn in west village/tribeca. when it's nice out, sit out in the backyard which makes you feel like you're no longer in nyc.
Barnaby E. • September 6, 2012Want to sing showtunes? This is the place to be then. But don't forget to tip your piano player, server and bartender, and they'll take care of you!
Bridget W. • November 22, 2017They play excellent music. A nice blend of 70s, 80s, and 90s. Drinks and service are great, too. Really cozy spot.
Carol • 1 week agoCool aesthetic, horrendous mixology. The $18-20+ drinks came in cool cups, but tasted awful. The ingredients don’t blend and we ended up paying and leaving. Don’t order cocktails. Take pics & leave
George A. • September 9, 2023From ambience to tasty drinks, this place is a literal hidden gem. Love the owners and the speakeasy tour that they give when asked. Designed right and a treasure in Farmingdale.
Josh N. • October 26, 2013Meyer Lansky's old joint, used occasionally as the site of an immersive mystery theatre experience!
Don't see the place you're looking for? Add a new place to Foursquare.