Suggestions for secret menu near New York

Steven Y. • March 19, 2013Get the crispy pork off the secret menu at this BYOB gem, and they provide a corkscrew if you need one; be prepared to wait though as there are only a few tables, but it's well worth it

Sergey N. • April 20, 2012Great decor and the off the menu "batch burger" is hands down the best in the city. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu)

Joe F. • February 15, 2016Awesome Italian restaurant with an old school feel and fantastic service. Fresh past, seafood, and Italian classics. Start with the off the menu veal parmigiana, it's the best in the city.

Emily B. • March 1, 2016Get the off menu burger in the tap room (and sometimes if your really nice in the dining room). Swiss and cheddar, house smoked bacon, and a house made sesame bun!

Ryan S. • November 7, 2010Order off the menu - kimchi stew is amazing in the winter!

Ashlee H. • August 6, 2014Freaking delicious drinks. Order anything on or off the menu and it'll be great. Just let the waitress know if you're looking for particular liquors and flavors and they'll make a drink just for you!

Simon • February 24, 2013amazing food - get the truffle mushroom ravioli and the chicken parm (off menu). Great place for the fam, date or just a great Italian meal

Kara D. • August 8, 2014Favorite margarita in the city! Strongly recommend their guac, shrimp quesadillas, chicken wings (not on the menu!), and taco tray. Just do it.

Bon • March 7, 2019Mini tacos come with a ton of guac, special off menu naan is worth trying

Julie S. • August 1, 2018This place has been popular for a long time, but avoid the weekends for less crowds. Try getting there early for the full speakeasy vibe and make friends with bartenders for secret menu cocktails.

Eric L. • April 25, 20113 tips in 1: change up the rock shrimp by getting it with the honey truffle aioli (off menu). Don't be shy about getting 1/2 orders. And get a mojito with yuzu and shiso instead of lime and mint.

Catherine P. • March 15, 2018Ask for the limited foie gras dumplings (off menu!) they really are worth it!!! Also: Fantastic salmon sashimi with dried Miso (in photo).

Scott H. • November 6, 2009The perfect after date drink place in the lower west. Order the "Fair and Day" (off menu) - a rum based revelation haha. Or something a little sweet, try their "Dominicana."

Paul K. • April 14, 2015The best place in NYC to go off the menu for a cocktail, and the one of the best places for a cocktail period.

Brett F. • November 16, 2015The off menu specials are delicious. However, the terrible wine by the glass is unforgivable. Would not go back. Too many better choices available.

Najla • March 16, 2016Best calamari I've ever had in my life!!!! "Not in the menu ask the waiter for it"👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

Giulia M. • March 9, 2019Worth the wait! (Tip: Arrive right when it opens at 6pm, short line and you’ll probably get a table). Waiters are very friendly and helpful - got a few off the menu drinks that were amazing!

Oliva T. • April 10, 2013Always great food and be sure to ask the waiter for any off the menu special recommendations. Be sure to make a reservation on the weekends because it gets packed! Request David- he is awesome!

Simon • March 10, 2012Ask about the Texas burger on Saturdays (off the menu)

Albert T. • January 27, 2018Get the queso taco that’s not on the menu. The tortilla is deliciously cheese based. #nom

Bennet G. • October 11, 2019Unreal homemade flour and corn tortillas. Best tacos in NYC! Try the queso taco from the secret menu!

Stina P. • September 4, 2016the best burger in the entire city - i have dreams about it and the au poivre sauce. off menu and exactly 12 served each night from the bar only. kitchen opens at 530 and seats are filled by 5

Melissa H. • October 4, 2013The bathtub gin martini is perfect- so smooth! If you want to try something not on the menu, ask Kevin to make you his specialty drink - The Lost Digits.

Spice Symphony • March 5, 2013OFF THE MENU -" Shrimp Piri Piri" ( Spicy Shrimp in cider vinegar,curry leaves and Goan Chillies) Or for New Delhi Chat - Ask our Crafty Celebrity Chef to prepare .

Nadine B. • May 28, 2014Order The Nadine latte from their secret menu - it's a honey, almond milk latte ;)

Mackenzie K. • April 24, 2015Try ordering off the menu: The Rosco is a delicious take on the Manhattan. With a bite, but a sweet finish.

Paul C. • May 14, 2022All of it. And Teru is always ready to serve amazing fish, even if off menu

Taylor S. • May 7, 2011Ask for the off menu guacamole and plantains. Fantastic!

Jeff M. • January 25, 2015Ask for the skim milk off the secret menu.

tiffany y. • March 23, 2011order the vegetarian ramen, it's not on the menu and it's one of the best vegetarian ramens ever. and add spicy taste on the side!