Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Salvatore's Tomato Pies is one of The 9 Best Places for a Carbonara in Madison.

1. Salvatore's Tomato Pies

8.8
912 E Johnson St, Madison, WI
Pizzeria · Tenney-Lapham · 10 tips and reviews

GabeGabe: You can order mango on a pizza!

Corey J.Corey Jacob: The rotating selection of specialty pizzas are the star of the show at Sal's.👍

Nate V.Nate Vercauteren: Best pizza in Madison as far as I'm concerned.

Café Porta Alba is one of The 9 Best Places for a Carbonara in Madison.

2. Café Porta Alba

558 N Midvale Blvd, Madison, WI
Pizzeria · 22 tips and reviews

Han W.Han Wong: Charming live music similar to The Godfather soundtrack. Authentic, no frills pasta recipes. Excellent coffee.

Laurel CLaurel C: The Nutella pizza is AMAZING. Try it 4 dessert.

Brad L.Brad Leege: There is a Maradona shirt on the wall so you know this place is legit.

Tutto Pasta Trattoria is one of The 9 Best Places for a Carbonara in Madison.

3. Tutto Pasta Trattoria

7.1
305 State St (at W Johnson St), Madison, WI
Italian Restaurant · State Street · 19 tips and reviews

Lauren B.Lauren Bass: I shared the bruschetta as an appetizer with a friend and it was sooo delicious! It was also big enough to easily share, and the tomatoes tasted very fresh!

Samantha S.Samantha Samantha Adler: Penne Quattro Formaggio is a wonderful delicious dish with a big portion but it's nice and light

Tiffany W.Tiffany Wong: somewhat disappointed by my lobster ravioli in vodka sauce: a little overcooked and over salted

Pizza Di Roma is one of The 9 Best Places for a Carbonara in Madison.

4. Pizza Di Roma

7.3
313 State St, Madison, WI
Pizzeria · State Street · 12 tips and reviews

Joey P.Joey Paterick: Barbecue chicken and caprese pizza ... for dessert tiramisu is a winner!! :)

Gun R.Gun Runner: Mad Towns best and affordable Pizza

Aaron S.Aaron Silvers: At 2am, sometimes a Baked Ziti pizza is exactly what you need. Read more.

North and South Seafood & Smokehouse is one of The 9 Best Places for a Carbonara in Madison.

5. North and South Seafood & Smokehouse

7.4
6604 Mineral Point Road (Grand Canyon Drive), Madison, WI
Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews

Jason K.Jason Konen: Great seafood joint. Their New York strip is pretty good as well. If you go fish get the perch.

Sean L.Sean Lawler: Kids eat free on Sunday but they won't let you leave them here.

Dougie C.Dougie Cyanide: Too expensive for what you get.

Gates And Brovi is one of The 9 Best Places for a Carbonara in Madison.

6. Gates And Brovi

7.2
3502 Monroe St (Glenway St), Madison, WI
American Restaurant · Dudgeon - Monroe · 19 tips and reviews

Nicole S.Nicole Saunders: Great beer list, very friendly service, and every meal I've had is delicious. I particularly recommend the friend chicken sandwich, and the cheese curds are fantastic.

Jaquie R.Jaquie Rice: Oysters and old fashioned! Awesome!

Andrew B.Andrew Binsack: Loving the Fox Soccer Channel @ G&B!

Quiznos is one of The 9 Best Places for a Carbonara in Madison.

7. Quiznos

7.2
6611 McKee Rd (at Maple Grove Dr.), Madison, WI
Sandwich Spot · 2 tips and reviews

CT W.CT Weichmann: Get the Baja Chicken.

Tommy M.Tommy Mashuda: Best customer service I've had in a long time.

Olive Garden is one of The 9 Best Places for a Carbonara in Madison.

8. Olive Garden

7.9
7017 Mineral Point Rd, Madison, WI
Italian Restaurant · 20 tips and reviews

Maegan M.Maegan Mayhem: Chicken gnocchi soup YUM!

Amit P.Amit Padhy: Tour of Italy was the best..five cheese ziti for the veggie guys.. and Fonduta is not fondue

Cassandra D.Cassandra Davis: My food was the bomb!!! And got it within 10 mins...

Cafe La Bellitalia is one of The 9 Best Places for a Carbonara in Madison.

9. Cafe La Bellitalia

7.6
1026 N Sherman Ave, Madison, WI
Italian Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews

Ruth R.Ruth Rohlich: Everything is so good! Anything vegetarian is awesome! Friday night they sometimes have music. Pizza is good.

Ashley S.Ashley Stewart: The garlic bread is frozen. I got the Alfredo and it wasn't an Alfredo sauce and my boyfriend got the chicken parm and it was soggy

Colin E.Colin Erskine: $2.50 Pizza by the slice. From 11-2pm