See all
255 photos

Molly's Shebeen

Irish Pub and Pub$$$$

Gramercy Park, New York

Save

Molly's Shebeen

7.8^/10

446

ratings

Ranked #1 for burgers in Gramercy Park
The experts at The New York Times and Men's Health Mag recommend this place
"Cozy with lots of wood, brick and a fireplace."(8 Tips)
"The shepherd's pie is delicious and super hearty."(10 Tips)
"Molly’s offers a variety"(3 Tips)
"nice authentic pub full of Irish people ☘️."(3 Tips)

126 Tips and reviews

Filter:

burgers
fireplaces
shepherd's pie
molly s
casual
authentic
fish and chips
irish people
Irish breakfast
Irish coffee
sandwiches
great value
cute
chicken
pretzel rolls
spicy food
brunch food
baseball
staff
bacon
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Untapped CitiesAugust 18, 2017
Often named New York’s most authentic Irish pub, Molly’s offers a variety of traditional Irish dishes, like chicken potpie, pub sausage and mashed potatoes, and corned beef and cabbage. Read more
Nancy KangNovember 25, 2013
U can't go wrong w/ the corned beef & cabbage here. The meat is the leanest corned beef I've seen. Comes w/ plenty of meat & cabbage w/ some carrots too, a peeled baked potato & a yummy dill sauce.
GothamistJanuary 22, 2016
This wee Irish pub not only griddles up a ridiculously good burger, they also torch a roaring wood fire that fills the space with a warm glow. Stop in for a perfect pint or an Irish Coffee. Read more
GothamistAugust 1, 2014
This pub not only griddles up a good burger, they also torch a wood fire that fills the space with a warm glow and plenty of heat. Stop in for a perfect pint or an Irish Coffee to warm frozen noses. Read more
Men's Health MagAugust 3, 2014
The floors are covered with sawdust and the fireplace burns actual wood. Plus, the bartenders boast legitimate brogue—and, more to the point, know how to pour a perfect pint. Read more
First We FeastAugust 4, 2014
If you want to stick with the Gaelic theme, opt for the shepherd's pie—the ultimate Emerald Isle comfort food, built here with savory ground beef and thick mashed potatoes. Read more
Yuliya SamsonavaMarch 17, 2019
nice authentic pub full of Irish people ☘️. Crowded place with good food (Shepherds pie is 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼), old wooden floor and endless Guinness 🖤
Brad GaroonJune 25, 2015
Molly’s serves up 10 oz. patties, which is the only minor flaw in their game. The burgers have a nice char, but the heft of the patty leaves the center of the burger tasting flat. Read more
KarenFebruary 24, 2023
The shepherd's pie is delicious and super hearty. A side of fries is definitely shareable between 2-3 people.
Serious EatsOctober 1, 2013
Neighborhood Irish pub with a great vibe (sawdust on the floor included) and some solid classics like burgers, pot pie, and fish and chips.
Robert FioreNovember 11, 2019
Been here 10+ times
Awesome burger on a pretzel roll. Sheppard’s Pie, Chicken Pot Pie with a pastry crust. Ruben sandwich. Fish and chips (fresh cod). All soo good!
The Corcoran GroupJuly 24, 2013
The burgers here are awesome, plain and simple. Enjoy one in front of the fireplace, along with an Irish Coffee to warm you up!
Tyler CaineFebruary 6, 2015
If you're searching for a pun burger, then come on in. Don't mind the sawdust on the floor. The burger is big and juicy with a touch of Irish hospitality. Not a top ten for me, but not bad.
Nancy KangNovember 25, 2013
Very cozy atmosphere! Wood burning fireplace, ceilings covered w/ colorful lights, sawdust on the floors... Not to mention ever-so-friendly Irish service!
DoubleDeuceJuly 26, 2021
Been here 10+ times
They stick to their theme pretty closely so it's always a consistent experience. If you get the burger, they have the best side salad around.
Jen GrunwaldFebruary 12, 2016
Been here 25+ times
Molly's is a great old-fashioned pub with delicious food! Burgers are great as is the corn beef sandwich. Really anything. Excellent staff!
Zach SteereFebruary 1, 2014
Some of the best burgers in the city. Also, the cozy atmosphere, the fireplace, and the sawdust on the floor make tho one to check out. Highly recommended.
Meaghan SmithNovember 23, 2014
Great little Irish pub. Sawdust on the floor, a working fireplace and actual Irish people on staff. Great little find and a relaxing atmosphere.
GothamistMarch 17, 2016
It's green season, St. Paddy's Day has arrived. To celebrate with some authentic Irish food, head over to Molly's where you can wash down the lamb stew or fish and chips with some Guinness goodness. Read more
Tali KeteriAugust 21, 2011
Been here 25+ times
Order everything. No lie. The mozzarella sticks are homemade and aamazing. I haven't had a single thing here that hasn't been freakin genius. Best guinness in the city and my favorite bartender ever.
John PaterakisDecember 30, 2019
Been here 100+ times
This is the place to be on a cold rainy day. Three words. Guinness. Beef. Stew.
Joseph HuppertJanuary 4, 2017
The burgers and hand cut fries are probably the best in the city. Fabulous fish & chips. Drinks could be more generous.
sablerDecember 30, 2017
Been here 25+ times
It's the dead of winter, this is where you grab lunch on an icy weekend afternoon. It's not really up for discussion.
Anna VarshavskyMarch 25, 2012
The. Best. Irish. Pub. EVER! (or at least in NYC) The burgers are as big as your head, the onion rings are to die for and the staff will never forget your face.
Kev SkinnyOctober 24, 2014
This place is everything you could ask for when in the mood for a real irish establishment. Burger knocked me on my ass in a good way.
John PaterakisSeptember 20, 2014
Been here 100+ times
Good beer, great craic, sawdust on the floor, and a roaring fireplace in the winter. It doesn't get better than this!
First We FeastAugust 4, 2014
Molly's 10-ounce burger is a juicy, messy behemoth that we'd come back for time and time again. Read more
First We FeastAugust 4, 2014
Order this: Murphy's stout, burger, chicken potpie, shepherd's pie, fish and chips Read more
Erin SheaNovember 30, 2018
Authentic “old New York”. Filled with Irish people. Order yourself a Guinness and enjoy!
smitty smoovMay 26, 2014
Eat tha corned beef and rye sammy, drink tha Murphys stout, high five tha Mayor & have a smashing time.
David DiGregorioDecember 10, 2014
This is a cozy space with a bar staff who will chat back at you. It is easy to pass hours here.
sablerMay 23, 2015
Been here 25+ times
One of the most legit Irish pubs in the city, unfortunately it gets a bit crowded on weekends
Paul KatcherJuly 1, 2014
The corned beef on toasted rye with spicy Colman'a mustard is huge, moist and a total winner.
Romi KimJune 21, 2013
A decent, relatively quiet bar when you want to get away from the douchiness that is Murray Hill (which hopefully is always...)
M GonzalezMarch 6, 2018
The burgers are amazing!
Patrick WaiversJuly 21, 2013
The brunch is delicious. Get the Irish Breakfast Deluxe!
BurgeredJanuary 18, 2013
Great burger, keeping it simple with bacon and american cheese.
M GonzalezJune 14, 2018
Burgers are the best I’ve had in NYC and the whiskey selection is great
Lauren AmaioMarch 2, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Awesome place. Totally deceiving from the outside. Great atmosphere and bartenders.
AndrewJanuary 27, 2016
The big fat juicy burgers with thick steak fries are worth the trip.
Milun TesovicMarch 18, 2012
Grab a guineas, burger and a seat at the bar for interesting comvos. Still deciding if patrons are awesome or crazy
Kim AhearnJune 12, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Great, giant burgers! But $2 fee to share a plate is bogust.
Tina LenderAugust 11, 2014
Great Irish brunch. Christmastime is festive here. Peanut shells on the floor.
Kate WagnerOctober 13, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Get some miwadi in your Guinness. One of the few bars that carry it in NYC.
Nitzan BJuly 8, 2017
Loved it so much! Best hamburger in New York and the place is really cute
Lindsay GNovember 21, 2013
Murphy's on tap, sawdust on the floor, and the best burger around. Can't beat it!
Christopher VanoOctober 30, 2013
Been here 50+ times
Best irish pub in the city. Amazing onion rings and mozzarella sticks.
Gordon MeiJuly 17, 2014
Chicken fingers + honey mustard = crazy delish. Ask about the seasonal beer.
Kate GoldJanuary 29, 2012
Molly's has one of the best burgers in town. I like mine with bleu cheese.
Ed BidenJuly 23, 2011
Guineas on tap, saw dust on floor. Almost like a real pub, complete with cheesy 80s music warbling away in the background. Not the saw dust though. That's a bit affected

1 2 3

255 Photos

Molly's Shebeen

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Molly's Shebeen

Appears on 381 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.