Georgetown Cupcake is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

1. Georgetown Cupcake

8.6
83 Newbury St (btwn Berkeley & Clarendon), Boston, MA
Cupcake Shop · Back Bay East · 113 tips and reviews

Kare C.Kare C: My favorites so far are chocolate salted caramel, cookies and cream cheesecake, and chocolate peanut butter swirl! Everything else I tried was very sweet...too sweet and too much frosting.

Kate B.Kate Bachman: Peanut butter fudge cupcake- so good

Ron O.Ron Oppenheim: Perfectly sized cupcakes. Some great ones are the chocolate salted caramel and the peanut butter fudge.

Ben & Jerry's is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

2. Ben & Jerry's

8.6
174 Newbury St, Boston, MA
Ice Cream Parlor · Back Bay East · 16 tips and reviews

Jason L.Jason Landry: Chocolate Peanut Butter Swirl is the bomb! But don't eat it all, or I'll be pissed!

Gloria C.Gloria Chin: 1) Late Night Snack – chocolate-covered potato chips. 2) Everything But The… - heath bar chunks, white chocolate chunks, peanut butter cups & chocolate-covered almonds. 3) Dublin Mudslide

Stephen S.Stephen Smart: Ben & Jerry's is great when you buy in their pints but it is so much better when you get it at one of their shops. Definitely get "The Tonight Dough" if you're into peanut butter.

Mike's Pastry is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

3. Mike's Pastry

8.5
300 Hanover St (btwn Parmenter & Prince St), Boston, MA
Pastry Shop · North End · 573 tips and reviews

Alisha S.Alisha Scott: First time to ever have cannoli.. Amazing!! Gotta try the peanut butter one!

Linda B.Linda Billotti: The peanut butter cannoli is great!

Susan K.Susan King: How many varieties of canoli can there be??? Mikey's has every one! Pistachio, peanut butter, amaretto, hazelnut, chocolate ricotta, on & on! Push your way to the counter!

Bukowski Tavern is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

4. Bukowski Tavern

7.4
50 Dalton St (btwn Belvidere & Boylston), Boston, MA
Dive Bar · Fenway - Kenmore - Audubon Circle - Longwood · 147 tips and reviews

Frank A.Frank Auer: Burger with peanut butter is fantastic!

Christopher L.Christopher Lucca: Try the peanut butter cheese burger. It may sound disgusting but it's actually delicious. I was surprised!

M💊dnune💢 H.M💊dnune💢 Hussey: Yeah..Burger with peanut butter ...great :)

Boston Burger Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

5. Boston Burger Company

8.3
1100 Boylston St (btwn Hemenway & Massachusetts Ave.), Boston, MA
Burger Joint · Fenway - Kenmore - Audubon Circle - Longwood · 101 tips and reviews

Ryan T.Ryan Troup: Get "the king". Bacon, peanut butter, caramelized onions, cinnamon and sugar. You will not regret it.

Men's Health MagMen's Health Mag: ORDER: The King. Head to Massachusetts to try this Angus beef patty—piled high with bacon, fried cinnamon-and-sugar bananas and gooey peanut butter named after the rock-and-roll icon.

Simon P.Simon P: The king with peanut butter is a killer !

J.P. Licks is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

6. J.P. Licks

8.7
1106 Boylston St (btwn Hemenway & Mass Ave), Boston, MA
Ice Cream Parlor · Fenway - Kenmore - Audubon Circle - Longwood · 21 tips and reviews

Laura S.Laura S: I love their peanut butter fro yo and it's almost always available. Great place to go on a hot summer day!

Sara T.Sara Taylor: Had a hard tome deciding between the peanut butter cookies n cream and the cookies and cake batter. They were both amazing! Lots of choices.

Virginia T.Virginia Tinsley: Everything! Love the banana Oreo ice cream, wish it was a regular flavor.

Moogy's Sandwich Shop is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

7. Moogy's Sandwich Shop

8.1
154 Chestnut Hill Ave, Brighton, MA
Sandwich Spot · 29 tips and reviews

E S.E Suliga: peanut butter heaven !

Katie C.Katie Ciampa: Pancakes- Banana with Reece's Peanut butter chips.

Tyler M.Tyler Murphy: Peanut butter chip pancakes. You CANNOT go wrong.

J.P. Licks Beacon Hill is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

8. J.P. Licks Beacon Hill

8.9
150 Charles St (btwn Cambridge & Revere St), Boston, MA
Ice Cream Parlor · Beacon Hill · 39 tips and reviews

Zane Y.Zane Younger: PUT PEANUT BUTTER SAUCE ON EVERYTHING !!!!

Emily C.Emily Chalko: All the ice creams and frozen yogurts are amazing but the peanut butter sauce topping is amazing! I love coffee froyo with peanut butter sauce and cookie dough.

🇫🇷 Michel D.🇫🇷 Michel Daoud: Spoil your Boston Terrier (or any breed) with some Cow Paws. Sir Parker White, of Beacon Hill, loves it!

Shake Shack is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

9. Shake Shack

8.3
234-236 Newbury St, Boston, MA
Burger Joint · Back Bay East · 55 tips and reviews

Hisham E.Hisham ELNAGGAR: It was amazing the burger was out of this world .. The Peanut butter milk shake is heart killing (900 Kal) amazing

IlkerIlker: Peanut butter shake was awesome!

DebbDebb: Amazing burguers, also for vegetarian people! I took the mash room burguer and it's absolutely great!

FoMu South End is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

10. FoMu South End

9.0
655 Tremont Street (West Brookline), Boston, MA
Ice Cream Parlor · South End · 9 tips and reviews

Saleh N.Saleh Nasser: Peanut butter and chocolate ice cream is very tasty.

Jennifer K.Jennifer K: Great for delicious dairy free ice cream

Gianna N.Gianna Nebbia: Coffee, baked desserts and ice cream. All Ice cream dairy free, MOST are gf. Pretty good coming from a dairy lover, but some of the flavors didn't really take like dessert- like the chocolate sauce 😬

Boston Chipyard is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

11. Boston Chipyard

8.1
257 Faneuil Hall Marketplace, Boston, MA
Bakery · Downtown Boston · 9 tips and reviews

Club MonacoClub Monaco: Our Prudential Center store team swears by the peanut butter chocolate chip cookies.

KariKari: Chocolate chip cookies are the best so soft and yummie

Gabriel P.Gabriel Pereira: Maddy joys!

Picco is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

12. Picco

8.8
513 Tremont St (at E Berkeley St), Boston, MA
Pizzeria · South End · 174 tips and reviews

Eric A.Eric Andersen: The pizzas and ice cream here are both fantastic! Try the peanut butter (when they have it)!

Nathan P.Nathan P.: Peanut Butter Ice Cream is amazing.

Thalia K.Thalia Karanasiou: Pizza was perfect! Nice mac n cheese and salads. Totally recommended!

South End Buttery is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

13. South End Buttery

8.6
314 Shawmut Ave (at Union Park St.), Boston, MA
Café · South End · 168 tips and reviews

Kixhead H.Kixhead H: get a peanut butter reese's pieces cookie and coffee but skip the dry cupcakes. also, skip this place on weekend mornings when it's beseiged by dogs, kids and their keepers.

Mike C.Mike Chau: Try the Reese's Pieces Peanut Butter Cookie - Awesome. Very chewy and peanut buttery

Brandon B.Brandon Bettencourt: Eggs Benedict are the best I've ever had. The homemade biscuit makes it.

FroyoWorld - Frozen Yogurt Lounge is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

14. FroyoWorld - Frozen Yogurt Lounge

8.3
157 Harvard Ave (Glenville Ave), Allston, MA
Frozen Yogurt Shop · 17 tips and reviews

Ally M.Ally Milewich: Taro is the best flavor that was ever created. And chocobanana and peanut butter make for a great combo!

CrystalCrystal: All their froyo is creamy (vs icey) but the green tea is pretty wonderful

Brooke E.Brooke Evans: Holy lychee tart. Very good--and this is coming from a former swirler. Staff is shockingly friendly.

Caffe Dello Sport is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Boston.

15. Caffe Dello Sport

7.8
308 Hanover St (Prince St), Boston, MA
Café · North End · 17 tips and reviews

Scott M.Scott MacKenzie: Peanut butter gelato is awesome. Still love their Nutella Cannoli

Jim W.Jim WOODIN: Caramel was amazing

Sean B.Sean Bender: the best iced cappuccino in town