Macosa Trattoria is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

1. Macosa Trattoria

9.0
310 Tompkins Ave (Quincy), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Bedford-Stuyvesant · 5 tips and reviews

Janelle G.Janelle Grace: The pasta is handmade and the olives are house-brined. I came for a large group dinner and everything was delicious, from the caprese salad to the olive oil cake.

JoJo: Oxtail pappardelle

nikininikini: The panzanella!

La Villa Pizzeria is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

2. La Villa Pizzeria

8.6
6610 Avenue U (at 66th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Mill Basin · 40 tips and reviews

T M.T M: Great fried mozzarella! Caprese salad to die for! And wonderful service

Joyce C.Joyce Coco: The lasagna. Anything with their sweet fennel sausage. Love it with the broccoli rabe. The foccacio is delicious.

Tanya C.Tanya Collette: Mia famiglia & I always sit in a (big) booth & order our usuals - baked clams, bruschetta & insalata caprese for apps & penne gamberi, calzone for entrees. Delizioso!

Cataldo's is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

3. Cataldo's

554 Vanderbilt Ave (Dean St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Prospect Heights · 47 tips and reviews

Mike P.Mike P: Pizza and caprese salad is legit

Stevan M.Stevan Milesevic: Surprisingly great pizza, probably the best in Prospect Heights. Good service, reasonable prices -- be sure to check it out if you're in the neighborhood.

Sadie R.Sadie Rosenthal: Their pizza's amazing - recommend trying garlic and artichoke hearts!!

Aurora is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

4. Aurora

8.5
70 Grand St (btwn Kent & Wythe Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Williamsburg · 129 tips and reviews

Jeff S.Jeff Stokvis: Wonderful Caprese salad

Jessie C.Jessie Catana: Amazing food. Pasta was perfectly seasoned and cooked al dente

Brooklyn365Brooklyn365: Lunch special, $20 for 3-courses and wine... awesome.

Oregano is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

5. Oregano

7.2
102 Berry St (N. 8th st), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Williamsburg · 43 tips and reviews

Tim H.Tim Hettler: A cozy, BYOB place that offers excellent pizzas. Great for small groups.

Kelsey W.Kelsey Williams: Great spot for gluten free pizza! Wouldn't recommend as a BYOB place. The corkage fee is now $15 because they can serve wine and beer now.

Alyssa A.Alyssa A.: Stumbled upon this while looking for a place to eat. Pleasant surprise-everything was great, love the ambiance!

La Nonna Ristorante & Bar is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

6. La Nonna Ristorante & Bar

7.8
184 Kent Ave (btwn N 3rd & N 4th St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Williamsburg · 22 tips and reviews

Raquelle J.Raquelle Jessie: bruschetta, burrata caprese salad, homemade pasta w. spicy sausage & pink tequila sauce, homemade linguini w. mushrooms and truffle oil, homemade lasagna order as much as you can bc everything's amaze

Lili B.Lili Baz: Fairly priced Italian food! Recommend the mushroom pasta!

Garrett C.Garrett Carey: Sacchetti Piccanti.

Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

7. Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe

9.2
433 Graham Ave (btw Withers and Frost), Brooklyn, NY
Sandwich Spot · Williamsburg · 71 tips and reviews

Doug W.Doug Wampler: Never had a bad sandwich. Healthilicious is my favorite. Lots of drinks and chip selections too.

Sabino C.Sabino Curcio: Great sandwhiches and the best coffee !

Antonio C.Antonio C: FDNY best sandwich around !

Lenny's Pizza is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

8. Lenny's Pizza

1969 86th St (btwn Bay 23rd St. & 20th Ave.), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Bensonhurst · 13 tips and reviews

Theresa R.Theresa Roldan: I love everything that I have tried - pizza, chicken rolls, mozzarella sticks, garlic knots, and rice balls! And their minestrone soup is definitely worth the wait.

Joseph D.Joseph DiMartino: Get a slice of Grandma's Pie. This place made famous by the movie Saturday Night Fever...

Joseph D.Joseph DiMartino: Great pizza and the Grandma's pie can't be beat....

George's Restaurant is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

9. George's Restaurant

7.4
753 Coney Island Ave (at Cortelyou Rd.), Brooklyn, NY
Diner · Flatbush · 14 tips and reviews

William C.William Cerf: George's is a family owned restaurant started in 1956. Now reopened after total makeover. Great food at very resonable prices

Jake S.Jake Smith: Make sure you order home fries with whatever you plan on eating.

Stan K.Stan Killian: Angelo and Christina are awesome! Tip them well!

Luigi's Pizza is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

10. Luigi's Pizza

7.3
4704 5th Ave (46 street), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Sunset Park · 3 tips and reviews

Tom M.Tom Maxim: awesome chicken parm slice

Lupe C.Lupe C: Is a good place to eat pizza

Tanika T.Tanika Talbert: Pepperoni was okay. Thin crust, greasy , NY pizza. We ordered late and and mozzarella pizza was old,

Armando's Pizza is one of The 11 Best Places for Caprese Salad in Brooklyn.

11. Armando's Pizza

7.6
1717 Broadway (Cooper), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Bushwick · 6 tips and reviews

Tonia D.Tonia Darrisaw: The spinach rolls are deelish :-)

Ronin W.Ronin Wood: Great slices

Brian Wellington IIIBrian Wellington III: Pizza 🍕 is good