1. Anthony's Place
7.8
2110 Avenue X (btwn E 21st & E 22nd St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 10 tips and reviews
The Corcoran Group: Straightforward, home-style Italian food, with the BEST garlic knots. Get the house salad, followed by fried zucchini and something from their specials menu.
Gregory Fillinger: Good stuff
Ilyssa D: Fresh, delicious, can't go wrong with anything on this menu...and top it off with zeppoles!
Lauren: Great fresh mozz, calamari, focaccia. Definitely make a reservation if it's a weekend night. This place is bumpin'.
Ricardo Lupo: You can't go wrong with any of the selections. If you're looking for treat however, indulge in the chicken wings with hot sauce. They are seriously some of the best wings I have ever had!!!
Tom Maxim: Meatball appetizer with ricotta
3. Randazzo's Clam Bar
8.1
2017 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 96 tips and reviews
Natalya: Start off with Loster Bisque, the fresh oysters anytime of the year, steamed female lobster, yumm fried zucchini on the side mussel di zuppas great as well and so is the stuffed lobster, just everythi
The Corcoran Group: A landmark restaurant serving fresh seafood! Get the Lobster Bisque & Spicy Crab, then the Combo with Hot Sauce or the Cold Seafood Platter and a side of biscuits.
#ultrafacts: The seafood here is locally sourced from a secret cove off the Verrazzano. Only "Old Starple," the Randazzo family fisherman, knows the coordinates.
4. La Villa
8.2
261 5th Ave (btw Garfield Pl & 1st St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Central Slope · 86 tips and reviews
john staub: Cannot go wrong with any of the pastas, pizzas and specials. The fried zucchini is right on. Not greasy w fresh zucchini and great gravy. All around friendly staff and the Peroni on tap? Spot on.
Franncis P: Good pizza, food is great also. House wine is nice. Service is good.
Leah Kopperman: Keep an eye out for Groupons for La Villa. For some unknown reason, they offer them quite regularly. The last $30 meal I got cost only $10 because of a Groupon.
6. Michael's
8.3
2929 Avenue R (at Nostrand Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 11 tips and reviews
Amy Carothers: The Chilean Sea Bass is amazing and taste the scallop appetizer for a succulent starter!
Eater: The menu hits all the old Italian-American classics with some newfangled stuff thrown in, mainly on the specials menu, which often features wild boar stew, arugula and orange salad, and burrata. Read more.
Alicia Rudick: Fantastic food and the staff is superb! It truly is a small family kinda restaurant.. But we were treated like family! Your of the sauce making! Try the biscotti, lobster far diavlo!! Absolutely fa
8. Pizza D' Amore
8.4
2147 Mill Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Mill Basin · 16 tips and reviews
Illan Weiner: Everything, from the heart-shaped pizza to the pepperoni pinwheel to their pasta, is exceptional!
The Corcoran Group: While "pizza" is in the name of this spot, we love the pastas here, especially the penne vodka. Great chicken parm too!
Ken MacBride: Great FAMILY atmosphere!
9. Mama Rao's
8.5
6408 11th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Borough Park · 21 tips and reviews
Mary Jasen: The food was fantastic, the beet salad was so great, shrimp Oreganata was so light and string beans done just right. The Snowflake dessert drink was outstanding’
🌺 Lauren S 🇺🇸: Best lemon cookies around : )
💋StephanieMarie💋: After you eat go next door & pick up their DELISH lemon cookies! They have a wide selection of cookies & food! Heaven
13. La Villa Pizzeria
8.6
6610 Avenue U (at 66th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Mill Basin · 40 tips and reviews
Joyce Coco: The lasagna. Anything with their sweet fennel sausage. Love it with the broccoli rabe. The foccacio is delicious.
Tanya Collette: Mia famiglia & I always sit in a (big) booth & order our usuals - baked clams, bruschetta & insalata caprese for apps & penne gamberi, calzone for entrees. Delizioso!
PizzaSnobo pizzasnobo.com: The pizza is good but not great. La Villa also serves a full Italian menu. Pleasant place for a meal.