1. Shake Shack
8.9
409 Fulton St (at Boerum Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Burger Joint · Downtown Brooklyn · 240 tips and reviews
Flo Flo: Hands down the best fast food burger out there! Get the mushroom burger, it has cheese inside the shroom that explodes in your mouth when you bite into it...nuff' said!
Joel Betances: Love the shroom burger
Lauren Varga: Whoa! The Shack Stack, which has the burger & shroom on one bun, is amazing!
2. Five Leaves
8.9
18 Bedford Ave (at Lorimer St), Brooklyn, NY
New American Restaurant · Greenpoint · 535 tips and reviews
Soapy Jankel: Get there early to get a table, you might need to wait around 30 minutes at busy times. Get the truffle oil fries, the burger and the mushrooms on toast are amazing. Also try the mimosa cocktail!
Hailey Donaldson: By far my favorite brunch place in Brooklyn. Perfect ambiance, great food, though the staff (and long wait) could use some work. I recommend the Mushroom Toast, it's heavenly!
Vera Aaa: Mushroom sandwitch is delicious! Love it!
6. Peppino's Pizza
8.8
469 5th Ave (at 10th St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · South Slope · 56 tips and reviews
Monica Lo: Pizza alla vodka with vodka sauce, mushroom & prosciutto = love
Behrad Eats: Nice casual pizza shop with some delicious pies. I recommend the Pizza Alla Vodka made with vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, mushrooms, and prosciutto. And grab a Brooklyn Lager to wash it down.
J Crowley: Believe the hype about the vodka pizza with mushrooms and prosciutto. It might be one of my favorites pizzas ever. Well worth the $27.
7. Kings County Imperial
9.1
20 Skillman Ave (btwn Union Ave & Lorimer St), Brooklyn, NY
Chinese Restaurant · Williamsburg · 119 tips and reviews
Bin Yang: Mock eel's flavor and crunch is spot on like the traditional non-mock dish; ends up with juicy umami packed mushrooms - it's great. Get the soup dumplings, ants on a tree, and the crispy chicken!
Bre: They weren't kidding about the mock eel — amazing. (And this is coming from someone who usually hates mushrooms!)
Matt Green: Mock eel was so good! (It's fried mushrooms) I also liked the pork fried rice and the pork soup dumplings.
8. Brook Vin
8.6
381 7th Ave (btwn 11th & 12th St), Brooklyn, NY
Wine Bar · South Slope · 90 tips and reviews
Katherine: Its all about the creamed mushroom crostini!!
Nate Folkert: roasted mushroom tartine: creamed mushrooms, scallion, Reggiano, truffle oil, on sourdough
Margarita Krup: Amazing wine list and small plates. Try the meatballs, cheese platter and mushroom tartine.
9. Piccoli Trattoria
8.4
522 6th Ave (at 14th St.), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · South Slope · 54 tips and reviews
Keri N.: The polenta and mushroom appetizer is delicious. Everything I've tried here has been flavorful yet simple. No sauce or salt overkill. My current fave place in the Slope.
Adam Goldberg: Excellent! My faves - the polenta with mushrooms appetizer and the butternut squash ravioli entree.
simhskal: Excellent pastas and salad. Recommend Gnocchi with mushrooms and cream, risotto with butternut squash and blood orange tiramisu for real!
10. al di là
8.7
248 5th Ave (at Carroll St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · North Slope · 200 tips and reviews
ConciergeQ: What is your favorite smell or taste in Brooklyn? Simone Dinnerstein, Classical Pianist: "The polenta with mushrooms at al di la." Read more.
Jill Hoffman: One of the best brunches I've had in BK. Try the white salad to start and then get the polenta with mushrooms... Amazing!
With Love from Brooklyn: No wait at lunchtime. Yes!!! @ABCDsofCooking recommends the mushroom polenta with poached egg.
11. Ugly Baby
8.9
407 Smith St (at Fourth Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Thai Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 78 tips and reviews
Marie Richer: Super spicy! Duck salad, pineapple mushroom curry and coconut taro cakes were so good. Friendly, helpful and fast service. 🔥🌶❤️👶🏻
Zucchini Rose: Laab (duck salad), Kao Tod Nam Klook (curry rice), and Kang Kua Supparod (mushroom, pineapple 🍍 curry) all super delicious! Can’t wait to come back!
Kathryn D: Best in NYC, especially the mushroom curry.
12. Colonie
9.2
127 Atlantic Ave (btwn Henry & Clinton St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Brooklyn Heights · 245 tips and reviews
Jeremy Goldstein: Mushroom toast for brunch. Light and flavorful.
The New York Times: Have some ricotta on toast to begin, mushrooms or a steak if available, and a date cake you can walk off with a hike down Atlantic Avenue, to Brooklyn Bridge Park. Read more.
Mell Perling: Shrimp and grits are excellent. Leek and mushroom scramble was ok, but similar dishes are done better elsewhere in the neighborhood
14. Hot Potato House
8.8
109 Oriental Blvd (Westend Avenue), Brooklyn, NY
Eastern European Restaurant · Manhattan Beach · 9 tips and reviews
Emil H: The Hot Potato House is like a mushroom omelette made out of a potato latke. Tasty!
Lalita Salgaokar: Mushroom, cheese stuffed latkes and the Borscht. So. Damn. Good. Service is fantastic too.
Svetlana Amirkhanov: Beet salad-mixed greens, baked beets, pear, caramelized walnuts and blue cheese make it so delicious