3. Michael's
8.4
2929 Avenue R (at Nostrand Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 11 tips and reviews
Amy Carothers: The Chilean Sea Bass is amazing and taste the scallop appetizer for a succulent starter!
Eater: The menu hits all the old Italian-American classics with some newfangled stuff thrown in, mainly on the specials menu, which often features wild boar stew, arugula and orange salad, and burrata. Read more.
Alicia Rudick: Fantastic food and the staff is superb! It truly is a small family kinda restaurant.. But we were treated like family! Your of the sauce making! Try the biscotti, lobster far diavlo!! Absolutely fa
5. V & S Pizza
8.4
1723 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Sheepshead Bay · 5 tips and reviews
Allen S.: The pizza here is some of the best regular-oven pizza I've ever tasted. Their grandma slice to fresh mozzarella to veggie slice, and even calzone, everything tastes great.
Leah Labrecque: The best sauce around makes it well worth the trip!
Andrei Bibikov: Accepting orders online www.dinnerout.com/restaurant/97/menu Use coupon: FOUR20 & get 20% Off.
Brian Masefield: Love the $12 or less table. Staff is supremely helpful too.
estheribrown ✌🏻: The staff here are super friendly and helpful - they're happy to make recommendations and I've never had a miss w/one. Love the $12 and under table and the free wine tastings & classes. Great shop.
Scott Flaherty: I'm no connoisseur (tend to pick wine by the design on the label), but it seems like they keep the cheaper stuff on a table in the middle, and in general have a great selection.
13. Peppino's Pizza
8.8
469 5th Ave (at 10th St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · South Slope · 56 tips and reviews
Helena Wong: Closest thing to old school Italian in Park Slope. Pasta dishes rocked w/ large portions. We loved the Penne Rustico & anything w/ their homemade tomato sauce. Need to try the pizza, parm & meatballs
Kev Skinny: If you have a choice between here and Toby's choose Peppinos.That alla vodka pie with help you find Jesus you pagan s.o.b. I will tell u, the manager and service is amazing.These ppl run a great spot.
Behrad Eats: Nice casual pizza shop with some delicious pies. I recommend the Pizza Alla Vodka made with vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, mushrooms, and prosciutto. And grab a Brooklyn Lager to wash it down.
15. Nick's Lobster House
7.4
2777 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Southeastern Brooklyn · 416 tips and reviews
Tanya Collette: Shrimp scampi's great, but flooded w/ oil on the bottom. Servers don't hover over you. Overall, great seafood!
LysperApp For iPhone: The service was top notch. Our waiter let us know about the specials, and the kitchen accommodated my request for rice vs pasta with the shrimp scampi. Everything was delicious. We'll be back for...
LysperApp For iPhone: Wonderful experience, the food and service was excellent, we are never disappointed with the food and service. Our server Jeff was amazing great service.