Brancaccio's is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

1. Brancaccio's

8.9
3011 Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY
Food and Beverage Retail · Windsor Terrace · 44 tips and reviews

Nate F.Nate Folkert: tilapia sandwich with mesclun greens and house-made tartar sauce

Jesse L.Jesse Lane: Small, neighborhood sandwich shop in Windsor Terrace. Pork shoulder sandwich (with prosciutto, fontina cheese and sweet gherkins) is a must for any first timer.

Real Cheap EatsReal Cheap Eats: Try the rotisserie chicken. "Dressed with lemon, garlic, herbs and spices, then roasted perfectly, it’s just the kind of chicken dinner you’d put on the table if you had the time." Read more.

Brooklyn Public House is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

2. Brooklyn Public House

8.8
247 Dekalb Ave (at Vanderbilt Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Cocktail Bar · Clinton Hill · 132 tips and reviews

Rick D.Rick Dennstedt: Great late night dining in sleepy Fort Greene. The catfish sandwich was great and the unique "tartar sauce" was so hipster!

Marty A.Marty Allen: This joint is swell, and it's easily the best darn burger in a many-blocked radius. Solid draft list with good daily specials. Good bar.

Orkun B.Orkun Beydagi: The most delicious french fries I have ever eaten

The Double Windsor is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

3. The Double Windsor

9.0
210 Prospect Park W (at 16th St), Brooklyn, NY
Bar · South Slope · 161 tips and reviews

Emily W.Emily W: Great food! Best homemade tartar sauce. Really generous portions. Communal seating and be prepared to wait for a table though.

Susannah G.Susannah Gruder: A heavenly neighborhood spot. Plenty of room to sit and enjoy some mussels & fries (food epiphany) on weeknights, weekends are crowded & fun. Amazing tap selection - try the Green Flash.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Beer is the main event here but you'd be making a mistake to overlook the food menu: great burgers and sandwiches and really good wings among other things. It's all good.

Elia Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

4. Elia Restaurant

8.2
8611 3rd Ave (Near 86 street), Brooklyn, NY
Greek Restaurant · Bay Ridge · 13 tips and reviews

Ilona K.Ilona Kirnos: My favorite restaurant in Brooklyn! Absolutely adore their grilled octopus. Their other food is great, but this one is a must!

michael m.michael marinakis: I just love this place consistent and great!

Lia K.Lia Kefalonikas: Grilled fish is the best... I highly recommend the grilled octopus.....

Chinar is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

5. Chinar

8.0
2775 Coney Island Ave (Ave Y), Brooklyn, NY
Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 8 tips and reviews

Sachin B.Sachin Bhagat: all types of salad; baked potatoes with mashroom, basa fish, food is amazing ;) try anything ;)

Alex Z.Alex Zaltsman: Great place! Recommend the sea bass and branzino. Try to get a table to the far left on the balcony section. The music can get loud on the main floor.

Courtney W.Courtney Wendel: Having a good time.

Bogota Latin Bistro is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

6. Bogota Latin Bistro

8.7
141 5th Ave (at St. Johns Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Colombian Restaurant · North Slope · 251 tips and reviews

AdamAdam: Grilled catfish, jalapeño marinade, fruit salsa & cilantro tartar sauce. Arepa de Chocolo, con Queso Blanco. (via Scoville) Read more.

James H.James Horan: Quinoa = yum! Make sure to go light on the apps or you won't have room for your entree. Everything was delicious

Farid L.Farid Lancheros: The Bandeja Paisa is the specialty dish

Hunter's Steak & Ale House is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

7. Hunter's Steak & Ale House

8.2
9404 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Steakhouse · Bay Ridge · 19 tips and reviews

Mary J.Mary Jasen: Another great meal at Hunter's excellent chicken francese ! Service always friendly and nice. Great band tonight!!!

Daniel H.Daniel H: surf and turf!!!

Lisa R.Lisa Ryan: Went here for my 29th bday and the food was AMAZING. .the staff was so friendly and there was a man there playing a keyboard and he was awesome, we knew every song! !' Wonderful dining experience!

Il Porto is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

8. Il Porto

8.5
37 Washington Avenue (Flushing), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Clinton Hill · 36 tips and reviews

Jean HannahJean Hannah: Do not tell anyone about this place -- its obscurity is integral to its charm, along with the phenomenal pizza (the small is more than enough for 2 to share). Lovely staff, too.

AvaAva: Grandma slice with extra pepperoni!

Marika H.Marika H: The grandma slices are amazing! If your drinking, try any one of the Bellinis.

Anthony's Place is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

9. Anthony's Place

7.8
2110 Avenue X (btwn E 21st & E 22nd St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 10 tips and reviews

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Straightforward, home-style Italian food, with the BEST garlic knots. Get the house salad, followed by fried zucchini and something from their specials menu.

Gregory F.Gregory Fillinger: Good stuff

Ilyssa D.Ilyssa D: Fresh, delicious, can't go wrong with anything on this menu...and top it off with zeppoles!

Mexico 2000 is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

10. Mexico 2000

8.4
367 Broadway (btw Keap & Hooper), Brooklyn, NY
Taco Restaurant · East Williamsburg · 36 tips and reviews

Emily W.Emily Wilson: Great place to celebrate a birthday with a group. Be sure to let them know and they'll make it fun. The tableside guac is seriously good and they'll do all kinds of pitchers of margs (frozen or not).

Tim V.Tim Vetter: Weird food club score: Get a quesadilla con huitlacoche aka Mexican truffle aka corn smut, not easy to find in NYC. $4. http://www.brooklyntheborough.com/2010/08/the-dish-uncovering-huitlacoche/

Time Out New YorkTime Out New York: Try the flor de calabaza quesadilla. Fresh masa is griddled, then topped with mounds of sautéed squash blossoms, cotija cheese, crema and lettuce. It’s one of our #100best dishes and drinks of 2011. Read more.

Wasan is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

11. Wasan

7.8
440 Bergen St (5th Ave & Flatbush Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Japanese Restaurant · North Slope · 13 tips and reviews

HolidayHoliday: Lunch and brunch bento boxes are the way to go. suburb quality and value. We had the grilled chicken and a few sushi rolls. Def be back!

Jessica N.Jessica Nicole: Loved the tuna roll, seaweed salad and shishito peppers!

RoRo: Sushi all day.

Shaking Crab is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

12. Shaking Crab

7.7
230 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · North Slope · 5 tips and reviews

Trendy D.Trendy Danie: The seafood combo bags are great . The drinks are good as well .

AdamAdam: Not a PO’boy. Bread is all wrong.

Andy P.Andy Poon: Not your typical snow crab legs with butter on the side.

Brooklyn Pizza Crew is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

13. Brooklyn Pizza Crew

7.8
758 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Crown Heights · 15 tips and reviews

alex L.alex L: Grandma slice for the win! Same owners as Williamsburg pizza in LES and wBurg. The best!

Al W.Al Write: Build your own pizza if you’re picky/creative.

Lisa S.Lisa Schreibman: For slice pizza, we walk here from Prospect Heights. Cause it is better pizza.

Royal Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

14. Royal Restaurant

7.7
7609 5th Ave (76th Street), Brooklyn, NY
Diner · Bay Ridge · 12 tips and reviews

Gail F.Gail Frohlinger: I had waffles and ice cream. Super friendly staff and delicious breakfast..see you soonest : -)

Vicario Brensley P.Vicario Brensley Phillip: The Best Diner in BayRidge! Ask for George and Tom...they will take care of you.

Victor L.Victor Law: Best breakfast in Bay Ridge. I love their french toast. No other diner around here has good home fries except them!

Le Paddock is one of The 15 Best Places for Tartar Sauce in Brooklyn.

15. Le Paddock

8.5
1235 Prospect Ave (at Reeve Pl.), Brooklyn, NY
French Restaurant · Windsor Terrace · 58 tips and reviews

Steve L.Steve LeVine: Expected to have: wood-burning pizza, cheeses and charcuteries platters, mussels, a great burger, and other small plates and specials dishes made with seasonal and local products. Read more.

Steve L.Steve LeVine: New Lemon-Pear Martini (made with Soju) is light and refreshing.

7th.List7th.List: Vibe: A casual place for neighbors to meet and hang out while enjoying good wines by the glass, wood-burning pizza such as Pissaladiere and Flammenkuche, cheeses and charcuteries platters, mussels Read more.