Paneantico is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

1. Paneantico

8.7
9124 3rd Ave (at 92nd St.), Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · Bay Ridge · 59 tips and reviews

Alison B.Alison Beth: Tuna salad is amazing here! The dressing is delish

Mary J.Mary Jasen: Dessert is great, Strawberry Shortcake lite and fluffy with "real" whip cream, tiramisu also tasty and light.

LadyMissDiLadyMissDi: Get the # 9 sandwich on brick oven bread with chicken cutlet - the best!!

Mill Basin Bagel Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

2. Mill Basin Bagel Cafe

7.9
6319 Avenue N, Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · Bergen Beach · 12 tips and reviews

Joyce C.Joyce C: Love the lox, tuna salad and the baked salmon. Expensive, but worth it. Always crowded, but line moves fast.

Catherine R.Catherine Ritorto: Great place for bagels and specialty coffees

Tricia S.Tricia Sheehan: Good bagels. Quick service.

Highway Bagels is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

3. Highway Bagels

7.8
1923 Kings Hwy (Ocean Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · Sheepshead Bay · 8 tips and reviews

Bruce S.Bruce Solomon: Fantastic Tuna Salad here.

Lucia D.Lucia Di: After trying several bagel shops, this is the best in the area. Seating area available. Nice staff.

Lucia D.Lucia Di: The very overpriced tip is incorrect. I found it to be very reasonable and cheaper than the others on the area. Whole grain bagel w lox spread $3.

Fob Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

4. Fob Restaurant

8.1
271 Smith St (Degraw and Sackett), Brooklyn, NY
Filipino Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 31 tips and reviews

Matej M.Matej Mavriček: The lemongrass punch was delicious, but the overnight adobo with thr garlic rice was fantastic. Thr flounder was very nice, not mind blowing. Tuna salad with Taro chips excellent.

Elaine L.Elaine Lin: Incredible pancakes (get the plain) on the brunch menu.. hands down the best in the neighborhood. All the bbqs are good.

Valentin G.Valentin Guerin: Nice outdoor, but service was very slow (even if the restaurant was empty) and food was just ok

Fifth Avenue Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

5. Fifth Avenue Market

8.1
185 5th Ave (at Berkeley Pl.), Brooklyn, NY
Deli · North Slope · 30 tips and reviews

Giang B.Giang B: Tuna salad sandwich

keri s.keri setaro: This is by far the best deli in the slope. Sandwiches are fresh and out of control good. Great organic beauty section too!

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Open 24hrs! Great sandwiches and the greatest guys behind the counter. Mo and Sammy are always there, always remember you and always put a smile on your face.

Stolovaya is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

6. Stolovaya

7.8
813 Avenue U (btwn 8th & 9th St), Brooklyn, NY
Russian Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 27 tips and reviews

Maxim I.Maxim Ilin: Bitochki po selyanski and tuna salad are my favorites!!!

ChrystieChrystie: Authentic Homestyle Russian food. Get some vodka to shoot and some cherry compote. Start with the Siberian Pelmeni (dumplings) and a Cheburecki. The Beef Stroganoff is the BEST here. Kebabs are great.

Raisa B.Raisa Berger: This place is like coming home to mom's place after living by yourself for a decade. Excellent food, excellent atmosphere.

Panera Bread is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

7. Panera Bread

7.6
345 Adams St, Brooklyn, NY
Bakery · Downtown Brooklyn · 52 tips and reviews

Dei W.Dei West: The tuna salad on honey wheat sandwich is a must try to tuna lovers!

Julie M.Julie Morse: Love the Pick 2, the salad portion is perfect and you can either get a sandwich or soup to go with it. Tomato soup is really good and the spicy thai chicken salad!!

JBMJBM: So, plenty of seating upstairs to do work. Nice service.

BKLYN Larder is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

8. BKLYN Larder

8.7
228 Flatbush Ave (at Bergen St), Brooklyn, NY
Gourmet Store · North Slope · 122 tips and reviews

Dhruva G.Dhruva Ganesan: Tuna salad sandwich - get it with heirloom tomatoes - they just got them from the market today.

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Pricey but lovely market with great sandwiches, cheese, pantry and prepared foods, ice cream, and more, with many products made in Brooklyn.

Hanna Y.Hanna Yum: Sandwich punch card. Buy 9 get the 10th for $1

Hot Potato House is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

9. Hot Potato House

8.8
109 Oriental Blvd (Westend Avenue), Brooklyn, NY
Eastern European Restaurant · Manhattan Beach · 9 tips and reviews

Svetlana A.Svetlana Amirkhanov: Beet salad-mixed greens, baked beets, pear, caramelized walnuts and blue cheese make it so delicious

Emil H.Emil H: The Hot Potato House is like a mushroom omelette made out of a potato latke. Tasty!

Chris G.Chris Gampat: Get the massive thing of pig meat. And the latkes.

Knickerbocker Bagel is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

10. Knickerbocker Bagel

8.9
367 Knickerbocker Ave (btwn Stockholm & Stanhope St), Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · Bushwick · 16 tips and reviews

Megan M.Megan McNally: Some of the best bagels in Brooklyn. Get the lox and capers.

Myles H.Myles Hunt: My favorite bagels in the area so far, tasty and big with plenty of spreads including vegan options!

aytayt: amazing cream cheese presentation

Konditori is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

11. Konditori

7.8
186 5th Ave (btwn Lincoln & Berkeley Pl.), Brooklyn, NY
Coffee Shop · North Slope · 74 tips and reviews

7th.List7th.List: It’s what they call coffee shops in Sweden. Konditori’s specialty is a medium-roast, Swedish-style house blend.In addition to the daily roasted coffee, there are bagels, muffins, tuna salad, & Mazarin Read more.

Ty M.Ty McMahan: Best coffee in the neighborhood. Dough donuts. Friendly owner and staff.

Micke H.Micke Håkansson: Not anything Swedish about it, but the coffee was decent.

Bagelsmith is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

12. Bagelsmith

8.2
566 Lorimer St (at Metropolitan Ave), Brooklyn, NY
Bagel Shop · East Williamsburg · 107 tips and reviews

Alex P.Alex Pyatetsky: For my keto folk, the tuna salad here is quite good (reminds me of WholeFoods). Besides bagels it's like a nicer bodega.

A M.A M: Super delicious bagels, reasonably priced. Takes cards, has 2 ATMs.

Dalia K.Dalia K: i think the bagel i had here saved my life. thank you based bagel god

Knapp Pizza II is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

13. Knapp Pizza II

8.4
261 Avenue X (at W 3rd St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Gravesend · 10 tips and reviews

arthur a.arthur abbensett: I had the buffalo chicken pizza and garlic knots, two days in a row.....super good. Dope place to eat and hang out !

khrystsina t.khrystsina tryboi: Always get tomato,mozzarella and basil slice!

Roxanne S.Roxanne Sharpe: Get the online coupons

Mejlander and Mulgannon Delicatessen is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

14. Mejlander and Mulgannon Delicatessen

8.5
7615 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Sandwich Spot · Bay Ridge · 11 tips and reviews

owen m.owen masiello: The pot pie is delicious, well everything is but the pot pie and the philly cheesesteak are my fave

Timothy B.Timothy Borock: Order the Cardiac Arrest w/ Peter Lugers steak sauce. Best sandwich anywhere!!!

Ana C.Ana C: Home of the Brooklyn cupcakes. Yummm. M&M makes everything great!!! Love this spot!!

Peppino's is one of The 15 Best Places for Tuna Salad in Brooklyn.

15. Peppino's

8.6
7708 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Bay Ridge · 16 tips and reviews

Iuliia SIuliia S: Eggplant parmigiana roll is perfect, love it

Alexandra K.Alexandra Kang: Great family food!

Chef FrytzChef Frytz: Down and dirty Italiano...Brooklyn style. You really can't go wrong with anything. They even have a wine frig with more than a few choices.