Anderson's Frozen Custard is one of The 9 Best Places for Custard in Buffalo.

1. Anderson's Frozen Custard

8.7
2634 Delaware Ave (in Delaware Consumer Square), Buffalo, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · North Delaware · 31 tips and reviews

Samantha N.Samantha Nephew: Best custards!

Laketa C.Laketa C.: Pistachio frozen custard! my fave, yum! Call to see if they have it before you go, it's a special flavor they have once in a while.

Elliott V.Elliott Vance: Sponge candy ice cream is the titties

Hanna's Frosty Treats is one of The 9 Best Places for Custard in Buffalo.

2. Hanna's Frosty Treats

7.6
140 Taunton Pl (at Colvin Ave), Buffalo, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · North Park · 9 tips and reviews

Jeromy A.Jeromy Allsop: Best custard!!!

Alicia M.Alicia Maniotis: They do complimentary doggy cones!! Awesome service :)

Barb K.Barb Ketterer: Strawberry ice!!!!

Oliver's is one of The 9 Best Places for Custard in Buffalo.

3. Oliver's

8.4
2095 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · Park Meadow · 20 tips and reviews

Amnon B.Amnon B: Seafood risotto was amazing.swordfish was prepared beautifully and strawberry sorbet was excellent .Sunday wine at half price ...how lucky we are.

Adam Robert B.Adam Robert Bartha: U.S.D.A. Prime Filet Mignon • yukon gold mashed potatoes, broccoli & foie gras butter

Brandi S.Brandi S.: Lemon drop martini....Yum!

The Black Sheep is one of The 9 Best Places for Custard in Buffalo.

4. The Black Sheep

8.0
367 Connecticut St (at 14th St), Buffalo, NY
Eastern European Restaurant · West Side · 12 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Poland: "Then there was the sticky toffee pudding, a Bistro Europa gem. It’s like butter making love to caramel under a whipped cream canopy. Expressed as cake." Buffalo News. 100% correct. YUM

Marge N.Marge Novara: Pierogis were over the top delicious. I had chicken breast on a purée of vegetables. It was great! The sticky toffee pudding with their coffee ended aa incredible meal.

Steve P.Steve Poland: French fries were amazing. Love the charcuterie (3 meats). Homemade bread. Need to try the clams. Great fancy cocktails, beers and wine selection. Love the ambiance.

Tokyo II Steakhouse is one of The 9 Best Places for Custard in Buffalo.

5. Tokyo II Steakhouse

7.6
2262 Delaware Ave (at Linden Ave), Buffalo, NY
Japanese Restaurant · North Delaware · 16 tips and reviews

Kevin O.Kevin O'Keefe: The Unagi-Don is the best I've had. Also best sushi rice in town I've had so far, and i don't think enough places realize how big a difference that makes. Part of what makes the Unagi-Don so good.

Cassandra L.Cassandra Lyons: Wu Tang eats here!!!

Emily B.Emily Bolles: Came in a few minutes before closing (we thought they were open later than they actually were) they still served us, we're incredibly polite and gave us soup on the house. Amazing customer service!

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffé is one of The 9 Best Places for Custard in Buffalo.

6. Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffé

7.8
1292 Hertel Ave (at Crestwood Ave), Buffalo, NY
Italian Restaurant · North Park · 23 tips and reviews

Buffalo E.Buffalo Eats: I'm addicted to their sweets, the Florentine's are fantastic and cheap. Good Italian food as well but the bakery is what keeps me coming back.

Libby M.Libby MacDougall: Cassata cake!

Amy K.Amy Kirst: Pizza is big enough for two.

Family Tree Restaurant is one of The 9 Best Places for Custard in Buffalo.

7. Family Tree Restaurant

8.0
4346 Bailey Ave, Buffalo, NY
Greek Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews

Casey G.Casey Garbaty: HUGE serving size for the dinner specials. Excellent quality! I will be back!

Nancy S.Nancy S. ☕☃️❄️: Veggie Lasagna is good, but it is not tomato-based, so make sure you like lots of cheese

Sally G.Sally G: Great place to have it your way!

99 Fast Food Restaurant is one of The 9 Best Places for Custard in Buffalo.

8. 99 Fast Food Restaurant

8.1
3396 Bailey Ave (btwn Rounds & Highgate), Buffalo, NY
Vietnamese Restaurant · 31 tips and reviews

Brien H.Brien Hall: Their egg rolls are actually spring rolls, their spring rolls are actually summer rolls. All their food is awesome

Buffalo E.Buffalo Eats: Order a bowl of Pho, but not their Banh Mi. Not served on baguettes last we checked.

Kyle B.Kyle Brazier: Put a little kick into your Pho, add sriracha sauce