Marco's Italian Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

1. Marco's Italian Deli

8.5
1518 Hertel Ave (at Wellington Rd), Buffalo, NY
Deli · North Park · 14 tips and reviews

Paul P.Paul Pellitieri: All of the "Sangwhiches" are delicious and worth try, all have generous helping of meat and toppings. My personal favorite is the Forget About It, their chili mayo is awesome

Joey B.Joey Bucheker: Outstanding sandwiches. Corned Beef to die for.

Ed G.Ed Glass: Best sub: Mama Mia. Best soup (when in season): Italian Wedding. Great food! Give it a try. You won't be disappointed.

Lexington Co-Op is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

2. Lexington Co-Op

8.8
807 Elmwood Ave (at Auburn Ave), Buffalo, NY
Grocery Store · Delaware - West Ferry · 37 tips and reviews

WalterWalter: Their in house turkey sandwitch with cranberry mayo is outstanding. You can also get a great cup of coffee to go! And buy some groceries.

SushiaSushia: great ready to eat items for lunch, make sure you become a member-owner!

Xavier G.Xavier Guillaume: Their Grinch dip is amaaaazing! It's in the prepared food section.

Coco Bar & Bistro is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

3. Coco Bar & Bistro

8.5
888 Main St (btwn Virginia & Allen), Buffalo, NY
French Restaurant · Allen · 12 tips and reviews

Elliott V.Elliott Vance: Get the rosemary frites

Roger C.Roger Chen: Everything..... Unpretentious French bistro.

Niagara PopcornNiagara Popcorn: The mussels are amazing!

Nickel City Cheese & Mercantile is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

4. Nickel City Cheese & Mercantile

8.2
346 Connecticut St (at Normal Ave), Buffalo, NY
Cheese Store · West Side · 7 tips and reviews

MalindaMalinda: Gorgeous, huge patio in the back! If the weather is great and you have time, it is a MUST!

Buffalo E.Buffalo Eats: Great selection of cured meats, imported cheeses and other foodie goodies (chocolates, jams, olives)

Dan G.Dan Green: Breakfast sandwiches and joe bean coffee. Mmm.

Chris' NY Sandwich Co is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

5. Chris' NY Sandwich Co

8.6
395 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY
Sandwich Spot · Allen · 25 tips and reviews

Joe D.Joe DiNardo: Cajun Chicken Salad Croissant is AMAZING

Jibreel R.Jibreel R: Remember this is Downtown Buffalo. It closes at 15:00 thus come early, come often; just before 3 p.m. because this is Downtown Buffalo.

Zachary S.Zachary Schneider: Always the best. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Best to grab a cookie on the way out.

La Nova Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

6. La Nova Pizzeria

8.8
371 W Ferry St (at Hampshire St), Buffalo, NY
Pizzeria · West Side · 24 tips and reviews

Maki S.Maki S: I got a free slice of pizza at the Sabres game. It was very tasty! They use generous amount of cheese and pepperonis are crunchy and spicy! Thank you for your generosity!

SushiaSushia: I think this is the best pizza in town!

Matt C.Matt Carlucci: BBQ Wings may be my favorite thing to eat in all of Buffalo Read more.

Anderson's Frozen Custard is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

7. Anderson's Frozen Custard

8.8
2634 Delaware Ave (in Delaware Consumer Square), Buffalo, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · North Delaware · 31 tips and reviews

Kevin v.Kevin van wagner: Carmel Apple crisp ice cream is amazing

Elliott V.Elliott Vance: Sponge candy ice cream is the titties

Cara A.Cara Ann: Seasonal Special: Hot Apple Crisp Sundae. Yum!

Pearl Street Grill & Brewery is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

8. Pearl Street Grill & Brewery

8.3
76 Pearl St (at Seneca St), Buffalo, NY
Brewery · Central Business District · 168 tips and reviews

Beverly F.Beverly Fillinger: Chicken spinach sandwich was awesome even without the garlic mayo!

Alex N.Alex Nesselbeck: Get the trainwreck!

Gabi B.Gabi Bulumac: I like this place 👍 raspberry and blueberry beer 😂 Brew Masters are really good😜Great experience !

Blackthorn Restaurant & Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

9. Blackthorn Restaurant & Pub

8.4
2134 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · South Buffalo · 25 tips and reviews

Marge N.Marge Novara: French onion chicken...it's a pasta dish with chicken, broccoli and mushrooms. It was delicious and the seasoning was amazing.

Food NetworkFood Network: Guy Fieri checked out this local watering hole that makes the hometown favorite sandwich called "beef and weck." Read more.

Buffalo E.Buffalo Eats: Beer Battered Fish Fry is huge with a great thick delicious crust, a must if you are there on a Friday.

Gene McCarthy's Irish Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

10. Gene McCarthy's Irish Pub

8.4
73 Hamburg St (at Republic St), Buffalo, NY
Pub · First Ward · 24 tips and reviews

tessa l.tessa lowe: Reuben is excellent. Portobello fries are the best fried mushrooms I've ever had.

Jan W.Jan Wopperer: The gravy is perfect.

Pat M.Pat Meehan: This place is legit. Great local beer selection on tap. Great wings and food specials. Trivia every Tuesday night.

Hutch's is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

11. Hutch's

8.9
1375 Delaware Ave (at Delavan Ave), Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · Delaware - West Ferry · 32 tips and reviews

Chuck H.Chuck Hoskins: Tuna sashimi is not on the menu, but ask for it. And the Swordfish steak is amazing

Matt H.Matt Hames: This is one of the best places to eat in buffalo. If you're coming here, make a reservation.

Clark D.Clark Dever: Maple Glazed Bacon.

Buffalo AKG Art Museum is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

12. Buffalo AKG Art Museum

8.8
1285 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY
Art Museum · Albright · 41 tips and reviews

Nev V.Nev Valentine-lauder Jr.: Excellent staffing and blend of knowledge & entertainment; I highly recommend if your in the area stop thru and take in some breath taking galleys. www.TrimPrinting.com

Mark D.Mark Didas: Friday evenings are free

Social YeahSocial Yeah: Amazing collection including pieces from Jackson Pollock, Andy Warhol, Pablo Picasso, Henri Matisse, & many more!

Tokyo II Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

13. Tokyo II Steakhouse

8.1
2262 Delaware Ave (at Linden Ave), Buffalo, NY
Japanese Restaurant · North Delaware · 16 tips and reviews

Brenda - B.Brenda - Buffalo on Purpose: omg shrimp n scallop hibachi and pb&j martini will b back

Cassandra L.Cassandra Lyons: Wu Tang eats here!!!

Emily B.Emily Bolles: Came in a few minutes before closing (we thought they were open later than they actually were) they still served us, we're incredibly polite and gave us soup on the house. Amazing customer service!

The Lunch Box is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

14. The Lunch Box

7.8
465 Main St (in Lafayette Court Building), Buffalo, NY
Sandwich Spot · Central Business District · 7 tips and reviews

Laura S.Laura Suttell: Hummus veggie wraps and salads (especially good balsamic dressing) are remarkable.

patricia f.patricia frey: Expensive and asks for tips for over the counter service.

patricia f.patricia frey: Inefficient setup!

Parkside Meadow is one of The 15 Best Places for Mayonnaise in Buffalo.

15. Parkside Meadow

7.7
2 Russell St (at Parkside Ave), Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · Parkside · 3 tips and reviews

Diane W.Diane Wonch: The new owners (2015) have worked miracles in an entire remodel. The bar is uniquely Buffalo with great lunches. Give it a try. Parking may be a challenge.

Kevin C.Kevin Curtin: A true neighborhood pub. I love the food the people and the owners are always there to greet you and make sure your are happy.

Hard R.Hard Rocker: A bit pricey. But staff is friendly.