La Nova Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

1. La Nova Pizzeria

8.8
371 W Ferry St (at Hampshire St), Buffalo, NY
Pizzeria · West Side · 24 tips and reviews

David R.David Rodriguez: Love the cheese pepperoni with garlic and sesame crust. Yummy

Maki S.Maki S: I got a free slice of pizza at the Sabres game. It was very tasty! They use generous amount of cheese and pepperonis are crunchy and spicy! Thank you for your generosity!

Marco N.Marco Navarra: Not my typical thin crust authentic neopalitan pizza; however, I had to visit this Bizarre Foods Delicious Destinations. I really enjoyed their beef and pork pepperoni pizza. I'd go back!

Imperial Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

2. Imperial Pizza

8.7
1035 Abbott Rd, Buffalo, NY
Pizzeria · South Abbott · 24 tips and reviews

Buffalo E.Buffalo Eats: They live up to the hype. Sweet sauce, Whole Milk Mozz, big fully crust and pepperoni with a kick. No seating though, have to order to go.

Mary Ellen K.Mary Ellen Koscielny: Extra crispy barbecue wings are excellent!

Steve P.Steve Poland: Patrick Kane brought the Stanley Cup here in 2013 when he had it for the day after winning it his 2nd time in 4 years. Kane grew up eating here after games as a kid. http://es.pn/17smTA9

Lafayette Brewing Co. is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

3. Lafayette Brewing Co.

7.1
391 Washington St (in Hotel @ The Lafayette), Buffalo, NY
Brewery · Central Business District · 21 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Poland: The sausage pepperoni pizza thin crust is up there as the best of my life. Light. Great in a time of post-dinner drinking munchy need.

Chaitanya N.Chaitanya Nettem: Try one of the brewed beer flavors along with the white pizza. Very reasonable prices

Jen B.Jen B.: Medium wings were great, BBQ weren't so good :(

Gino & Joe's Famous NY Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

4. Gino & Joe's Famous NY Pizza

7.3
400 Main St (Lower Level Main Place Mall), Buffalo, NY
Pizzeria · Central Business District · 12 tips and reviews

R H.R HF: Just really good pizza. Don't go fancy just do cheese and pepperoni or a sausage roll

Emma B.Emma Balkin: Hidden gem in the main place mall! I got the chicken and broccoli slice!

Cj S.Cj Sternisha: The Buffalo chicken is to die for! Its Fabulous!

Marco's Fine Italian Dining is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

5. Marco's Fine Italian Dining

8.2
1085 Niagara St (at Fargo Ave), Buffalo, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Side · 6 tips and reviews

phil c.phil ciallela: Get the Sicilian bread as an app!

Maggie M.Maggie Manning: Sarah is the best waitress in the place!!! Sit in her section.

Jennifer C.Jennifer Crowley: Absolutely delicious Marco is a very good chef and you really get full fast too much food

Marco's Italian Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

6. Marco's Italian Deli

8.5
1518 Hertel Ave (at Wellington Rd), Buffalo, NY
Deli · North Park · 14 tips and reviews

Joey B.Joey Bucheker: Outstanding sandwiches. Corned Beef to die for.

Ed G.Ed Glass: Best sub: Mama Mia. Best soup (when in season): Italian Wedding. Great food! Give it a try. You won't be disappointed.

Mark Z.Mark Zorn: Mama Mia. Order it. Enjoy it. Order another.

Oliver's is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

7. Oliver's

8.7
2095 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · Park Meadow · 20 tips and reviews

Adam Robert B.Adam Robert Bartha: U.S.D.A. Prime Filet Mignon • yukon gold mashed potatoes, broccoli & foie gras butter

Brandi S.Brandi S.: Lemon drop martini....Yum!

joe s.joe smith: Great to sit at the bar and have dinner

Coco Bar & Bistro is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

8. Coco Bar & Bistro

8.3
888 Main St (btwn Virginia & Allen), Buffalo, NY
French Restaurant · Allen · 12 tips and reviews

Elliott V.Elliott Vance: Get the rosemary frites

Roger C.Roger Chen: Everything..... Unpretentious French bistro.

Niagara PopcornNiagara Popcorn: The mussels are amazing!

Ristorante Lombardo is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

9. Ristorante Lombardo

8.2
1198 Hertel Ave (at Virgil Ave), Buffalo, NY
Italian Restaurant · North Park · 17 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Poland: Desserts were delicious. Tiramisu, wow. Banana cream pie thing was likely the best, but I am a chocolate fan and thus the oreo pie was a grand slam!

Mike H.Mike Hayes: Amanda might be the best waitress ever. Not a bad thing on the menu. Feel a little full after dinner but still want to try dessert? Vanilla bean gelato! Sounds plain? It's far from it!

Marco N.Marco Navarra: Everything was great! Hot Banana Peppers and Mud Pie were outstanding!

Gino's New York Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

10. Gino's New York Pizza

7.7
1009 Elmwood Ave (Potomac Ave), Buffalo, NY
Fast Food Restaurant · Albright · 5 tips and reviews

Messie J.Messie Jessie: Their pizzas and Stromboli are divine! The guys are all extremely nice and you can't beat their prices.

Jamie M.Jamie Markley: Best white pizza on westside.

Steve P.Steve Poland: I'm told it's homemade marinara and to get the garlic knots.

Osteria 166 is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

11. Osteria 166

8.2
166 Franklin St (at W Mohawk St), Buffalo, NY
Trattoria · Central Business District · 26 tips and reviews

🌞🌞Sunny🌞🌞 S.🌞🌞Sunny🌞🌞 Sunshine🌞🌞: Excellent. Chicken lasagna, pumpkin crime brûlée and a vodka espresso!! Night made!

Chris S.Chris Smith: Excellent service, good food, solid wine list, and the friendliest owner in the city. A great place for happy hour and dinner.

Rachel G.Rachel Gottlieb: If you're unhappy about anything, Nick will bend over backwards to fix it. Plus the food is great.

Wayside Family Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

12. Wayside Family Restaurant

7.8
2301 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · South Park · 22 tips and reviews

Lisa G.Lisa Gatti: Food is always great! Homemade and healthy portions! Try their specials, you won't be disappointed.

Edwina K.Edwina Kwiatkowski: Burger basket is awesome

Ray K.Ray K.: Good food and good prices!

Anchor Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

13. Anchor Bar

7.6
1047 Main St (at North St), Buffalo, NY
Wings Joint · Medical Park · 209 tips and reviews

Valerie B.Valerie B: My absolute favorite pepperoni pizza! Crunchy pepperoni filled with pools of grease

Markets of New York CityMarkets of New York City: The Buffalo wings are amazing, but the buffalo chicken sandwich is crispy, tangy and yummy too!

Gabi B.Gabi Bulumac: America's most famous and beloved culinar dishes has been born in The Anchor Bar in 1964 by Teressa Bellissimo - BUFFALO WINGS 😋

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffé is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

14. Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffé

7.5
1292 Hertel Ave (at Crestwood Ave), Buffalo, NY
Italian Restaurant · North Park · 23 tips and reviews

Rachel J.Rachel Jankowski: The stuffed red pepper is my favorite!

Buffalo E.Buffalo Eats: I'm addicted to their sweets, the Florentine's are fantastic and cheap. Good Italian food as well but the bakery is what keeps me coming back.

Libby M.Libby MacDougall: Cassata cake!

Carbone's Pizzeria is one of The 15 Best Places for Pepperoni in Buffalo.

15. Carbone's Pizzeria

7.2
1126 E Lovejoy St, Buffalo, NY
Pizzeria · Lovejoy · 3 tips and reviews

Emily R.Emily Righ: Best pizza, wings and breadstix in town!!

Jason P.Jason Pilarski: Awesome boneless wings!!!!!!

Richard F.Richard Falkowski: Good subs:-)