Gene McCarthy's Irish Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

1. Gene McCarthy's Irish Pub

8.7
73 Hamburg St (at Republic St), Buffalo, NY
Pub · First Ward · 24 tips and reviews

tessa l.tessa lowe: Reuben is excellent. Portobello fries are the best fried mushrooms I've ever had.

James G.James Gerland: The Buffalo Brat and Reuben were killer.

Steve P.Steve Poland: Microbrewery beer. Wings don't get any better. Reuben was spot on. Fries are the hand cut ones. Great patio in summer. Tuesday night trivia.

Big Ditch Brewing Company is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

2. Big Ditch Brewing Company

9.1
55 E Huron St (at Ellicott St), Buffalo, NY
Brewery · Central Business District · 31 tips and reviews

Leslie B.Leslie Bardak: Order the Breuben! It's the best Reuben in the city!

Steve P.Steve Poland: Beet salad is huge and legit— eat as meal or share with others (like 3-4). Brueben was delicious— it’s mammoth- split that.

Big Ditch Brewing CompanyBig Ditch Brewing Company: Our Restaurant and Tap room is now open.

Amy's Place is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

3. Amy's Place

8.1
3234 Main St (at Merrimac St), Buffalo, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · University · 72 tips and reviews

Kusum S.Kusum Saini: Their sicillian burger and Seiten Reuben( special today ) was so delicious !! Love to eat here ..

Zach M.Zach M: Plenty of veggie/vegan, also plenty of meat. Loved the 2-2-2, two eggs/two sausage/two pancakes (gluten free buckwheat pancakes available). Breakfast all day. Low-key diner w/cool people running shop.

CaydenCayden: Check out breakfast at Amy's between 6 and 9. $1.99 eggs, toast, and home fries!

Joe's Deli is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

4. Joe's Deli

8.3
1322 Hertel Ave (at Colvin Blvd), Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · North Park · 38 tips and reviews

Charlie F.Charlie Flash: The Reuben with slaw!

Dave S.Dave Shah: Unassuming deli with great sandwiches and soups.

Lauren R.Lauren R.: Sweet baby james. Every time.

Globe Market is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

5. Globe Market

7.4
762 Elmwood Ave (at Auburn Ave), Buffalo, NY
Sandwich Spot · West Side · 44 tips and reviews

Josh K.Josh Kruk: Cuban Reuben is the way to go

Jason W.Jason W: The Cuban Reuben is YUMMO!!!!!!

Christofer M.Christofer MacDonald: Hummus wrap Rocks! Get the garlic hummus! 😀

Towne Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

6. Towne Restaurant

7.4
186 Allen St (at Elmwood Ave), Buffalo, NY
Greek Restaurant · Allen · 42 tips and reviews

Archer M.Archer McConkle: Great Reuben

Meg R.Meg Robertson: The best Greek diner in Buffalo. It's not on the menu anymore, but order the 2-2-2... 2 eggs, 2 pieces of sausage and 2 pieces of toast with butter. Leave a good tip!

Dan C.Dan Ciesla: Chicken fingers. The best :-)

Pasión is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

7. Pasión

7.1
153 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY
Cuban Restaurant · Allen · 8 tips and reviews

Laketa C.Laketa C.: Excellent service, our server, Reuben was fantastic. Great personality, efficient and intuitive...wonderful experience overall!

Laketa C.Laketa C.: PLEASE, try the Spicy Oxtails a divine start. The tender meat is layered on 2 homeade corn tortillas with an avocado puree, cheese, arugula, and balsamic vinegrette...I was almost full off that alone!

Laketa C.Laketa C.: Hands down the BEST Margaritas I've EVER had! Nothing weak about them. Happy Hour is Tues., Thurs., and Fri. 4pm-8pm $5 Margaritas, $3 beers, $5 glasses of wine. My new spot for Spring Summer '17!!

Blackthorn Restaurant & Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

8. Blackthorn Restaurant & Pub

8.6
2134 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · South Buffalo · 25 tips and reviews

George R.George Ramon: This place is AMAZING, recently have been here 6 times for lunch and dinner. My plan is to try every item on the menu!

Food NetworkFood Network: Guy Fieri checked out this local watering hole that makes the hometown favorite sandwich called "beef and weck." Read more.

Buffalo E.Buffalo Eats: Beer Battered Fish Fry is huge with a great thick delicious crust, a must if you are there on a Friday.

Imperial Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

9. Imperial Pizza

8.7
1035 Abbott Rd, Buffalo, NY
Pizzeria · South Abbott · 24 tips and reviews

Dean R.Dean Rozler: Pizza of course. Great wings as well.

Steve P.Steve Poland: Patrick Kane brought the Stanley Cup here in 2013 when he had it for the day after winning it his 2nd time in 4 years. Kane grew up eating here after games as a kid. http://es.pn/17smTA9

Buffalo E.Buffalo Eats: They live up to the hype. Sweet sauce, Whole Milk Mozz, big fully crust and pepperoni with a kick. No seating though, have to order to go.

Lafayette Brewing Co. is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

10. Lafayette Brewing Co.

7.1
391 Washington St (in Hotel @ The Lafayette), Buffalo, NY
Brewery · Central Business District · 21 tips and reviews

Guy M.Guy Merrill: Duck Reuben was great! Home made chips too..

Matthäus F.Matthäus Friedman: Good quality food. Tasty, but a little bland at times. The white pizza is a real winner, though. The ambiance and staff are amazing, and make up for any other (minor) shortcomings.

Jen B.Jen B.: Medium wings were great, BBQ weren't so good :(

Parkside Meadow is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

11. Parkside Meadow

7.7
2 Russell St (at Parkside Ave), Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · Parkside · 3 tips and reviews

Diane W.Diane Wonch: The new owners (2015) have worked miracles in an entire remodel. The bar is uniquely Buffalo with great lunches. Give it a try. Parking may be a challenge.

Kevin C.Kevin Curtin: A true neighborhood pub. I love the food the people and the owners are always there to greet you and make sure your are happy.

Hard R.Hard Rocker: A bit pricey. But staff is friendly.

Hamlin House is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

12. Hamlin House

7.7
432 Franklin St, Buffalo, NY
Event Space · Allen · 6 tips and reviews

Brandyn I.Brandyn Isiah: Good food good hospitality !! Order a vodka cranberry they are strong and stiff !!

Mike S.Mike Szukala: Fish Fry. Voted one of Buffalo's best for a reason.

Kurt K.Kurt K: Stop in for pull tabs and beer during the art festival!

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

13. Dinosaur Bar-B-Que

8.5
301 Franklin St (btwn W Chippewa St & W Tupper St), Buffalo, NY
BBQ Joint · Central Business District · 58 tips and reviews

JoshJosh: Great BBQ and nice atmosphere. Always busy, make a reservation first.

Gabi B.Gabi Bulumac: Get a full rack Bar-B-Que pork ribs with Sam Adams ;)

Josh A.Josh Auringer: Actually the wings are awesome. As well as the brisket, pulled pork and ribs. Its how bbq is done. Good riddance to Famous Daves and Smokey Bones. There simply is no other.

The Wellington Pub is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

14. The Wellington Pub

7.7
1541 Hertel Ave (btwn Wellington & Parkside), Buffalo, NY
Sports Bar · North Park · 19 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Poland: Spitz says get pot roast Sammy (top5 dish in town for me). Get Cajun fries and hidden gem beer

Martin S.Martin Slanovich: MONSTER BURGER!

Andres Y.Andres Yarritu: Jerk wings, pot roast sandwich with provolone on garlic bread, buttermilk and bacon potato salad. Do it.

Pearl Street Grill & Brewery is one of The 15 Best Places for Reuben Sandwiches in Buffalo.

15. Pearl Street Grill & Brewery

8.5
76 Pearl St (at Seneca St), Buffalo, NY
Brewery · Central Business District · 168 tips and reviews

Theresa M.Theresa Marie: When you try the pig fingers ask for double sauce. They're stingy with it. The sauce is awesome.

Alex N.Alex Nesselbeck: Get the trainwreck!

Gabi B.Gabi Bulumac: I like this place 👍 raspberry and blueberry beer 😂 Brew Masters are really good😜Great experience !