Rusty Bucket is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Chicken Sandwich in Columbus.

1. Rusty Bucket

8.3
4062 Gramercy St (Gramercy St.), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 25 tips and reviews

Asha A.Asha Augustine: Best buffalo chicken sandwich!

Sarah C.Sarah CJ: Great gluten free menu, tried the pasta. Excellent choice. Staff is great!

Kennel R.Kennel Ruth: The Asian Tuna Wrap is a great light lunch alternative or brunch go-to. Instead of fries, do the Double Nickel salad as your side and pair it with the Hangtime Pinot Noir.

Rusty Bucket is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Chicken Sandwich in Columbus.

2. Rusty Bucket

7.7
7800 Olentangy River Rd, Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Jenny Z.Jenny Zavatsky: Blackened salmon salad, pizza, buffalo chicken sandwich, fried pickles and nickel salad

Aaron H.Aaron Hawes: Double Nickel salad if you can handle the onions. A few hidden gems like the Asian Tuna wrap if you like sushi

TommyTommy: Awesome place. Bryce is a great bartender, knows the ropes. Ask for old-school Nachos, you won't be disappointed.

DiBella's Old Fashioned Subs is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Chicken Sandwich in Columbus.

3. DiBella's Old Fashioned Subs

7.9
1539 Olentangy River Rd (King and Olentangy River Rd), Columbus, OH
Sandwich Spot · 16 tips and reviews

Katie J.Katie Jaspers: Get the Buffalo Chicken sub with bleu cheese dressing. You won't regret it.

Alex M.Alex Martin: Best sub shop in the area. Must eat here!

Amy J.Amy Jones: Try the everything bread. Way better than Jimmy John's.

Tommy's Diner is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Chicken Sandwich in Columbus.

4. Tommy's Diner

9.0
914 W Broad St, Columbus, OH
Diner · 33 tips and reviews

Hershil Jr. D.Hershil Jr. Daniels: Great place to eat, best breakfast in Columbus, Can’t go wrong.

Matt S.Matt Shetler: Gyro & Feta Omelet. Excellent.

PatriciaPatricia: Chicken gyro, sweet potato fries with honey mustard dipping sauce, cinnamon applesauce!

Red Door Tavern is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Chicken Sandwich in Columbus.

5. Red Door Tavern

8.1
1736 W 5th Ave (at Westwood), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Kayla D.Kayla Dillahunt: Try the nachos with chicken, so good. They make their own tortilla chips.

Josh B.Josh Boles: Mondays are $5 burgers. I suggest the Arlington: bacon, BBQ sauce, and shredded cheese.

Kelly S.Kelly Sells: The tater tots are amazing. And anything on a pretzel bun!

The Pizza House is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Chicken Sandwich in Columbus.

6. The Pizza House

8.5
747 E Lincoln Ave (Sinclair Rd), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 30 tips and reviews

Elizabeth H.Elizabeth Hill (Blinn): The pizza is amazing but I got the baked cheese ravioli and it was so yummy and a good price!

Joshua J.Joshua Johnson: Pretty good pizza. So long as you don't want a refill and like seeing your waitress every 30 min.

Yolanda C.Yolanda Cawthorne: Pizza and Beer.

Hang Over Easy is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Chicken Sandwich in Columbus.

7. Hang Over Easy

8.7
1646 Neil Ave (between 10th and 11th), Columbus, OH
Breakfast Spot · 39 tips and reviews

Chip B.Chip Bradford: Bloody Mary was best ever. Balanced and could taste the individual ingredients. Ordered an omelet that was perfectly cooked. Great dining experience!!

Pablo D.Pablo DePacas: They have an actual working phone booth outside to the right!

Kevin M.Kevin Murray: Everything is good. The #3 is sweet.

Massey's Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Chicken Sandwich in Columbus.

8. Massey's Pizza

7.4
2970 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 2 tips and reviews

David J.David Jennings: Simple good thin crust pizza. Great westside delivery area.

ᴡ W.ᴡ Wampler: if you like deep dish pizza the Godfather is great!

Gresso's Restaurant & Bar is one of The 9 Best Places for Buffalo Chicken Sandwich in Columbus.

9. Gresso's Restaurant & Bar

7.6
961 S High St, Columbus, OH
Pub · 29 tips and reviews

jireselljiresell: Had a very good hamburger here and they have a decent tap beer selection. It can get pretty crowded with softball teams from Berliner Park.

Courtney B.Courtney Briscoe: They will charge you for using your credit card!! Be careful!

Martin P.Martin Poston: Bring your dog(s) for Pups on the Patio on Tuesday, but you can bring them anytime. Awesome dog-friendly business! Read more.