York Steak House is one of The 7 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Columbus.

1. York Steak House

7.8
4220 W Broad St (Phillipi Rd), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 14 tips and reviews

Joseph F.Joseph Ferraro: Sirloin tips and chocolate peanut butter pie

Reba S.Reba Snodgrass: York Steak House has a nice homey feel and the waiting staff is amazing! They always decorate for the holidays and bake cookies. This place has true character.

Jim K.Jim Koontz: this place is great, Christian Family owned. great food. God Bless :-)

Krema Nut Company is one of The 7 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Columbus.

2. Krema Nut Company

8.5
1000 Goodale Blvd, Columbus, OH
Food and Beverage Retail · 13 tips and reviews

Brent S.Brent Small: Try the Nutty Mallow with banana. $5 for the best peanut butter sandwich of your life!

Robbie B.Robbie Brickner: get a bag of Buckeye Crunch!!

NathanNathan: Best peanut butter ever! Try the butter toffee peanuts!

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 7 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Columbus.

3. The Cheesecake Factory

8.5
1566 Polaris Pkwy # 124 (at Polaris Mall), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 63 tips and reviews

Nely R.Nely Reyes: The Mai Tai drink, absolutely perfect! :D

Meghann C.Meghann Cleary: Best Happy Hour in the Area!

Sara C.Sara Cleary: Erica is a pretty sweet bartender!

Bob Evans Restaurant is one of The 7 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Columbus.

4. Bob Evans Restaurant

7.3
5970 E Main St (at McNaughten Rd), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 5 tips and reviews

Dave S.Dave Sav: Service was great! Food was surprisingly excellent. My first time at Bob Evans!

Joseph F.Joseph F: This one is slow and I do mean slow.

Alex G.Alex Gonzalez: Try the Curbside Carry Out. Order on-line at BobEvans.com, drive to Bob Evans, call them on your cell phone and they'll bring your order out to you!

Bob Evans Restaurant is one of The 7 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Columbus.

5. Bob Evans Restaurant

6.9
5205 New Albany Rd (State Route 161), New Albany, OH
American Restaurant · 7 tips and reviews

Michelle G.Michelle G: Their sausage gravy is amazing!

Ken H.Ken Holcomb: Friendly waiters and consistent quality.

Sc😜tSc😜t: Awesome Wild Maine Blueberry Preserves

The Cheesecake Factory is one of The 7 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Columbus.

6. The Cheesecake Factory

8.4
3975 Townsfair Way Easton Town Center (Easton Town Center), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 92 tips and reviews

Adriana R.Adriana R: The bang bang chicken and shrimp is by far one of the most tastiest dish I’ve tried. The mango key lime cheesecake is my absolute favorite!

Jason M.Jason McLaughlin: Don't care about calories or the size of your ass? Welcome to The Cheesecake Factory!

Corey H.Corey Holliday: Amazing food, great location. If you're eating here be sure to ask for Ashley, she's very nice and a great server

Bob Evans is one of The 7 Best Places for Chocolate Peanut Butter in Columbus.

7. Bob Evans

6.8
1455 Olentangy River Rd (King Ave), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 22 tips and reviews

Glenn B.Glenn Barker: Great breakfast any time of day!

Glenn B.Glenn Barker: Awesome breakfast!

Luke T.Luke Toney: According to the GM and a vegetarian waitress, the country gravy is vegetarian. Just have them leave out the sausage. Sweet.