Third & Hollywood is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Mashed Potatoes in Columbus.

1. Third & Hollywood

8.5
1433 W 3rd Ave (Hollywood), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 46 tips and reviews

KathrineKathrine: The cheeseburger and french fries are a must! Would also recommend the cheddar herb biscuits and the croque madam.

Mark S.Mark S.: Biscuits. Get biscuits.

Bill L.Bill Litfin: Saltiest food in town. Even the steamed broccoli is salty.

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Mashed Potatoes in Columbus.

2. Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

8.1
1313 Hilliard Rome Rd I-70 & Hilliard-Rome Rd., Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 24 tips and reviews

Kam K.Kam King: Ask to have your hashbrown casserole well-done!

Matthew S.Matthew Sprankle: Never thought I'd recommend ribs from a Cracker Barrel. They were delicious

Chris R.Chris Rea: Country fried steak

Logan's Roadhouse is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Mashed Potatoes in Columbus.

3. Logan's Roadhouse

3969 Morse Crossing, Columbus, OH
Steakhouse · 17 tips and reviews

Cassandra D.Cassandra Daniels: Ask for the chilli cheese fries...not on the menu..but fantastic!

Michael D.Michael Donahoe: great place to eat

Cassandra D.Cassandra Daniels: Megan was our server. Very attentive.

Fridays is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Mashed Potatoes in Columbus.

4. Fridays

1330 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 21 tips and reviews

Steve F.Steve Foy: No WiFi (yet), but Terri the bartender was warm and welcoming! Food is always good at Fridays! Parmesan Flounder is great! Get a side salad and you have a nice healthy meal!

Le Ron C.Le Ron Carlton: Sizzling Chicken and Cheese are to die for. Swap the Mashed Potatoes for Broc and ask for less cheese and get a healthier, filling dish.

mister trillis s.mister trillis sixonefour: Nice place to eat long as yu got the right server

Gresso's Restaurant & Bar is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Mashed Potatoes in Columbus.

5. Gresso's Restaurant & Bar

7.3
961 S High St, Columbus, OH
Pub · 29 tips and reviews

J H.J Hamlin: They actually MAKE their own feta cheese in house- try it in the spicy feta dip! Also, only bar in Cols to serve pieroghi's. Mmmm yum!

Courtney B.Courtney Briscoe: They will charge you for using your credit card!! Be careful!

Martin P.Martin Poston: Bring your dog(s) for Pups on the Patio on Tuesday, but you can bring them anytime. Awesome dog-friendly business! Read more.

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Mashed Potatoes in Columbus.

6. Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

7.5
1860 Winderly Ln. I-70 & SR 256, Pickerington, OH
American Restaurant · 25 tips and reviews

Tamika J.Tamika Jones: The grilled and breaded catfish are great!

Sherri R.Sherri Rasmussen: Friday Fish Fry! The cod is awesome!

Chris M.Chris M: Sunday fried chicken is worth braving the after church crowd for!

Red Lobster is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Mashed Potatoes in Columbus.

7. Red Lobster

7.8
1520 Georgesville Rd (Holt Rd), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 21 tips and reviews

Tammy H.Tammy Howard: Excellent food, we ordered the Admiral's Feast, Lg. Lobster tail, Stuffed Lobster, Crab & Seafood Mushrooms and Crab Linguine Alfredo. Everything was fantastic! Ask for waitress Cynthia Z!

Craig G.Craig Gibson: Cheddar bay biscuits make any meal.

HeatherHeather: Shrimp tacos!! Everything's delicious here but shrimp tacos!!