Panera Bread is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in Columbus.

1. Panera Bread

8.6
685 W Waterloo St (Waterloo), Canal Winchester, OH
Bakery · 1 tip

HeatherHeather: Turkey and avocado sandwich with kettle cooked potato chips yum !

BRAVO! Cucina Italiana is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in Columbus.

2. BRAVO! Cucina Italiana

8.6
3000 Hayden Rd (Bethel Rd.), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 14 tips and reviews

Chelsea S.Chelsea Stamp: Crispy shrimp Napoli. Chicken chop salad. Beef ravioli. Chicken scallopini. Chicken bacon spin. flatbread. Lobster ravioli. Filet Toscano with Gorgonzola. Sketchbook Cab and Pinot noir. Happy eating!

None N.None None: The Italian wedding soup tastes like the bride came in it.

joy c.joy chambers: Bread pudding

Panera Bread is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in Columbus.

3. Panera Bread

7.6
611 E Livingston Ave, Ste A, Columbus, OH
Bakery · No tips or reviews
Moretti's is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in Columbus.

4. Moretti's

7.8
5849 Sawmill Rd, Dublin, OH
Italian Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

Mark S.Mark Sampras: Best Italian place so far in Ohio at Columbus area. Big portions a@s big flavors. And big plates

Mark B.Mark Bodnar: I recommend anything. It is impossible to go wrong. Moretti's may have the second best alfredo I've ever tasted (mom is first...always).

Steve P.Steve Petrosino: This is one of the 2 best Italian restaurants we have experienced. Ever. And that includes 4 trips to Italy! Tommy Moretti is a culinary master!

The Old Mohawk is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in Columbus.

5. The Old Mohawk

8.3
819 Mohawk St (at Kossouth St.), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 42 tips and reviews

Francie G.Francie Griffith: Reuben is good and they have really great wedge salads!

Chris S.Chris Skovron: In the winter, the vestibule is the warmest place in Cbus.

Shannon B.Shannon Beeson: Great, old school neighborhood bar. Food is great and excellent service!

Barcelona Restaurant & Bar is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in Columbus.

6. Barcelona Restaurant & Bar

8.3
263 E Whittier St (Jaeger), Columbus, OH
Tapas Restaurant · 50 tips and reviews

Gabe T.Gabe Tippery: Russell is the server to have! Hard working and detail oriented… spot on!

nicole k.nicole kimber: The chef cook off was fantastic!!! Highly suggested!

Columbus Food AdventuresColumbus Food Adventures: Home of the best mojitos in Columbus.

Curry & Hurry is one of The 7 Best Places for Creamy Tomato in Columbus.

7. Curry & Hurry

7.4
2412 N High St (at Blake Ave), Columbus, OH
Indian Restaurant · 3 tips and reviews

Lauren F.Lauren Fiorucci: Lamb Dansak. Actually, anything lamb is amazing.

Eric J.Eric J: Vegetable samosa to die for!

Christopher F.Christopher F: Get the Chicken Korma at lunch. You won't regret it!