Adriatico's is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

1. Adriatico's

8.8
265 W 11th Ave (Neil Ave), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 22 tips and reviews

Hope M.Hope McGonigle: get the breadsticks with the garlic butter

Amanda D.Amanda Downey: Deep dish. Huge pepperoni. Hole-in-the-wall feel. Best pizza in town!

Aaron C.Aaron C: Best pizza from here to Cleveland. Likely the best pizza in Ohio.

Hounddog's Three Degree Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

2. Hounddog's Three Degree Pizza

8.6
2657 N High St (at W Dodridge St.), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 120 tips and reviews

Brett p.Brett payne: mozzarella has a smoky flavor and the sauce is very rich. smokin joes garlic butter crust is the only type to get. It's a campus institution because the food is fudgin killer.

James D.James Dague: We loved the smokin Joe's crust. Made our own meat lovers with the sausage, bacon, & cajun hotlinks. Crispy crust bottom with garlic butter on outer crust. Wish we lived closer!

ProngsProngs: Great pizza, great ambience. Great list of drinks too

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

3. Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse

8.9
1615 Old Henderson Rd (Larwell Dr), Columbus, OH
Steakhouse · 5 tips and reviews

Danny S.Danny Sauter: everything is great, but my favorite is the steak rahal. also, make sure you consume insane amounts of pretzel bread.

Justin M.Justin Meats: Come before 6pm and get a salad, side and entree for $19.90

Deb C.Deb Clark: Lobster Mac & Cheese! Yummy!

Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

4. Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse

8.7
89 E Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH
Steakhouse · 5 tips and reviews

Henry U.Henry Unger: Amazing sushi and sashimi, seafood, and steaks! Great service and great decor. Loved it!

Sew D.Sew Dee: Impecable service. Dry aged steak was phenomenal, Almost as good as Quality Meats NYC. Mushrooms were out of this world.

Adam M.Adam Mason: Steak. Fries. The bar. What more do you need?

Figlio is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

5. Figlio

8.9
1369 Grandview Ave (3rd), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 16 tips and reviews

Courtney L.Courtney Lewis: Figlio Manhattan is delicious! You cannot go wrong with any of the pastas, pizzas, salads.

Katie R.Katie Robinson: Service was very slow and the food was ok buy not worth the wait. Fun atmosphere though!

Courtney L.Courtney Lewis: So many favorites here! Field green salad with vinaigrette & crumbled blue cheese. Chicken Piccata! Spicy Tomato Blackened Chicken. Chicken & Mushroom Ravioli! Chicken & Avocado Pizza. Chicken Diablo

Granddad's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

6. Granddad's Pizza

8.3
4093 Trueman Blvd (Cemetery Road & Truemsn Blvd), Hilliard, OH
Pizzeria · 5 tips and reviews

Ken H.Ken Holcomb: Generous House salad and good Sub.

Mike F.Mike Fleer: Pizza and wings are excellent

Scott F.Scott Fuhrmann: Generous toppings on a nice thin crust pizza. Slow night, but attentive service. Will return.

Massey's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

7. Massey's Pizza

7.7
261 Lincoln Cir (Granville St.), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 2 tips and reviews

Jason K.Jason Kusner: good pizza buffet during lunch and its a good price

Patrick P.Patrick Priest: Pizza buffet during lunch - cheap and not as good as one remembers when they were a kid. Read more.

The Top Steakhouse is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

8. The Top Steakhouse

9.2
2891 E Main St (at S. Chesterfield Rd.), Columbus, OH
Steakhouse · 24 tips and reviews

Jody W.Jody Wasbro: Good cocktails, shrimp cocktails and the salmon is delicious. Fun place to celebrate or just because.

NickNick: Try the steak!

Jackson F.Jackson Fraley: Best Steak House in Columbus.. and for a fantastic "bar" burger?..You cannot beat The Top

Tony's Italian Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

9. Tony's Italian Ristorante

7.2
16 W Beck St (High St), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews

Wednesday Q.Wednesday Quansah: Roman bread, side salad, the warm Italian bread with garlic butter are changed my life for the better. Limoncello martini was too saccharine.

Brian A.Brian Ashworth: The Tonys garlic bread appetizer was well worth it. Finished off with an entree of veal.

Tiffany H.Tiffany Hagerdorn: Bartender is absolutely terrible! No personality and acts like he's way to busy to talk to his guests!

Massey's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

10. Massey's Pizza

7.9
4464 E Main St, Whitehall, OH
Pizzeria · 3 tips and reviews

Molly C.Molly Cruz: The pizza here is the best in Columbus. Don't forget to get an order of cheese bread it's yummy!!!

Richard F.Richard Folk: This is the original location opened in 1949.

Jake S.Jake Steinberg: Do the dew!

Rotolo's Pizza is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

11. Rotolo's Pizza

7.9
2163 W Dublin Granville Rd, Worthington, OH
Pizzeria · 7 tips and reviews

Eric C.Eric Chivington: Great pizza. Soon to gave dine in service too.

Jessica T.Jessica Tarleton: Best local pizza around

Christy N.Christy N: The mini pasta dishes are the perfect size'

Confluence Park is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

12. Confluence Park

7.9
679 W Long St (SR 33), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · Downtown Columbus · 7 tips and reviews

Christopher T.Christopher Taylor: Great happy hour with live music, incredible bar food menu and very cheap drinks. A must-go mon-fri!

Charla W.Charla W: Best view of the city. Hands down.

Robin C.Robin Cassady: Great place for photographers!! The trails will lead you to wonders, take them!!

The Mad Greek is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

13. The Mad Greek

8.3
4210 E Broad St (btwn Beechwood & Pinewood Dr), Columbus, OH
Greek Restaurant · 25 tips and reviews

Deborah W.Deborah White: Love the Falafel! Great authentic Greek food. Nice atmosphere and friendly people. Feta chesse is wonderful on the salads.

Samuel C.Samuel Camacho: This place is a gem!! Gyro meat is delicious and plentiful in both sandwich and platter forms. It's lentil soup is bold and rich with flavor. Don't forget to try one of several desserts made in house

Tom O.Tom Ohmer: Having a gyro, but waited a while for a server. No, this place is not busy now.

Rusty Bucket is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

14. Rusty Bucket

8.0
7800 Olentangy River Rd, Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Justin F.Justin Flowers: Good food. Double nickle salad is spot on for 55's.

Aaron H.Aaron Hawes: Double Nickel salad if you can handle the onions. A few hidden gems like the Asian Tuna wrap if you like sushi

TommyTommy: Awesome place. Bryce is a great bartender, knows the ropes. Ask for old-school Nachos, you won't be disappointed.

The Rossi Kitchen & Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Garlic Butter in Columbus.

15. The Rossi Kitchen & Bar

8.8
895 N High St (Price Ave), Columbus, OH
Wine Bar · 52 tips and reviews

Deborah C.Deborah Contizano: My favorite short north spot! Best pizza, fries and grilled romaine salad all in one place!

Donald v.Donald van Atta: Great ambience, delicious food, nice wine list.

Robert T.Robert Trautman: Great place to get a delicious pizza and bottle of wine!