Scali Ristorante is one of The 9 Best Places for Manicotti in Columbus.

1. Scali Ristorante

8.7
1903 State Route 256, Reynoldsburg, OH
Italian Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

Ellen O.Ellen O'Dell (RealtorGal71): Love this place. Food was excellent and service was exceptional. Had the Manicotti and Artichoke Salad. Delicious!

Tom H.Tom Higgins: Can't miss with anything here. Lasagne is terrific, order early because they sometimes run out.

Tracy H.Tracy Heitmeyer: Chicken Marsala is to die for! Wonderful desserts- try the cheesecake w fresh berries.

Carfagna's Market is one of The 9 Best Places for Manicotti in Columbus.

2. Carfagna's Market

1405 E Dublin Granville Rd, Columbus, OH
Grocery Store · 26 tips and reviews

Wes R.Wes Roller: Bahama mama's are the best! Great for any gathering.

Fallyne J.Fallyne Johnson: The meat and homemade pasta sauces are amazing, but so is the staff!! The people who work here make the experience complete!

Nico F.Nico Franano: Have them cut down a tenderloin into filets and freezer pack them to grill all summer long.

Moretti's is one of The 9 Best Places for Manicotti in Columbus.

3. Moretti's

7.8
5849 Sawmill Rd, Dublin, OH
Italian Restaurant · 16 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Petrosino: This is one of the 2 best Italian restaurants we have experienced. Ever. And that includes 4 trips to Italy! Tommy Moretti is a culinary master!

Mark B.Mark Bodnar: I recommend anything. It is impossible to go wrong. Moretti's may have the second best alfredo I've ever tasted (mom is first...always).

Allen V.Allen Vogliano: This is by far the best Italian food I have ever had! Sorry Grandma...

Tommy's Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Manicotti in Columbus.

4. Tommy's Pizza

8.1
174 W Lane Ave (Neil Ave), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 15 tips and reviews

Britny S.Britny Sanders: Delicious cheesy campus pizza. Not that cheap, but nice place on campus to sit in with friends.

RC C.RC Cohen: Pizza and subs are fantastic.

Todd L.Todd Lucas: Subs are best in town

Villa Nova Ristorante is one of The 9 Best Places for Manicotti in Columbus.

5. Villa Nova Ristorante

8.3
5545 N High St (btw W Lincoln Ave & W Staton Ave), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 35 tips and reviews

Dale L.Dale Litt: amazing food! Try ordering a small pizza as an appetizer!

Leslie®Leslie®: Cozy and love the Clocks!

Claire C.Claire Chen: Wedding soup and bread sticks everytime!

Caffe DaVinci is one of The 9 Best Places for Manicotti in Columbus.

6. Caffe DaVinci

7.8
3080 Tremont Rd (Zollinger Rd), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Shelly H.Shelly Hall: Egg plant Parm rocks!!!

Jen T.Jen T.: Try the Donatella gelato--caramel, hazelnut, and chocolate. Amazing!

Beth W.Beth Wroe: The house salad is the best

Tommy's Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Manicotti in Columbus.

7. Tommy's Pizza

8.0
1350 W Lane Ave (North Star Rd.), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 29 tips and reviews

Courtney C.Courtney Campbell: Their ranch dressing is good with everything. Get extra sides to enjoy after the pizza is gone. Veggie basket is a must have too!

Cartucho C.Cartucho Clark: Don't forget to ask for the old oven. Pepperoni in the old oven is the best pie in columbus.

Mike S.Mike Singleton: They have two different ovens, a new electric one and an old-style brick one. You can ask them to make your pizza in the old oven if you prefer it a little crispier. Read more.

Panzera's Pizza is one of The 9 Best Places for Manicotti in Columbus.

8. Panzera's Pizza

7.3
1354 Grandview Ave (at 3rd Ave.), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 6 tips and reviews

William F.William Forest: We drive 100 miles each way to eat a panzera pizza! Best pizza ever!

jireselljiresell: Pizza is pretty good especially if you live in the Grandview area of Columbus and can get it home quick.

Niqui C.Niqui Chatfield: Great pizza !!

Carfagna's Kitchen is one of The 9 Best Places for Manicotti in Columbus.

9. Carfagna's Kitchen

2025 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews

jireselljiresell: Great salads. And try the house dressing!

Michael Ann E.Michael Ann Effron: Ravioli with Meat is awesome!!!

Sampson S.Sampson Smith: The punch is good