Cap City Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

1. Cap City Diner

8.7
1299 Olentangy River Rd (at Fifth Ave), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 78 tips and reviews

Johnny L.Johnny LaBelle: gotta try the meat loaf! delicious!

Gina M.Gina McDougal: The meatloaf is to die for and they have the best pretzels I've ever tasted!

Kip L.Kip Lawrence: Best meatloaf in Columbus,Ohio.

Cap City Fine Diner is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

2. Cap City Fine Diner

8.5
1301 Stoneridge Dr (Morse Rd), Columbus, OH
Diner · 49 tips and reviews

ChrisChris: Meatloaf is a must!

McCheese A.McCheese Amer: Pretty sure everything's good. Meatloaf, Reuben, and key lime pie are a few favorites.

Erica M.Erica Martin: Meatloaf sandwich mmmmm

Schmidt's Restaurant und Sausage Haus is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

3. Schmidt's Restaurant und Sausage Haus

9.1
240 E Kossuth St (at Purdy Alley), Columbus, OH
German Restaurant · 160 tips and reviews

JohnJohn: The German meatloaf is amazing!

Bob M.Bob Merry: It was great the meatloaf is awesome.

Randy F.Randy Franson: Meatloaf and all sausages with kraut and horseradish of coarse

Club 185 is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

4. Club 185

8.6
185 E Livingston Ave (at Mohawk St.), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 40 tips and reviews

Cbus L.Cbus Law: Meatloaf sandwich is a must have.

jireselljiresell: Nice spot! Had the meatloaf sandwich which was outstanding! The chili was spicy and very good! Great device too!

Megan M.Megan McGlinchey: Meatloaf sandwich and mac n cheese

Hickory House is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

5. Hickory House

8.1
550 Officenter Pl (Corner of Taylor and Morrison), Gahanna, OH
Bar · 24 tips and reviews

Shirelle P.Shirelle Peterson: BBQ glazed meatloaf with straw onions on top of creamy garlic mashed potatoes, delicious, enough for 2.

sara mae p.sara mae pickle: me- "u think we'll have room for peach pie?" the hubs (while eating ribs)- "I don't have room for ribs" 😳😛 we loved it. had a small hometown feel to it. next time we'll have to save room for desert!

Lea S.Lea Smith: Onion straws were great. I really liked the rib dinner and salad. My husband had crab cakes and he said they were mostly filling and will not get them again. We will definitely go back.

Ted's Montana Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

6. Ted's Montana Grill

8.0
191 West Nationwide Blvd (at West St), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 40 tips and reviews

Aaron R.Aaron R: The bison meatloaf is easy my favorite if that's not ur thing get any bison burger

Michael L.Michael Laverdière: Bison Meatloaf. It's just like home cookin'

John K.John Kidde: Old school feel restaurant w/ wood, counter tops, straw dispenser and a delicious juicy bacon blue burger as well. Super friendly staff in a relaxing atmosphere.

Melt Bar and Grilled is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

7. Melt Bar and Grilled

8.3
4206 Worth Ave, Columbus, OH
Comfort Food Restaurant · Easton · 22 tips and reviews

T-town T.T-town Tom: Hangover fries are a great starter. The homemade meatloaf version was great, with a side of general tso brussel sprouts.

HeatherHeather: Buffalo Chicken half sandwich and chips 👍😋

Gleb J.Gleb Jenson: There is not a sandwich on their menu that is anything less than phenomenal

Northstar Cafe is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

8. Northstar Cafe

8.9
951 N High St (at 2nd Ave), Columbus, OH
Café · Short North · 153 tips and reviews

Nick K.Nick Krafft: Mostly everything is Organic. Food is great. Must try the cheese dip app and for dinner the meatloaf sandwich made with local free range pork. Organic beer choices!!! This place is a must try!

Heather K.Heather Kyle: Basil burrito was so awesome tonight. And the chop salad!

MichelleMichelle: Northstar Burger is a must-have. Even for meat eaters!

Firebirds Wood Fired Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

9. Firebirds Wood Fired Grill

8.2
8760 Sancus Blvd, Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 19 tips and reviews

Brian K.Brian Klein: Meatloaf is so tender and tasty, also I had the burger it was spicy but not to hot, served with onion strings with garlic ranch drizzle... I got key lime wife had cheesecake really good

Anita P.Anita Pryor: This place just opened June 2014. It's really nice! Warm, romantic setting with amazing food!!

Vasanth R.Vasanth Rk: Each food has different & awesome taste! I love it😋

Press Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

10. Press Grill

8.2
741 N High St (btwn Warren St. & Bollinger Pl.), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 76 tips and reviews

Don T.Don Traxler: Luv the tasty meatloaf dinner!

Peter J.Peter Jackson: “Double Press Burger” is as good as advertised, thumbs up!

Amy L.Amy Landino: Get their pizza. Probably the best pizza I've ever had.

Tony's Italian Ristorante is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

11. Tony's Italian Ristorante

7.2
16 W Beck St (High St), Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 13 tips and reviews

Derek D.Derek DeHart: The meatloaf marsala is excellent. I've never seen anything quite like it on other Italian restaurant menus.

Megan L.Megan Lotz: A cozy hideaway in the Brewery District! This place is perfect for romantic dinners or if you're in the mood for some good quality Italian food. Love their lasagne😀

Tiffany H.Tiffany Hagerdorn: Bartender is absolutely terrible! No personality and acts like he's way to busy to talk to his guests!

Red Door Tavern is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

12. Red Door Tavern

8.1
1736 W 5th Ave (at Westwood), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 15 tips and reviews

Kayla D.Kayla Dillahunt: Try the nachos with chicken, so good. They make their own tortilla chips.

Josh B.Josh Boles: Mondays are $5 burgers. I suggest the Arlington: bacon, BBQ sauce, and shredded cheese.

Kelly S.Kelly Sells: The tater tots are amazing. And anything on a pretzel bun!

The Old Mohawk is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

13. The Old Mohawk

8.0
819 Mohawk St (at Kossouth St.), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 42 tips and reviews

Maxwell P.Maxwell Posival: Awesome! One of the best Bacon Cheeseburgers I have ever had

Chris S.Chris Skovron: In the winter, the vestibule is the warmest place in Cbus.

Francie G.Francie Griffith: Reuben is good and they have really great wedge salads!

The Guild House is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

14. The Guild House

8.4
624 N High St, Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 23 tips and reviews

Niki B.Niki B: I loved the decor of this restaurant. They blended trendy colors with classic and farmhouse furniture. My favorite dishes of the night were the tuna ribbons, brussels sprouts, and the smoked trout.

Katie B.Katie Brownfield: Brussels sprouts were amazing.

Jen M.Jen Marquez Ginn: Duck pate was awesome. Smoked trout was great. Loved the pork. Nice atmosphere. Dance music playing, which was an interesting choice. Good beer & cocktail selection.

The Hickory House is one of The 15 Best Places for Meatloaf in Columbus.

15. The Hickory House

8.2
7051 E Main St (Rosehill Road), Reynoldsburg, OH
BBQ Joint · 12 tips and reviews

Hunter Y.Hunter Young: Filet and Ribs. All-time best.

Tony B.Tony Burkhart: The ribs and burgers are amazing!

Samantha H.Samantha Herbert: The ribs and the grilled shrimp are absolutely wonderful