1. Northstar Cafe
9.0
4015 Townsfair Way (at Felon St), Columbus, OH
New American Restaurant · Easton · 137 tips and reviews
Erik Griffin: GET the mushroom breakfast thing so good.
Imani Willis: If you're looking for light pancakes, get the Cloud 9 pancakes they are amazing. The mushroom frittata is great as well as their fish sandwich. You really can't go wrong at this place.
Cindy Santiago: I have a Mushroom frittata was awsome, and natural juces are the best!! Good choices for vegan people!!☆☆☆☆
5. Dewey's Pizza
8.4
1327 W 5th Ave, Grandview Heights, OH
Pizzeria · 43 tips and reviews
Maranda Coehins-Noble: I had a green lantern minus mushrooms plus pepperoni and I swear it's the best pizza I ever ate. Mm mm mm!!!!
Stephanie Livingston: Great selection. Always helpful staff. Favorite pizza place because of the vegetarian options. Billy Goat, wild mushroom and green lantern are my favorites. Pesto is to die for.
John Hall: The X-Pepperoni is the best. They have the best pizza sauce.
6. Red Lobster
7.5
1520 Georgesville Rd (Holt Rd), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 21 tips and reviews
Rebecca Porter: Clams, Stuffed Mushrooms & Scallops...
Tammy Howard: Excellent food, we ordered the Admiral's Feast, Lg. Lobster tail, Stuffed Lobster, Crab & Seafood Mushrooms and Crab Linguine Alfredo. Everything was fantastic! Ask for waitress Cynthia Z!
Heather: Yummy Appetizer.. Seafood stuffed mushrooms 👍🍤🍄
Wanda S: Mussels have great light, spicy, creamy tomoato-red pepper sauce. Wild mushroom & goat cheese pizza very good w/Reisling. Staff polite and did not hover, waiter had perfect timing allowing me a leis
Jenn M: Get the mushroom ravioli
Sherri Kingrea: Salmon, mushroom pizza, & chicken parm. So good!
Elizabeth Hill (Blinn): Mushroom Pizza
Andrew Todd-Smith: Portabella fries with banana ketchup were great, as was Spicy Yuma with buttermilk ranch to dip. Ask about their house and seasonal draft selections, some nice surprises could be in store.
jiresell: The pizza is great here, but try one of the burgers, they are outstanding!
9. Tony's Coneys
8.9
5266 W Broad St (Buena Vista Ave), Columbus, OH
Hot Dog Joint · 13 tips and reviews
Chris Robinson: Been eating at tonys for 30 years, its the best! Fried mushrooms, awesome slaw dogs, and ice cream galore. Its a must for anyone in the area!
Jacqualine Champion: Try the black cherry ice cream shake! This place rocks.
Denise Williams: I loved the zucchini sticks
12. JT's Pizza & Pub
8.2
2390 W Dublin Granville Rd (at Linworth Rd & RT161 W Dublin Granville Rd), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 25 tips and reviews
JT's Pizza & Pub: Dec POM: Philly Pizza - Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, Pizza Cheese, Philly Cheesesteak, and Mayo.
Joe Hartnett: POM - Ultimate Meat Lovers Pizza: Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Bacon, Salami, and Chorizo Sausage. Don't forget to try our new Strawberry Swirl Cheesecake or dessert!!
Deb B.: Colleen is best bartender in town!!
13. Figlio
8.9
1369 Grandview Ave (3rd), Columbus, OH
Pizzeria · 16 tips and reviews
Courtney Lewis: So many favorites here! Field green salad with vinaigrette & crumbled blue cheese. Chicken Piccata! Spicy Tomato Blackened Chicken. Chicken & Mushroom Ravioli! Chicken & Avocado Pizza. Chicken Diablo
Katie Robinson: Service was very slow and the food was ok buy not worth the wait. Fun atmosphere though!
Courtney Lewis: Figlio Manhattan is delicious! You cannot go wrong with any of the pastas, pizzas, salads.