ZenCha Tea Salon is one of The 9 Best Places for New York Cheesecake in Columbus.

1. ZenCha Tea Salon

8.1
2396 E Main St, Bexley, OH
Tea Room · 12 tips and reviews

Mikayla Z.Mikayla Zielke: The mango mate is delicious! So is the grilled salmon salad. So fresh!

Marcie S.Marcie Smith: Tried mint, cinnamon tea and Passion fruit bubble tea here!

Marcie S.Marcie Smith: Best Restaurant, terrible crowded parking but food is A1!

Scali Ristorante is one of The 9 Best Places for New York Cheesecake in Columbus.

2. Scali Ristorante

8.6
1903 State Route 256, Reynoldsburg, OH
Italian Restaurant · 17 tips and reviews

Ellen O.Ellen O'Dell (RealtorGal71): Love this place. Food was excellent and service was exceptional. Had the Manicotti and Artichoke Salad. Delicious!

Tom H.Tom Higgins: Can't miss with anything here. Lasagne is terrific, order early because they sometimes run out.

Tracy H.Tracy Heitmeyer: Chicken Marsala is to die for! Wonderful desserts- try the cheesecake w fresh berries.

Buckeye Bourbon House is one of The 9 Best Places for New York Cheesecake in Columbus.

3. Buckeye Bourbon House

7.8
36 E Gay St (Pearl St), Columbus, OH
Whisky Bar · 3 tips and reviews

Stephanie L.Stephanie Livingston: Great service. Great booze helpful bartenders

mishee d.mishee dee: Great cocktail list, bartenders and small plates menu, did I mention - SHUFFLEBOARD!!

Jeff H.Jeff Hendrickson: Cool spot, Fig Manhattans, and Shuffleboard! Awesome selection of whiskeys to boot. I guess it’s also a plus that it’s two blocks from my place 👍🏼

Palle by Moretti is one of The 9 Best Places for New York Cheesecake in Columbus.

4. Palle by Moretti

1021 West 5th Ave., Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 4 tips and reviews

Ashley B.Ashley B: So. Many. Meatballs! Get 'em on pasta, polenta or a sandwich. Vegetarian, too.

Jeff M.Jeff McGuire: The made from scratch tots are awesome!

Alisha S.Alisha Skeel: Is everything an answer? The cheese Gouda sauce is a beautiful things.

Peking Dynasty is one of The 9 Best Places for New York Cheesecake in Columbus.

5. Peking Dynasty

7.7
2210 E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH
Asian Restaurant · 18 tips and reviews

Nate L.Nate Lockwood: On Saturday nights they have a live reggae band play. Interesting combination of cultures, but makes for a great time!

Grace M.Grace Moore: If you're a Capital Student, get the "Cap Special!" So good!

hallie h.hallie harris: Try the egg foo yung!

Katzinger's Delicatessen is one of The 9 Best Places for New York Cheesecake in Columbus.

6. Katzinger's Delicatessen

8.7
475 S 3rd St (at E. Livingston Ave.), Columbus, OH
Deli · German Village · 93 tips and reviews

Jeremiah C.Jeremiah Cosner: Corned beef is to dye for. Great bread too. I always make sure to get a matzoball.

easyColumbuseasyColumbus: Try Katzinger's famous Reuben - and don't forget the free pickles! Nothing better than getting pickles out of a barrel.

Sam M.Sam Murphy: Everything here is yummy but my fave is the chicken salad sandwich (#67?)

Milestone 229 is one of The 9 Best Places for New York Cheesecake in Columbus.

7. Milestone 229

8.2
229 Civic Center Dr (Rich Street), Columbus, OH
American Restaurant · 80 tips and reviews

tabitha k.tabitha kunsman: mimosas are fabulous. great patio. awesome & friendly bartenders.

Jonida B.Jonida Bega: Tried the hummus and seafood stew. Both incredible!

Jonathan P.Jonathan Poma: Ignore the tip about poor hostess planning. Don't let one bad apple spoil the bunch. Seated us plenty early.

Lemongrass Fusion Bistro is one of The 9 Best Places for New York Cheesecake in Columbus.

8. Lemongrass Fusion Bistro

7.5
641 N High St (at W. Russell St.), Columbus, OH
Asian Restaurant · 47 tips and reviews

Anya H.Anya Herbert: Shiitake seared tuna steak over rice noodles instead.. gluten free and yummy!

Alissa B.Alissa Brunelli: Fuck yeah Anya!

Shannon Z.Shannon Ziegler: Get a Pom pon from Anya! She's the best bartender!!! We come see her every year

Verdi Restaurant & Pizzeria is one of The 9 Best Places for New York Cheesecake in Columbus.

9. Verdi Restaurant & Pizzeria

6.9
7770 Olentangy River Rd, Columbus, OH
Italian Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

Patrick S.Patrick S: Good pizza, excellent pasta dishes. The shrimp scampi is a must try.

Randall G.Randall G.: We stopped after a soccer game for a late evening family meal. The food was so good! We highly recommend the meatballs and manicotti!

Bill B.Bill Bartelt: Chicken parm and lasagna.